START A PETITION 25,136,189 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x
1,382,736 people care about Politics

Bear Attack Prompts the Question: Do We Kill Every Animal That Attacks a Human?

Bear Attack Prompts the Question: Do We Kill Every Animal That Attacks a Human?

In Italy, a man foraging for mushrooms was attacked when he happened upon a mother bear and her cubs. Part of a reintroduction and conservation program in Italy’s northern Dolomites, the bear, named Daniza, was ordered to be captured and possibly killed. This has sparked social media outrage, prompting those on twitter to hashtag #iostocondanzia (I’m with Danzia).

The outrage stems from a revelation that when mauling victim Daniele Maturi happened upon the bear, he did not immediately leave, but rather hid behind a tree to watch him. It is said the bear only charged when it spotted him watching from behind a tree (like a predator would do, thus provoking the bear).

One Italian columnist, Anna Lebedeva, shared her opinion on the situation, “I grew up in Siberia, the land of brown bears, and even as a child I knew that you do not mess with those giants. There it would never occur to a person who is accustomed to sharing the woods with bears to hide behind a tree and watch a female with two cubs from a distance of 30 metres.”

Environmentalists and conversationalists are concerned over the fact that Danzia is still nursing her cubs.

However, not all are of that opinion. The wounded forager described the bear as crazy, telling a local news network, “She chased me. She took me with one paw on my back; she made a hole in my back. I was on the ground and then she jumped on top of me…It only needs to happen once. With me it went OK. If it had been a woman or someone else … I don’t know if it would have been OK because it’s really brutal.”

Some who live in the Dolomite mountain range have lost livestock to bears, and find their reintroduction has been mismanaged. Others advocate that once a wild animal turns and attacks a human, it must be killed.

These ideas are predicated on the assumption that:

1. An animal killing or wounding a person instigates revenge attacks from humans, wiping populations out further rather than the one creature responsible and

2. Animals that get a taste for attacking humans tend to do so multiple times.

However, these points have been hotly contested by environmentalists. They are quick to point out that needless culling of say, stingrays, after the death of Steven Irwin is a human fault that animals should not be held responsible or killed for. Furthermore, the fact that animals ‘acquire’ a taste for human flesh or blood is not always the case. This is especially true when we talk about animals that are protecting their offspring, and maul a human as a warning to stay away rather than attempt to eat it.

In cases of man-eating predators, such as lions and tigers, it is often said that they only go after humans during times of food scarcity and unnatural encroachment. Ironically enough, this is often brought about by humans themselves through illegal hunting and deforestation. One notable example of this being in India, where encroachment on tiger domains has caused multiple run-ins between wildlife and humans.

Although tigers and wolves are especially prone to ‘acquiring’ a taste for humans, which is attributable to the content of salt in our blood, these cases tend to be extremely rare.

Although in Italy, the officials are certain of the bear responsible, in other cases it can be shown that trying to track and kill bears that attack humans is a very imperfect science.

In Florida of this year, six bears were killed after one woman was mauled. The bears were killed on the premise that they ‘displayed no fear of humans.’ However, despite killing half a dozen bears, authorities were still not convinced they had brought down the particular bear that mauled the woman.

Animal care advocates say that rather than trying to kill or capture an animal accused of mauling or killing a human, each case ought to be examined for the probability of reoccurrence. For instance, the mama bear and cubs likely did not acquire a taste for human flesh after an incomplete mauling. So in cases like those, many advocate that animals such as these be relocated further away from areas populated by humans.

Nature belongs to everybody but it is not a zoo, nor is it without risks. The very fact that we are wandering deeper into the wilderness than ever before, without considering those hazards shows a very particular kind of hubris. Nothing, not one species, lives side by side in the wild without facing danger. So before we go on killing rampages or separate mother bears from cubs, let’s use these magnificent, evolved brains of ours to come up with solutions that focus on conservation, rather than killing.

