START A PETITION37,000,000 members: the world's largest community for good
Group Discussions
  Surprise Me
| track thread
« Back to topics
Would You Rent Your Car Out While Not Driving It?
6 years ago
| Surprise Me

Since its launch in 2000, Zipcar has shaken up the car rental market and grown to include more than 550,000 members in the United States, Canada, and the United Kingdom. Its main selling points? The ability to reserve vehicles by the hour instead of by the day and the convenience of pickup locations all over major metropolitan areas. Similar services now include the nonprofits CityCarShare, I-Go Carsharing, and e-Go Carshare.


Now, new services are taking this model a step further. Instead of using a fleet of Zipcars, RelayRides, WhipCar, Spride Share, and Getaround allow car owners to rent out their vehicles to their neighbors when they’re not in use.

“Economically, it makes a ton of sense for both sides,” says Shelby Clark, the chief executive officer of RelayRides, which currently operates in Boston and San Francisco. “People underestimate how much it costs to own and maintain a vehicle.” AAA’s 2010 “Your Driving Costs” study revealed that that the owners of average-sized sedans spend more than $8,000 a year to own and operate their vehicle. Minivan owners spend more than $9,000 a year!


These sites allow car owners to offset some of these costs through rental fees. Owners get pricing guidelines based on their car’s year, condition, location, and other factors, but they ultimately set the hourly rate themselves.

For car renters, those rates can sometimes be lower than services like Zipcar. Tom Wright, cofounder of the UK-based WhipCar, says borrowers are motivated by cost and environmental factors. “Since they can use cars that are affordable and close to them, it doesn’t require extra cars and allows them to make better use of existing assets,” he says.


Many borrowers also appreciate that their money is going to a neighbor instead of a company, says Clark. Many of RelayRides’ car owners also offer special features like GPS, bike racks, CD collections, or even homemade cookies left in their vehicles.


But do the savings outweigh the safety and insurance risks?

As you can imagine, screening drivers and vehicles is a high priority for all of these sites. Wright says WhipCar conducts three-way conference calls with driving applicants and the DVLA (Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency, the UK equivalent of the RMV) to ensure that the person has a spotless driving record. WhipCar also requires that vehicles be no older than eight years and checks if the vehicle has been stolen or involved in accident. Other sites have similar policies, and some allow the owner and the driver to rate the experience afterwards based on the caliber of the vehicle and the driver.

Like Zipcar, peer-to-peer car sharing sites bear the cost of gas and auto insurance. In the case of RelayRides, drivers over the age of 21 are insured by RelayRides’ $1 million liability insurance policy but are liable for a $500 deductible (Clark says this ensures that they treat vehicles as their own). Drivers are also responsible for paying any parking or traffic tickets issued during their rental period. Getaround has very similar insurance policies.


Though car owners are not liable for accidents that occur while their car is being rented, some auto insurance companies are squeamish about personal car sharing. But state legislatures are, in some cases, taking the side of the consumer: California recently passed a bill on car sharing that makes it illegal for auto insurance companies to void the policies of car owners who rent out their vehicles. The state of Oregon is considering a similar bill.

Car owners outside of California and Oregon would be wise to check their auto insurance policy before renting out their vehicle. However, with growing environmental and cost concerns associated with cars, other states may pass car sharing legislation in the future.


Clark sees this as just one example of the sharing economy. “Society is increasing rejecting traditional forms for ownership,” he says, pointing to Netflix as an example. “In the nineties, everyone had these giant bookcases of VHS tapes. But at the end of the day, I didn’t really want to own all these movies, I just wanted to watch them. It makes sense to access that movie whenever you need it. The global economic crisis has forced people to take a step back, and realize that ownership might not make sense.”

6 years ago

It costs me about $2,000/year to operate my car and that's averaging out repairs we've had since we bought it, but not including maintenance, which is a few oil changes per year, and every four years or so a new set of tires.  It also does not incluce car payments because it's paid for (thank God).


Would I rent out my car?  No way.  I've seen what people do to rental cars


6 years ago way!   I don't want strangers in my personal automobile!

6 years ago

I'm thinking while it may not be for everyone, it does provide alternatives to both car owners and renters..

6 years ago

I'm sure that there are those who find this useful, but I wouldn't rent my car to anyone.


When I was living in New York, my s-i-l used my car a lot to get her to work and home in the hospital where she was doing her medical residency.  One day she was driving in, and was hit by a car that didn't even stop for a red light.  Luckily, it was hit on the passenger side, so she wasn't hurt.  It was hit so hard that it was actually shaped like a kidney bean.


The insurance company totaled the car.  Luckily, I had just inherited some money, so I paid for the new car in full.  However, my s-i-l was just driver in the car - she had no liability, and didn't have the money to help at the I had to bear the full cost.


Rent out my car?  Never ever ever!

6 years ago

Its a good idea - just like you can swap homes for vacations with people but I have a 5 year old and my car shows it - I would be too embarrassed to allow anyone to see the inside. 

6 years ago

I believe our automobiles, because they are all expensive to maintain, are hard to share.   I couldn't bring myself to do it.   If I had to trim my expenses, it wouldn't start with my car LOL!

This thread is archived. To reply to it you must re-activate it.

New to Care2? Start Here.