Jim Stanek, who has worked as a station agent for BART (Bay Area Rapid Transit) for the past seven years, faces the loss of his job for giving $300 worth of tickets so a student could afford his commute to school. According to SFGate, 65-year-old Stanek gave a stack of paid, unused tickets (left behind by commuters) to the 16-year-old grandson of a friend, Lonnie Gordon. The boy’s father died last year and Gordon and his wife had stepped in to care for the teenager, a student in Herculaneum public schools.
But the teenage began to struggle in school and was suspended. Gordon and his wife sent him instead to Flex Academy in San Francisco, a tuition-free charter school. The teenager is a junior there now and has reportedly been doing much better. A round-trip ticket from the Pittsburg/Bay Point BART Station to San Francisco costs $11.00, about $200 a month and a significant expense for Gordon and his wife, both retirees.
As Gordon told SFGate, “It’s a real long commute, it’s a lot of trouble, but if it can keep him on the right track, that’s where I want him to go to school.” Stanek stepped in to help and gave the teenager the tickets, while knowing that it was against the rules — as BART spokesman Jim Allison puts it, “tickets are like cash to us.”
Stanek had to attend a personnel hearing today, April 20, and has been told that he may be forced to take early retirement. He indeed notes that he is not “unblemished,” “made a mistake” and “screwed up.” But he emphasizes that he gave the boy the tickets “not for profit – for benevolence, to help the kid.” As he says, “the penalty does not, to me, seem to be fitting the crime.”
Wouldn’t it be more of a crime for the teenager not to be attend a school where he has been successful, especially after significant troubles? Might not the boy’s needs be taken into account as extenuating circumstances and Stanek be allowed to keep his job — should not Stanek’s giving the teenager the tickets be seen as an attempt to keep a potentially at-risk young person on the right track?
Related Care2 Coverage
Photo by mattyturner
Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may
not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.
Problem on this page? Briefly let us know what isn't working for you and we'll try to make it right!