START A PETITION 25,136,189 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x
925,178 people care about Women's Rights

Are Women in the U.S. Military Ready for the Frontline of War?

Are Women in the U.S. Military Ready for the Frontline of War?

In November 2013, history was made in the Marine Corps. For the first time, the graduating infantry class included three women who had endured a grueling nine week combat training course. They were the first women to do so as part of a Marine Corps pilot program that required women to meet the same minimum physical standards as men. Of the fifteen women that started with them, they were the only three to make it until the end.

Nevertheless, the three women are not bound for combat positions just yet.

In January of last year, the Department of Defense announced that the 1994 Combat Exclusion Rule, which restricted women from serving in frontline infantry, armor and special operations units, would be lifted. At Congress’ instruction, then Defense Secretary Leon Panetta instructed the services to develop plans for gender integration in combat roles, as well as a list of† positions that would be opened up to women. A January 2016 compliance deadline has been set.

Six months later, military officials began studies to determine the best methods of training and which roles, if any, should remain closed to women. The one point all military leaders agreed on, however, was that the requirements, including physical ones, were not going to be lowered for women. If they were going to be on the frontline with men, they had to make sure they could keep up.

The approaches toward meeting these gender-neutral goals reflect the uniqueness of the individual military branches.

The Marine Corps by nature is go hard or go home, which is exactly the way they began their training program. They sought volunteers interested in the program and put them directly into the infantry training programs, requiring them to meet the same minimum standards as men, though what was considered a perfect score differed slightly. After more than half of the women failed to reach even the minimum physical requirements, the Marine Corps has slowed down their timetable of having women in combat units by 2015. While no new timetable has been announced, they feel the delay is necessary to determine a new approach.

Some argue that its standards arenít the problem, itís the way women need to be trained. The Marines already have gender-specific boot camps, understanding that women need to take different approaches to reach the same goal.

The Army, however, has not put any women into combat training programs, choosing to first determine the physical requirements for specific combat roles. With a job-oriented focus, approximately 500 random soldiers from eight different brigades performed hundreds of tasks required in 31 specialties to create baseline requirements. They now have gender-neutral standards which will allow them to determine what specialties can be opened up to women.

While there are some combat jobs already opening up in other services such as the Navy, many question whether women should be part of ground forces.

When the announcement was made last January, Israelís Army, which has long been touted as the most gender integrated military force in the world, was seen as a guide. However, even though 92 percent of I.D.F. positions such as fighter pilots, infantry captains, and Humvee drivers are open to women, only 3 percent of them are held by women. Israel’s long history of women in combat has not made the idea of women killing and being killed any easier for its citizens to handle. Even if women are willing to volunteer, military structural resistance has made their appearance on the frontline limited.

Women being injured and killed in the more than decade long fronts in Iraq and Afghanistan has done little to change the minds of many Americans. Many soldiers, including women, believe that a ground war isnít a womanís place.

As Marine Captain Katie Petronio says, when it comes to combat, women are not created equal.

She agrees that some combat roles should definitely be opened up to the many capable female soldiers, but infantry should not be one of them. Her five years in service, including deployments to both Iraq and Afghanistan, have left her suffering much of the physical degradation that her male counterparts suffered, but at a much faster rate. Her 5 foot 3 inch frame is not the same as it once was, which at the beginning of her service would have probably allowed her to be one of the few women to pass the new minimum Corps requirements for infantry. The former college hockey player suffers from muscle degeneration, restless leg syndrome and non-hereditary infertility.

As she points out, there is no data on the effects the chemical, physical and mental demands of that frontline combat on women. As scientific studies of various diseases from AIDS to cancer have shown, women suffer the consequences of environmental stresses differently. This doesnít mean they are weaker or less qualified, it just means they are different.

When it comes to war, itís not about political correctness, itís about life and death.

She writes in the Marine Corps Gazette, ďThe bottom line is that the enemy doesnít discriminate, rounds will not slow down, and combat loads donít get any lighter, regardless of gender or capability. Even more so, the burden of command does not diminish for a male or female; a leader must gain the respect and trust of his/her Marines in combat. Not being able to physically execute to the standards already established at IOC, which have been battle tested and proven, will produce a slower operational speed and tempo resulting in increased time of exposure to enemy forces and a higher risk of combat injury or death.Ē

As women, weíve come a long wayÖbut is war really where we want to go?

Read more: , , ,

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it

129 comments

+ add your own
10:01AM PDT on May 18, 2014

Thank you

12:55PM PST on Mar 5, 2014

an open letter to the armed forces:

due to the world's unbeknownst participation in "the war on women," as well as to peoples' utmost tolerance of those who regard females as lesser people, men are held to a higher standard. from scholastic and college sports, to professional sports, men do not compete against women. there are separate (gender-based) bodybuilding competitions, gender-based hot-dog-eating competitions, etc, which always separate men from women, which always expect more of men, and this is a war on women which has to stop.

as a man who is expected to be capable of doing more than what a woman can do, i am denied entry into the armed forces because i am held to a higher standard on account of my gender. i am a man, i am taller and broader and stronger than the vast majority of females in the military, i can physically do anything a "strong" woman can do, and yet i am denied entry into the armed forces. i am a failure because more is expected of me...yet, if i merely had an egg-bleeding vagina (or a set of milk-spouting mammary glands), then my current physical ability would have granted me a place in the military.

i believe that if members of the shorter/smaller/weaker gender have their own set of physical requirements for the military only because they are pipsqueaks who cannot achieve as men can achieve, then a similar compensation should be given to the men who cannot meet the physical requirements for men.

like a bent-arm hang is no match

2:55AM PST on Feb 17, 2014

War is no one's place (many men die in war and it's bad for your personality and the world). War should be a last resort.
But if the woman knows what she's doing and is fit enough etc. then she can choose to risk her life. She won't be slower if she meets standards, is properly trained and experienced.
This article offends me.

