Asthma-Causing Toxins in Children’s Supplements

A number of case-control studies have found that giving kids cod liver oil supplements may increase their risk of asthma later in life. Case-control studies are done by asking about past behavior in cases (those with asthma) versus controls (those without asthma) to see if certain past behaviors are more likely among the disease group. The problem is that asking people to remember what they were doing years ago, when most people canít remember what they had for breakfast last week, is unreliable. When interpreting the results from case-control studies, we also canít rule out something called reverse causation. Maybe cod liver oil doesnít lead to asthma, but asthma led to the use of cod liver oil.

It would therefore be nice to see a cohort study. In a cohort study, researchers would take people without asthma and follow them over time to see if those taking cod liver oil are more likely to develop it. Because people without the disease are followed over time, cohort studies bypass the problems of recall bias and reverse causation.

In 2013, we finally got one such study. 17,000 people free of asthma were followed over 11 years. Researchers knew who was taking cod liver oil and who wasnít, and then sat back and watched to see who got asthma over the subsequent 11 years. The researchers †found that cod liver oil intake was indeed significantly associated with the development of asthma. They thought it might be the excessive vitamin A in the cod liver oil that was causing the problem, but there are also a number of substances in fish oil we may not want our children exposed to.

Researchers from Philadelphia University recently looked at 13 over-the-counter childrenís dietary supplements containing fish oil to assess potential exposure to PCBs, toxic industrial pollutants that have contaminated our oceans. PCBs were detected in all products. Could we just stick to the supplements made from small, short-lived fish like anchovies instead of big predator fish like tuna to reduce the impact of biomagnification? Or use purified fish oils?† No, the researchers found no significant difference in PCB levels whether the supplements were labeled as molecularly distilled or how high up the food chain the fish were.

The researchers concluded that while childrenís dietary supplements containing the long-chain omega-3ís from fish oils may claim to benefit young consumers, ďdaily ingestion of these products may provide a vector for contaminant exposure that may off-set the positive health effects.Ē What positive health benefits are they talking about?

Researchers publishing in the journal, Early Human Development, found that infants given DHA-fortified formula may have better development of their eyes and brains compared to infants getting non DHA-fortified formula. What was the source of the DHA? Not fish, but algae-derived DHA. We can get the benefits of omega 3ís without the contaminant risks. But of course, breast milk is the gold standard, significantly better than either of the formula fed infants. So the best source of omega-3ís is mom.

Itís bad enough when supplement manufacturers exploit adults when theyíre sick and vulnerable with pills that are often useless or worse, but taking advantage of our parental drive to do whatís best for our children with contaminated products that may make them sick, makes me sick.

In health,
Michael Greger, M.D.

PS: If you havenít yet, you can subscribe to my free videos†here†and watch my live year-in-review presentations†Uprooting the Leading Causes of Death,†More Than an Apple a Day, and†From Table to Able.

Related
Is Fish Oil Just Snake Oil?
Fish Intake Associated With Brain Shrinkage
Mad Fish Disease

 

55 comments

Siyus Copetallus
Siyus Copetallus3 years ago

Thank you for sharing.

SEND
Angela AWAY
Angela K3 years ago

Thanks for sharing

SEND
Melissa DogLover
Melissa DogLover3 years ago

noted.

SEND
John B.
John B3 years ago

Thanks Dr. Greger for sharing the info and relevant links to the research and studies.

SEND
Paulinha Russell
Paulinha Russell3 years ago

Thank you

SEND
Carol S.
Carol S3 years ago

We need to stop polluting the oceans!!!!

SEND
Teresa W.
Teresa W3 years ago

scary

SEND
K b.
Kai Bach3 years ago

TYFS !!!

SEND
K b.
Kai Bach3 years ago

Interesting read. Appreciate you sharing this with us :)

SEND
Jp Jp
Jp Jp3 years ago

ty

SEND