START A PETITION 27,000,000 members: the world's largest community for good
1,311,370 people care about Civil Rights

Arizona’s SB 1070: A Civil Rights Fiasco

Arizona’s SB 1070: A Civil Rights Fiasco

by Erin Rosa, Media Consortium blogger

On Tuesday, the Department of Justice filed suit against the state of Arizona in an effort to overturn a stringent anti-immigration law passed in April. The move is a breath of fresh air for immigrant rights supporters. Democracy Now! and the Washington Independent have the story.

The suit will take on Arizona’s Senate Bill 1070, a law that requires local law enforcement to check an individual’s immigration status if there is “reasonable suspicion” that said individual is undocumented. The law has sparked national outrage and serious concerns that Latinos will be racially profiled by the police. Another provision of SB 1070 requires immigrants to carry papers denoting citizenship at all times while in the state.

Is SB 1070 unconstitutional?

At ColorLines, Daisy Hernandez reports that “the lawsuit, which was filed in a U.S. District Court in Phoenix, argues that it’s against the Constitution for a state to make its own immigration policy” because of “the legal doctrine of ‘preemption,’ which says that federal law trumps state statues.”

The key argument being that “the federal government already works with states to enforce federal immigration law,” so there’s no need for a law like SB 1070 to intervene, according to Hernandez.

A civil rights fiasco

Since April, the Arizona law has served as a rallying point for immigrant rights supporters, who refer to the bill as the “Juan Crow” law. The nickname references the Jim Crow laws that existed prior to the civil rights struggles of the 1960s.

Jessica Pieklo at Care2 notes that the DOJ suit “also contains a civil rights component and argues that the law would lead to law enforcement harassing U.S. citizens and lawful immigrants in efforts to hunt down undocumented workers.”

Citizens react

At New America Media, Valeria Fernández gauges immigrants’ and Arizona residents’ reactions to the suit.

“I really feel that the Justice Department will be on the winning side of history,” said Mary Rose Wilcox, a supervisor for District 5 in Maricopa County, AZ. “I think when justice needs to be served, you should never look at political costs.”

An undocumented immigrant named Griselda told Fernández that she “jumped for joy when she heard the news,” and “Thank God there’s another one in the fight.”

The immigration reform battle moves forward

Last week, President Barack Obama called for Congress to put politics aside and focus on immigration reform as quickly as possible. The speech and suit are fueling demand for comprehensive reform and it’s clear that the issue won’t be going away.

Yet despite the need for reform, there are roadblocks. As Paul Waldman writes for the American Prospect, “It’s true that there is little incentive for politicians to produce comprehensive reform. It’s guaranteed to displease much of the public, while there is a powerful incentive to play on people’s fears and resentments.”

However, there is hope in the organizing that’s being done by immigrant youth. Undocumented immigrant and student organizer Tania Unzueta said in an interview with In These Times that immigrants from across the country are risking deportation and incarceration to come “out of the shadows and into the spotlight.”

As Unzueta explains in the interview, “When you stop being afraid, there’s a whole world of possibilities in terms of how much risk you’re willing to take to fight for what you believe is just.”

This post features links to the best independent, progressive reporting about immigration by members of The Media Consortium. It is free to reprint.

Read more: , , , , , , , , , ,

Photo used under Creative Commons License via Flickr with thanks to Fibonacci Blue

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it


+ add your own
10:50AM PDT on Sep 19, 2012

Thank you.

10:50AM PDT on Sep 19, 2012

Thank you.

11:06AM PDT on Sep 6, 2010

Progressives, liberals, heck even some conservatives. It doesn't just go party lines. If they don't want to protect America and her Borders, Language, and Culture, they are the enemies of her.

10:28AM PDT on Sep 4, 2010

really so guess they where bsing when they threatened to lock me up cause i did not have mine on me and the one i had was expired i was a passanger in a vehicle.
tavis its more like progressives that are the problem

4:54PM PDT on Aug 31, 2010

Why is it that you liberals refuse to let Arizona protect its borders from the illegal, criminal scum from flooding across its borders? Arizona has every right to enforce this law, in truth, they are simply enforcing what the government is supposed to be doing.

Janice P. I salute you. Thank GOD that there are still some people with common sense.

Liberalism is a mental disorder, find a cure before it's too late...

6:17PM PDT on Aug 4, 2010

I asked two attorneys at work about Florida, they both are sure that it is not mandatory to always carry ID. In addition, they both stated that any local or state ordinance would be struck down as being unconstitutional. I also searched online and did not find any such law.

No mention of such law on the official Florida web site,

10:35AM PDT on Aug 4, 2010

roberto c
wow is you history distorted... go checkout you facts then try that one again. you must have slept throu history

10:34AM PDT on Aug 4, 2010

roberto c
wow is you history distorted... go checkout you facts then try that one again. you must have slept throu history

9:22PM PDT on Aug 3, 2010

What part of unconstitutional don't some of you get?for all those that are so anti immigration in reality we don't even belong here regarding of legal status we are all models for America the only people that should be here are Native Americans because they are Native to Americans and we are not let's not for get how our ancestors got here this nation was founded By mostly illegal immigration look during WW1 about 25 million of illegal immigrants came here nearly the double or triple we have let's not forget how our generation came here then us... and our roots so let's stop this nonsense then our ancestor's should've been turn back because they were undocumented but no they came here....and stayed

6:17PM PDT on Jul 26, 2010

Amnesty as the ONLY rational choice!

add your comment

Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Care2 - Be Extraordinary - Start a Care2 Petition
ads keep care2 free

Recent Comments from Causes

They do not understand what they are doing or they would not keep changing their minds on this. These…

Why Have Seven Black Churches Burned To The Ground? Preliminary answer: -- 2-lightning -- 1-tree…

ads keep care2 free

Select names from your address book   |   Help

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.