START A PETITION 25,136,189 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x
1,765,790 people care about Human Rights

A “Brothel” For the Disabled?

A “Brothel” For the Disabled?

A former British “madam,” Becky Adams, is planning to open a nonprofit that would be a “brothel” for individuals with physical and intellectual disabilities, men and women, gay, straight and transsexual. It’s a controversial idea that raises numerous concerns including safety, not to mention the legal issues surrounding prostitution.

Adams is described as “one of Britain’s top madams” or rather ex-madams, as she sold a chain of illegal sex houses in 2009 after twenty years. She is no stranger to controversy, having sparked plenty of outrage when she said she would not mind if her own daughter becoming a prostitute. As she says,

Some people will think this is wrong. Sex work polarises opinion. Disability is also an old taboo. Sex workers and disabled people are alike in that they are both vulnerable and have very little voice in society. No-one ever listens to them.

Alexander Freeman, an American man who has cerebral palsy, echoes Adams’ words, saying that “If we are denied our right to sensuality, we are denied being human.” Freeman has made a documentary on the topic of intimacy and relationships, The Last Taboo, with interviews by six individuals with different physical disabilities and the able-bodied partner of one.

Bringing up the topic of sex and disability can itself make a conversation “stifling,” as Bethany Stevens, who was born with brittle bone disease and teaches at the Center for Leadership in Disability at Georgia State University, says to ABC News. Noting that individuals with disabilities can “trigger [a] lot of discomfort and fear” simply by their presence Steven notes that, when she and her (able-bodied) husband are in public together and express affection, they are “socially erased.”

Using Public Funds To Pay For Sex

Currently Adams runs a nonprofit telephone-based service, Para Doxies — the name evokes an old British term for prostitute — whose volunteers provide individuals with disabilities or those who care for them with information about finding “trust worthy, reliable sex workers, enablers or body-workers.” The mothers of some young men on the autism spectrum have been among Adams’ clients as has a soldier who was paralyzed from the neck down after serving in Afghanistan and now lives with his parents.

Madam – Prostitutes, Punters & Puppets, Adams’ memoir about her years in the sex trade — not only won the Brit Writers Award in 2012, but an Erotic Award by a U.K. organization, Outsiders, a organization for individuals with disabilities whose stated mission is “living life to the full.” In Britain, it is legal for two people to exchange money for sex, but illegal if a third party is involved. The planned facility — for which Adams has yet to receive a permit — will have elevators and other accommodations for individuals with physical disabilities.

Adams’ planned facility will be a nonprofit so injured soldiers and others may use social service benefits to pay, says The Sun. In Holland, individuals with disabilities can receive public funds to pay for sexual relations up to twelve times a year. Chris Fulton, a British man with cerebral palsy and muscular dystrophy, has been urging U.K. authorities to have a similar policy and “do more to help disabled people pay for prostitutes.”

But other disability advocates including the group Disabled Rights UK have said that pushing to use public money to pay for sex is “not considered a priority.”

I think it’s fair to say there would be an absolute uproar if such a use of public money was even mentioned in the US!

Sex and Disability: A Very Delicate, But Important Topic

As a parent of a teenage son on the severer end of the autism spectrum, I’ll admit that issues of sexuality are difficult to address. My son has intellectual disabilities and “sex education” has generally been about issues of safety and “sanitation.” “Hormones” have occasionally been mentioned as a possible reason for times when Charlie seems in an agitated mood. Recalling my own less than happy adolescence and my struggle to explain how I felt, I have to think how more challenging it is for Charlie, who can communicate with only a few words.

I anticipate such feelings and needs remaining an issue as he becomes an adult; how to address them is not something anyone yet has an answer for. I’m not sure Adams’ facility is a solution for all, but it certainly raises the issue, as does a recent movie, The Sessions, in which a man with polio loses his virginity.

The topic of sex and disability is one that we have yet as a society to figure out how to approach. One reason is that, according to research cited by Stevens of George State University, those with disabilities are often viewed as “not full people — sort of suspended in childhood” and, therefore, “non-sexual or desexualized.”

Any debate about Adams’ proposed “brothel” for individuals with disabilities reminds us that, yes, children with disabilities grow up into adults with disabilities. While always taking care that those who are vulnerable are not taken advantage of or have their safety and health compromised, we need to acknowledge that, as adults, their needs change and evolve, and to learn how we might best support them.

 

Related Care2 Coverage

Rape of the Disabled: The Issue No One Wants to Discuss

Abortion For Disabled Woman? Judge to Decide

‘My Disabled Grandchild is a Punishment for My Abortion’

 

Read more: , , , ,

Photo from Thinkstock

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it

154 comments

+ add your own
2:18PM PDT on Jul 27, 2013

It's not the oldest profession by accident. Most of us have basic physical needs that make go crazy when they're not tended to, including the sensual. Whether it's right or wrong depends on the opinion in question.

5:59AM PST on Jan 31, 2013

unless, of course that is the "thing", we are talking about people who have a hard time "batting the eyelashes" and attracting a "mate", even for a one night stand.

or again, it is an issue of people recoiling in revultion, your untouchables like http://www.nature.com/ng/journal/v44/n8/full/ng.2332.html.

at least someone is going to "make love" to them. if they do not have "a partner".

12:33AM PST on Jan 29, 2013

I've known a disabled girl (wheel chair bound, and needed help getting in and out of a car, and used both hands to hold a pen) who could get boyfriends w/ a few blinks of her eyes... Seriously. But, we aren't talking about these kind, we are talking about those who used to be part of the untouchables, back in the caste system.

3:05PM PST on Jan 28, 2013

i wonder if having a romance with "a big deal" can help my body dysmorphic disorder. I mean, if there was someone who only dated supermodles and wanted me. I feel sexier than them. but no. it is just like it's my job to date the person with 67 disorders

I still want to try the first. maybe if I take those sexy classes.

5:50AM PST on Jan 25, 2013

maybe there will be a cut off. maybe not. you need to give everyone sex or they are not full people, or feel less. that is why it exists.

http://www.down-syndrome.org/practice/330/ even they can be little horndogs.

7:08PM PST on Jan 24, 2013

Really, a brothel for people with dissabilities? Might be okay if the dissabilities were only physical, but for someone with mental issues, such as the mental capabilities of a child, NO!!!
That in my opinion would be child rape. Thier bodies may be mature sexually but their minds are not. This would be so wrong!!!

2:58PM PST on Jan 24, 2013

I guess, Don, that you concur then that democrat women are in the group of mentally disabled along with democrat men...

2:33PM PST on Jan 24, 2013

There should be a law that Republican women must put in their time at brothels for the disabled. I kid. That would be cruel and unfair to the disabled.

12:46PM PST on Jan 24, 2013

You're right, of course it takes a special type of person and I don't think I am one of them. But when you talk about someone with mental development issues, etc. even if they are an 'adult' they are not necessarily desiring or capable of making the distinction or legal decision to have sex. So even in an adult's body, with the mind of a six or ten year old, it might be considered statutory rape whether the parent or guardian thinks it's what the person wants. And that is a very hard decision.

12:34PM PST on Jan 24, 2013

how many people posting here would do it. agian. I want answer.how many of you here would single out, and flirt with someone who doesn't have "an invisable illness".

like the link I put down about the mother with the son with Down Sydrome. how many of you would of "taken his virginity"?

talk big, but you won't do it either.

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

ads keep care2 free

meet our writers

Kristina Chew Kristina Chew teaches ancient Greek, Latin and Classics at Saint Peter's University in New Jersey.... more
Story idea? Want to blog? Contact the editors!
ads keep care2 free



Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.