START A PETITION 27,000,000 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x
1,800,105 people care about Human Rights

Are Religious People Less Compassionate?

Are Religious People Less Compassionate?
  • 1 of 2

Why are highly religious people are lesslikely to be moved by compassion than atheists, agnostics, and people who are religiously unaffiliated?  After all, charity is a central tenet of most religious traditions. But, according to a new study from scientists at the University of California, Berkeley, that fact may be exactly why highly religious people are least likely to be moved by compassion.

In a series of experiments, the scientists found that nonreligious people were consistently compelled toward acts of generosity by feelings of compassion. According to the study’s news release, compassion is defined as “an emotion felt when people see the suffering of others which then motivates them to help, often at a personal risk or cost.” By contrast, for people who were rated “highly religious” on an unidentified religiosity scale (the full article is behind a firewall), compassion had no impact on their levels of generosity. This finding is especially interesting in light of recent evidence showing that the highly religious are less likely to think analytically.

A moral obligation

This report, however, does not mean that highly religious people are, in general, less compassionate. But it does unseat a fundamental assumption about acts of generosity or charity: that is, that these acts are motivated by feelings of empathy and compassion. That appears to be true for people who are non-religious, but for the highly religious, generosity appears to be more connected to a sense of moral obligation.

Laura Saslow, the study’s lead author said that she was inspired to undertake the study after a nonreligious friend told her that “he had only donated to earthquake recovery efforts in Haiti after watching an emotionally stirring video of a woman being saved from the rubble, not because of a logical understanding that help was needed.”

In one of the experiments, subjects watched either a “neutral” or a “heartrending” video, and were then given 10 “lab dollars,” with the instruction to give any amount of that money to a stranger. The non-religious people who had watched the “heartrending” video were much more likely to give more of their money away.

  • 1 of 2

Read more: , , , , ,

quick poll

vote now!

Loading poll...

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it

148 comments

+ add your own
2:17PM PDT on Aug 18, 2012

i feel that a lot of religious people do good or donate because they are "supposed" to, and because some spiritual leader or book says they should. Non religious people don't get a reward, or have a spiritual reason to do good, we do it because it is the right thing to do, and because we realize there will be no "holy rescue". We are her for the long haul, and if we want there to be a difference, we have to make that happen. No magic being is going to save us, we have to save ourselves and look out for our own.

5:54AM PDT on May 12, 2012

Unfortunately, I found another reason to vote--Yes, here. At another sight, there was a post written by a self-professing 'Christian' who justified the treatment of the Native Americans as 'They were merely (heathens) so what ever happened to them--they deserved'
If only the Conservative Church weren't so busy judging, maybe just maybe they could notice that their heart has grown colder than ice from all their own judgments.

2:51PM PDT on May 11, 2012

Sarah H. Says:

"Religious people are not less compassionate. They may have a hard time tolerating differences but overall, they are benevolent and strive to be good at heart."

Not trying to be offensive Sarah, but what planet do you live on? Are you paying attention to what the Roman Catholic church is doing? Have you read about their "problems" with their nuns? Nuns who want to help the poor and downtroden instead of bashing glbt's and abortion rights for women the way the church says they should be doing? And this is Compassionate? Benevolent? I know that not all people of religion are this way, but it seems to me that there are too many who are.

6:19PM PDT on May 9, 2012

Interesting article. Thanks for sharing.

1:02PM PDT on May 9, 2012

I'm not at all sure that the answer implied in the article's title is the one shown by the research. It seems instead to show that religious people are more likely to give to any needy cause, whereas the non-religious need rather more prompting and more of a sense of return (what do I get out of giving).

6:07AM PDT on May 9, 2012

Thanks for the article.

5:02PM PDT on May 8, 2012

Please don't shout, Jane B. It's not necessary.

12:35PM PDT on May 8, 2012

I wound up converting from Methodist to Reconstructionist Jew because I found I could not really forgive Christians for bullying me into going through with Christian Confirmation when I told them that I objected to confirmation because I was more sure that lying under oath was morally wrong than I was that "God" even existed. What did Christians mean by "God", "Father", "Son" and "Holy Ghost" anyhow? Jews feel that "God" cares more how people act than what assortment of theological opinions they are willing to endorse. Christians just get too bogged down in details of theology. Why should solemnly swearing that you agree with your parents' denomination about theological opinions be Christianity's coming of age ceremony?

10:06AM PDT on May 8, 2012

The first EXCUSE Catholic/Christian/Nazi WHITE MEN can come up with is: WE'RE NOT ALL THAT WAY!!!! They search and search out of billions and find ONE ATHEIST and say SEE, HE'S JUST AS BAD!!!!! That is the LAMEST ARGUMENT on EARTH. At least 70% of Americans are CHRISTIANS or some splinter group of CHRISTIANS and they are the MAJORITY. Their FILTH has encompassed our GOVERNMENT LIKE AN OCTOPUS. BISHOPS are IN OUR CONGRESS LOBBYING AGAINST BIRTH CONTROL AND EXCLUDING WOMEN!!! Religions don't know the MEANING of COMPASSION, all they care about is PUSHING THEIR EVIL AGENDA!!! They're a MONEY GRUBBING BUNCH OF WAR MONGERERS. "COMPASSION" is when they DON'T SEND OUR CHILDREN TO HELL HOLES TO DIE FOR NOTHING!!!!! That has NEVER HAPPENED YET!!!! These Catholic/GOP Nazi pricks have teamed up to FORCE POOR WOMEN TO POP OUT MORE
CATHOLICS SO THEY WON'T GO BROKE and the GOP needs more BABIES FOR THEIR WAR MACHINE. Period.

9:37AM PDT on May 8, 2012

I do not think I agree with this article. I have known many people in my lifetime and the most charitable ones were the poorest. They were always the first to offer help when help was needed. Some of these people were very religious, some not at all. I do find though that now it is the older people I know who are the most charitable. They are also the poorest people I know.

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Care2 - Be Extraordinary - Start a Care2 Petition
ads keep care2 free
CONTACT THE EDITORS

Recent Comments from Causes

Surround yourself with positive, happy, people... And don't set goals for yourself, that are unattainable... Take…

meet our writers

Julie M. Rodriguez Julie M. Rodriguez is an arts, green living, and political writer based in San Mateo, CA. Her work... more
ads keep care2 free



Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.