START A PETITION 25,136,189 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x
767,244 people care about Education

Anti-Semitism, Racism, Communism: Everything You Didn’t Know About the Smurfs And Were Afraid to Ask (VIDEO)

Anti-Semitism, Racism, Communism: Everything You Didn’t Know About the Smurfs And Were Afraid to Ask (VIDEO)

It can’t smurfing be!

A new book Le petit livre bleu (The little blue book) claims that the Smurfs, those sarsaparailla-eating little blue denizens of Smurf village who talk about smurfing this and smurfing that, are anti-Semitic and racist. This, on top of earlier claims that, due to their living in a cooperative-like environment where everybody contributes to Smurf society, the Smurfs are communists, “Small Men Under Red Force,” as one American critic says.

The author of the book, Antoine Buéno, a lecturer at Sciences Po university in Paris, says in the Guardian that he’s been surprised at the “hyper violent” reaction to his claims among Smurf fans, some of whom have said he has “paranoid delusions” and is a “dream breaker.” Some more unhappy Smurf devotee critique via the Telegraph:

“What a disgrace to soil the legends of our childhood,” wrote Bibouille on the “Schtroumpfmania” website.

Another, called Anastasia wrote: “It’s not hard to find anti-Semitism in Shakespeare or Balzac.” The author’s arguments spring “from his own obsessions … the hooked nose of a wizard is neither Jewish nor Goy, it’s a traditional for wizards,” she wrote.

Buéno has indeed said he has “feared for his physical safety and insisted he meant no harm,” according to the Telegraph.

So what’s causing the big smurf-roar?

Belgian artist Peyo, whose real name was Thierry Culliford, created the Smurfs in 1958. Since their original appearance in comics, there have been animated films, a TV series, all manner of merchandise, theme parks, video games, an Ice Capades show; Sony is to release the first of three live-action/computer generated Smurf films on July 29. Buéno’s critique starts with Peyo’s very first work which was title The Black Smurfs in French and retitled The Purple Smurfs in English on the grounds of political correctness:

In the story, a Smurf gets stung by a black fly that turns his skin jet black, drives him insane and deprives him of speech. Soon the entire village has changed colour.

Mr Buéno said the story was clearly racist, as when the Smurfs turn black, “they are reduced to the state of primitives who get around by jumping and crying: ‘Gnap! Gnap!’”

“They lose all trace of intelligence and become completely moronic,” said Mr Buéno, also a speech writer for François Bayrou, the leader of the centrist Modem party.

“It’s roughly the way Africans were viewed by white colonisers in the 19th century.”

Mr Buéno also contends that The Smurfs’ arch-enemy, the wizard Gargamel, comes across as a classic anti-Semitic caricature of a money-grabbing Jew, the book claims. “Gargamel is ugly, dirty, with a hooked nose (who) is fascinated by gold”.

Culliford’s son Thierry Culliford has said in the French paper L’Express that his father “absolutely was not interested in politics” and that Buéno’s book is “situated between the grotesque and the not very serious.”

To some degree, I’m wondering at all the outcries about Buéno’s book. Academics, and people and general, are forever analyzing children’s literature and shows and toys for their “subliminal” messages. Many have, for instance, criticized the PBS show Teletubbies for its fascist overtones (the Teletubbies all go running dutifully to hear whatever a huge microphone that comes out of the ground commands), not to mention for the big purple Teletubby Tinky-Winky being (said some) gay (his ”favorite thing” is a red purse). I won’t even get started about some of the weird undertones about the shows with another large purple character, Barney.

Should we just let children’s shows and books be, or is it helpful to take heed about their “deeper messages”?

Though now that you mention it, what was going on with the Peanuts’ character Marcie calling Peppermint Patty “Sir”?

Below is a video showing Gargamel and the Smurfs.

 

Read more: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Photo by It's Meng!.

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it

46 comments

+ add your own
6:28PM PST on Jan 17, 2012

People are reading TOO much into something that is not meant to be thought too much about.

4:19PM PDT on Oct 11, 2011

Get over it Smurf fans. It's a stupid cartoon to begin with. I never understood its popularity.

4:46PM PDT on Aug 21, 2011

Enough!

6:32AM PDT on Jul 28, 2011

Smurfs lived in a kibbutz, an Israeli invention, thus how could Smurfs be anti-Semitic ;-)?! I loved watching Smurfs with my kids and had never observed anything racist, antisemitic or inappropriate, or otherwise would have not let my kids watch it.

Smurfs was a great show and those people who are looking for non-existing things in them should apply their imagination on creating something as good as Smurfs were, rather then dissing them ;-)!

5:11PM PDT on Jul 27, 2011

When you impugn adult themes or motives to children's shows, of course you'll get something absurd or obscene - garbage in, garbage out.

For example the Smurfs must surely have been polyandrous - unless Papa Smurf had exclusive rights to Smurfette. And Peppermint Patty has been described as gay, by adults reading their own motives into a cartoon for kids.

Charles Schultz was a very old-fashioned, conservative guy and I'm sure he never intended Patty and Marcie to be vanguards of Lesbianism. Nothing wrong with that; but it shows the silliness of posthumous interpretations.

4:28PM PDT on Jun 13, 2011

You can make any interpretation the truth if you just try....

6:13PM PDT on Jun 12, 2011

The person who found all these disturbing things in a cartoon is the sick one. I loved the Smurfs as a kid and I didn't see any of those things,go figure.It was just fun to watch.Come on.

10:55AM PDT on Jun 10, 2011

Ohh come on this is as stupid as the people who complained about Mr. Rogers,telletubbies, and Sesame street. Get a life.

9:34PM PDT on Jun 8, 2011

Mr. Buéno needs to do two things.

1) Learn that the Spanish word Bueno is spelled without an accent mark

2) Get a life

6:39PM PDT on Jun 8, 2011

Et, vous ne trouvez pas que leurs chapeaux ressemblent à ceux des membres du KKK? Et le Grand Schtroumpf, alors, c'est qui? C'est leur Grand Dragon?

Jokes aside, I loved the smurfs, as toys, books and movies. I passed the toys and books on to my kids, for another generation of fun in blue.

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Care2 - Be Extraordinary - Start a Care2 Petition
ads keep care2 free
CONTACT THE EDITORS

Recent Comments from Causes

What's in heir minds....Planet is dying ...soon it will be our turn... even though I believe it has …

We need to find out who owns the US Forest Service, then find out if they paid the proper fees and then…

meet our writers

Kristina Chew Kristina Chew teaches and writes about ancient Greek and Latin and is Online Advocacy and Marketing... more
ads keep care2 free



Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.