START A PETITION 25,136,189 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x
1,267,637 people care about Politics

90-Year-Old Veteran Speaks Out Against War

90-Year-Old Veteran Speaks Out Against War

Every November, poppies begin adorning political lapels and pop-up stands selling them appear in the doorways of post offices and other public buildings. They’re meant to serve as a reminder of the sacrifices of the military, and it’s not uncommon to see them worn by veterans, but one 90-year-old World War II veteran says he won’t be wearing his anymore.

His blistering opinion piece for The Guardian articulates the shift from an important cultural symbol reminding people of the terrible cost of war to something much darker, and he argues that the poppy has become too corrupt for him to wear with pride.

The poppy has been a symbol of remembrance since 1920, when it was added to Remembrance Day events commemorating the end of the First World War. Inspired by “In Flanders Fields,” a poem which makes numerous allusions to the red poppies growing over the bodies of the dead, poppies are an important part of events in the United Kingdom, Canada and various Commonwealth countries as well as the United States. Here in the United States, for example, they’re sold and the funds provide money for veterans’ services.

In this opinion piece, Harry Leslie Smith says: “I will no longer allow my obligation as a veteran to remember those who died in the great wars to be co-opted by current or former politicians to justify our folly in Iraq, our morally dubious war on terror and our elimination of one’s right to privacy.”

In an era of seemingly constant war paired with growing restrictions on civil liberties in the UK and abroad, Smith’s words are both searing and timely. He points out that war is heinous and terrible, and that it’s usually fought by the lowest classes of society, those least able to seek alternatives to the military. He fears growing nationalism in the United Kingdom, and argues that the festivities planned to commemorate the 1914 anniversary of the start of the First World War are nothing short of ghoulish.

All of his points are strongly made for an era when war is heavily glorified and often discussed in the media as something with minimal costs. Today, military forces are much smaller, and do much more of their work from a very remote distance; it’s possible to kill thousands of people by launching weapons from ships or aircraft far from the battlefield, or even to pilot a drone in the Middle East from a military installation in the United States. War features heavily in video games and other entertainment, while the military continues to prey on low-income people and those in disadvantaged social groups looking for opportunities and desperate for a way out.

Remembrance Day has shifted over the almost 100 years from its creation; at one time, it was a sombre opportunity to reflect on the lives lost and the high burden of a war that touched many people very directly. Today, it’s become an opportunity for sales at department stores and motivational political speeches, many of which, Smith argues, serve to remind people of a nebulous threat that requires sacrifices to civil liberties and independence.

His piece also makes a sharp point about the emergence of the middle class after the Second World War, and the battles fought on domestic soil to provide more opportunities to everyday Britons (and Americans, across the pond). He argues that a larger political theme overlies the commercialization of war: a theme of austerity and ignoring the walking wounded at home, many of whom are in urgent need of aid.

His fiery response to the poppy tradition serves as a reminder that many veterans, especially older veterans who hold a symbolic value because of the passing of their generation, find themselves used as tools by their governments. His refusal of such a role in such a public forum attracted more than 1,500 comments within a matter of days, and struck a deep chord with many readers in a nation facing harsh austerity measures, growing civil unrest and vast intrusions on civil liberties. Could Harry Leslie Smith have sparked a revolt?

Read more: , ,

Photo credit: tim_d via flickr.

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it

86 comments

+ add your own
10:09PM PST on Dec 13, 2013

ty

11:36AM PST on Nov 19, 2013

Linda M.: That's not QUITE true. War WILL end, but not until EVERY SINGLE LAST ONE OF US HUMANS IS DEAD!

1:40AM PST on Nov 16, 2013

I utterly despise war, and am always sad when I read the uninformed writing about how glad the military is there "to keep us safe". I honestly don't think that the very poor Afghanis or Iraquis or the Vietnamese had any designs on America. By now I would imagine they'd all rather forget they'd ever heard of it.
However . . . . . . . . I have every sympathy for the soldiers who go and have to follow orders, which I'm sure they do to the best of their ability. Some of them are frighteningly young - well, many of them are - and I know that some of them escape poverty-stricken conditions by joining one of the Armed Forces. Along with all the glorification and flag-waving comes the time for the soldiers to pay for their time in the Armed Forces - they come back injured physically, and some of them are absolutely gutted mentally. So many of them end up on the streets, and the suicide rate among them goes up by leaps and bounds. They don't seem to have enough of anything, including true respect from the people they "thought" they were saving from something or another. Some beg in the streets, some wander homeless, with mental illnesses and no-one to care for them, and some come home to people who can't cope with their sorrow, and the way they behave at times. And another home is split apart by the uncaring way returned soldiers are treated by their country. They don't need backs turned on them, but they DO need people to treat their sickness, be it physical or mental, and

3:57AM PST on Nov 15, 2013

War has NEVER done ANYTHING good for ANYONE except for those in Power (or behind the power). They got more MONEY = POWER = CONTROL

8:12PM PST on Nov 13, 2013

I have become friends with a gentleman in my apartment complex who served in the Viet nam war.
We have spent many hours talking about his involvement in that war ,how unpopular it was and effect it had on him and so many others.
I saw the war in Viet Nam DESTROY my older brother.
Not only the horror of being a Marine ,19 years old and what was known as a "grunt" .
He was in the ground troop division and saw the war first hand.
But it was his treatment back home when he was on leave for 30 days that I found appalling and unforgivable.
Those of you may have heard about them being spat upon called baby killers and other reprehensible things cannot imagine how difficult it was for me to see it first hand.
I was with him ever day he was home.
Once we were going to,the store and there were war protesters lining a very busy street where we lived.
He wore his uniform whoever he went ,proud to be a part of the Corps.
After about a week he stopped wearing it ,he started to feel shamed.
What a sorrowful day when a former member of the military is made to,feel the way this gentleman does.
I proud to be an American and live in a country where I am free because of the sacrifice of these brave men and women who have given each of ius throughout the world the liberties we enjoy.

10:30AM PST on Nov 13, 2013

ty

12:50AM PST on Nov 13, 2013

Brave man to speak up. But will anyone listen?

11:52PM PST on Nov 12, 2013

kudos to him for speaking up - I hadn't given it a thought until now.

8:35PM PST on Nov 12, 2013

Yes, our veterans definitely deserve so much better...

7:14PM PST on Nov 12, 2013

Well said Mr. Smith

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

ads keep care2 free

Recent Comments from Causes

I dedicated a lifetime to treatment of seriously mentally ill. In simplistic terms if we know genes…

We register all voters in Missouri as they apply for either a drivers' license or state ID card. If…

Story idea? Want to blog? Contact the editors!
ads keep care2 free



Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.