START A PETITION 27,000,000 members: the world's largest community for good
1,002,016 people care about Education

Are Student-Teaching Programs Seriously Flawed?

Are Student-Teaching Programs Seriously Flawed?
  • 1 of 2


On July 21, the National Council on Teacher Quality released a report titled “Student Teaching in the United States,” which examined 134 student teaching programs across the country and concluded that three-quarters of them did not meet five basic standards for high quality.

Three-Quarters Of Programs Do Not Meet Standards

Specifically, the report concluded that the schools differed so widely in their curricula, methods of assessment, and graduation requirements that it was impossible to know with any degree of certainty if students were being well educated. Although powerful changes were transforming some schools, the outlook was utterly hopeless for two-thirds of them.

Schools of education are understandably furious at these findings, especially since the group plans to give them letter grades that would appear in U.S. News and World Report. When the U.S. News rankings are published, the student-teaching programs will count for one-fifth to one-third of an education school’s grade, according to Kate Walsh, president of the council.

A Lack Of Program Standards

From The New York Times:

“Many people would say student teaching is the most important piece of teacher preparation,” Ms. Walsh said. “But the field is really barren in the area of standards. The basic accrediting body doesn’t even have a standard for how long a student teacher needs to be in the classroom. And most of the institutions we reviewed do not do enough to screen the quality of the cooperating teacher the student will work with.”

Even if the findings are open to question, the fact is that student teaching is the single most valuable part of teacher preparation. So it seems like an excellent idea to ask what can be done to remove any doubts about the quality of existing programs.

Should Ed. Schools Be More Like Med. Schools?

Walt Gardner, writing in Education Week, suggests that schools of education should be more like medical schools in their approach to training, although he goes on to give various reasons why it’s impossible for this transformation to take place.

  • 1 of 2

Read more: , , , , ,

Photo Credit: breity via Creative Commons

quick poll

vote now!

Loading poll...

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it


+ add your own
5:56PM PDT on Aug 30, 2011

Wouldn't know...

4:56AM PDT on Jul 26, 2011

Thanks for the article.

3:18PM PDT on Jul 25, 2011

I can't imagine where these ineffective student teaching programs are. I was definitely on the hotplate for 6 weeks, constantly watched by the homeroom teachers, and with surprise visits from the program directors. On top of all the lesson plan writing, I had to put together a large portfolio of essays on education, powerpoints demonstrating how I would teach certain SOLs, samples of student work demonstrating the effectiveness of my teaching techniques, etc.

If the program was lacking in anything, it was not enough instruction on how to deal with "differently abled" students. Just because you read their IEP doesn't mean you know how to best teach kids with ADHD or autism, or emotional problems. We really, really need more classroom aides, so these kids can be integrated without derailing the lesson for the rest of the class.

11:29PM PDT on Jul 24, 2011

Hate to say it but being taught be student teachers is NOT easy for students. May be good for the student teachers but the students do suffer because of it.

5:16PM PDT on Jul 24, 2011

Good teaching colleges produce well-prepared student teachers, make sure that supervisors know what is expected of them and do an excellent job of sending out teachers who are ready to teach. National standards will not make that happen any more than No Child Left Behind makes better students. School districts need to put their feet down on what they expect.

3:29PM PDT on Jul 24, 2011

It would be good for juniors and seniors to spend more time in schools. As a Speech Pathology student, I worked with children and adults (closely supervised, of course) from my sophomore year through graduate school. We did 2 semesters of student teaching in addition to 5 years in hospitals and clinics. By the time I had my master's degree, I was well-equipped to work in any setting.

2:17PM PDT on Jul 24, 2011

I really like the idea of students teaching because it is a more relaxed atmosphere and pace. I think students can learn more. Just watch kids teach one another. I builds a sense of caring and mentoring.
The downfall is of course, no oversight to make sure of the quality.
Perhaps they should have a certification before becoming a student teacher and that would be a certification for each subject or a least an intensive test.
Our school system is so poor anymore as they have dropped the "3 R's" that give most students a solid beginning. Our Reading program has all but done away with reading anything worthwhile and their is little comprehension taught along with debate which helps build logical thinking and the art of listening.
America needs to ditch this "new" curriculum and get back to basics.

1:08PM PDT on Jul 24, 2011

When my son needed to move from the UK to the US, he found that the guaranteed way to walk into a job was to get a British teaching diploma. US schools are keen to hire foreign trained teachers because the US teaching certificate is worthless.

12:33PM PDT on Jul 24, 2011

I was in an alternative program. We got a summer of intense training plus teaching with supervision of a licensed teacher in a summer school plus additional teacher observers and district observers. Then we got assigned to the worst classrooms nobody wants. We did this while taking our classes at night towards a license. I had two mentors who came in at least 1 time per week (each one), plus more if needed, and quarterly visits from an observer. The last semester was "student teaching" after already being full-time teaching for a year and a half.

It may not be perfect, but what I liked is lots of support while you learn your way, and the college classes were a source of things to do immediately, and could be responsive to our needs as new teachers, not in some future-teacher theoretical way, but in a boots-on-the-ground OMG help me right now kind of way.

It was incredibly demanding, but I think the real experience with so much support/oversight is a real plus. This was not TFA. It is for people who plan to stay as educators for their career.

9:49AM PDT on Jul 24, 2011

It's a shame but not suprising.

add your comment

Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Care2 - Be Extraordinary - Start a Care2 Petition
ads keep care2 free

Recent Comments from Causes

The biggest problem is going to be that greedy hunters will do everything they can to disguise their…

meet our writers

Lindsay Spangler Lindsay Spangler is a Web Editor and Producer for Care2 Causes. A recent UCLA graduate, she lives in... more
ads keep care2 free

Select names from your address book   |   Help

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.

site feedback


Problem on this page? Briefly let us know what isn't working for you and we'll try to make it right!