4:52AM PST on Jan 24, 2014

Rainbow...that is my point...I don't want to hear it from Politicians..I don't want to search it on Google..WOW..4.5million items in 11 seconds..mind blowing..I want to hear it from real people..telling me how it really is...what will make a difference...I don't wear Rose-Coloured glasses..although I do have to admit my glasses are tinted...not tainted..I'm not a "Daydream Believer" and all that goes with that.. Anyway..this is all futile..have taken up far to much space..

4:32AM PST on Jan 24, 2014

"But I am still touched..and I smile when I read those words......Grandma called me Ohiyantuwei "rainbowwalker"..there is a reason..don't let it be lost."
I cannot be manipulated. I know you are trying to appeal to what you believe is my ego in an attempt at a passive jab.

Actually, Mama Crow called me that "with a heavy heart". The rainbow isn't a pretty symbol to Native Americans as it is in the west. It's like a sacred place, can be a doorway to death, the unknown."

No Rainbow..I don't appeal to your ego, in any way and we both know that...I too have been given a name that would not be normally given to a female..by my Grandmothers..an ancient name...and it's not pretty either...but at least some do try to pronounce it and then there are others that get it right or have heard it before..cont

8:36PM PST on Jan 23, 2014

All countries lie to their citizens, but does that mean the rhetoric coming from the opposing mouth contains truth? I am rational. I know war is a part of man. Maybe we'll evolve in a billion years, who knows. The only way to deal with illogic logically is to temper it down and know scope. Hopefully we can eliminate all ideology and use rational. Then war would only occur as a defense.

"WW1 was suppose to be the war that ended all wars"
And yet it didn't. It was a misnomer anyway.

"But I am still touched..and I smile when I read those words......Grandma called me Ohiyantuwei "rainbowwalker"..there is a reason..don't let it be lost."
I cannot be manipulated. I know you are trying to appeal to what you believe is my ego in an attempt at a passive jab.

Actually, Mama Crow called me that "with a heavy heart". The rainbow isn't a pretty symbol to Native Americans as it is in the west. It's like a sacred place, can be a doorway to death, the unknown.

"cont.. ust found a new cause..where us old campaigners could just do some good..."
I thought you didn't read links but you sure love posting crap.

8:35PM PST on Jan 23, 2014

"Rainbow...I am not your enemy...despite what you believe.."
I have no enemies. The mere fact that you are using that vernacular tells me you consider me yours.

"Yes, defend your Country by all means.. I would expect nothing less..."
More of that passive aggression. If you haven't noticed I don't defend nor condemn. I state fact. There's a difference between understanding a situation and supporting it. You equate military with war. That is a fraction of what we do. I was more proud of assisting capsized ships, dispersing food during disaster and seeing our men and women work with engineers, doctors, chemists and myriad others not to create weapons but to heal, construct and aid. It is the fact you were raised by hippies you only see the negative. But when a disaster strikes and that uniform is there with care, supplies and protection hippies sing a different tune. Then quickly forget that and throw more dog shit at us.

Yes they deny us our benefits and I fight against that. But I fight for ANYONE who does a job and doesn't get what they earned and contracted for.

"but I'm a realist too"
Actually, you're not. You see things from a limited angle and no other. War does form part of everyday life, you are just in a bubble and don't see. Killing is natural and there has hardly been a time in man's existence when there wasn't conflict. Peace is the anomaly. Everyone manipulates, even hippies [perhaps more so]. All countries lie to their citizens, but does that mean t

3:36AM PST on Jan 23, 2014

cont.. ust found a new cause..where us old campaigners could just do some good...

http://newsbusters.org/blogs/tom-blumer/2013/03/29/st-louis-post-dispatch-columnist-most-veterans-did-nothing-heroic-and-ar

3:01AM PST on Jan 23, 2014

Rainbow...I am not your enemy...despite what you believe...."Neither man or women should be sent to war..."Then who? Children, dogs or monkeys? Yes, defend your Country by all means.. I would expect nothing less....stand strong on your own shores....I have signed countless petitions, sent emails, etc to your Congress..re your treatment..they enlist you..they send you..it is their wars you are fighting not mine...the rhetoric is all that matters to them...it's a simple job creation scheme..and the manufacturing and sales figures excel...Why would they deny you what you are entitled to??...I certainly don't. Yes, I'm a hippy child..but I'm a realist too and if you are injured in the Workplace, which you were..then you are entitled to Workers Compensation, if I can see this..why can't Governments???? But as we have discussed before........War is different.........actions are sanctioned...it does not form part of everyday life...if there is a better way to get this message across please tell me...WW1 was suppose to be the war that ended all wars..maybe all us protesters have wasted our time..it probably doesn't make a difference..we really are just fooling ourselves..thinking that we do..You are right "I do protest to much...why should I care..I have never been to war..I'm not effected by war, it's not my problem if others have" But I am still touched..and I smile when I read those words......Grandma called me Ohiyantuwei "rainbowwalker"..there is a reason..don't let it be lost.

3:40PM PST on Jan 22, 2014

Many vets medical records [like mine] were destroyed; they use this as a excuse to deny benefits: if they cannot determine if it's service related or not they would just deny it. Took an act of Congress to change it.

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Story idea? Want to blog? Contact the editors!
ads keep care2 free

more from causes

Animal Welfare

Causes Canada

Causes UK

Children

Civil Rights

Education

Endangered Wildlife

Environment & Wildlife

Global Development

Global Warming

Health Policy

Human Rights

LGBT rights

Politics

Real Food

Trailblazers For Good

Women's Rights




Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.