Read more: , , , , , , , ,

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it

262 comments

+ add your own
8:57AM PDT on Sep 11, 2014

paolo.abram@provincia.tn.it,pietro.acler@provincia.tn.it,giorgio.zattoni@provincia.tn.it,eliana.zomer@provincia.tn.it,paolo.zanghellini@provincia.tn.it,cristian.zanella@provincia.tn.it,danilo.tonina@provincia.tn.it,moreno.tacconi@provincia.tn.it,nadia.tomasi@provincia.tn.it,stefano.tasin@provincia.tn.it,roberto.risatti@provincia.tn.it,giancarlo.simoncelli@provincia.tn.it,mariano.sartori@provincia.tn.it,renato.rizzoli@provincia.tn.it,franca.pedrolli@provincia.tn.it,biancamaria.pontalti@provincia.tn.it,claudia.pedrotti@provincia.tn.it,daniele.paolazzi@provincia.tn.it,mariano.paris@provincia.tn.it,massimo.miori@provincia.tn.it,marco.olivari@provincia.tn.it,massimo.lissidini@provincia.tn.it,tomaso.marcolla@provincia.tn.it,claudio.groff@provincia.tn.it,annalisa.lenzi@provincia.tn.it,massimo.graziadei@provincia.tn.it,luisa.griso@provincia.tn.it,paola.comin@provincia.tn.it,ruggero.giovannini@provincia.tn.it,giuseppe.giovannini@provincia.tn.it,lorenza.giacomoni@provincia.tn.it,gabriella.gazzin@provincia.tn.it,nadia.garbari@provincia.tn.it,cristina.gandolfo@provincia.tn.it,caterina.gagliano@provincia.tn.it,roberta.cuzzolin@provincia.tn.it,mauro.confalonieri@provincia.tn.it,luisa.casapiccola@provincia.tn.it,ermanno.cetto@provincia.tn.it,celestino.castagna@provincia.tn.it,matteo.campolongo@provincia.tn.it,andrea.carbonari@provincia.tn.it,tarcisio.ballerin@provincia.tn.it,mariasanta.calabrese@provincia.tn.it,gabriella.bridi@provincia.tn.it,marialorenza.agnoli@provincia.tn.it,carlo.anderl

8:56AM PDT on Sep 11, 2014

lorena.fracchetti@provincia.tn.it,laura.toniutti@provincia.tn.it,mauro.zambotto@provincia.tn.it,maurizio.valentinotti@provincia.tn.it,antonella.veronesi@provincia.tn.it,gianmarco.richiardone@provincia.tn.it,veronica.tomazzolli@provincia.tn.it,michele.tarolli@provincia.tn.it,monica.toccoli@provincia.tn.it,manuel.rinaldi@provincia.tn.it,giuliana.passeri@provincia.tn.it,alba.ponessa@provincia.tn.it,mara.ress@provincia.tn.it,clara.poncia@provincia.tn.it,mauro.pisoni@provincia.tn.it,maddalena.pegoretti@provincia.tn.it,lorena.pescador@provincia.tn.it,carla.malacarne@provincia.tn.it,claudio.pallaoro@provincia.tn.it,elena.parolari@provincia.tn.it,luigino.mongera@provincia.tn.it,clara.pallanch@provincia.tn.it,claudio.nibali@provincia.tn.it,orietta.menestrina@provincia.tn.it,alessandro.moltrer@provincia.tn.it,luisa.martini@provincia.tn.it,arianna.marzadro@provincia.tn.it,tiziana.celli@provincia.tn.it,claudio.inama@provincia.tn.it,chiara.locicero@provincia.tn.it,monica.laudadio@provincia.tn.it,fabrizio.gerola@provincia.tn.it,simonetta.guastamacchia@provincia.tn.it,mauro.furlani@provincia.tn.it,corrado.gasperetti@provincia.tn.it,clara.faes@provincia.tn.it,paoloalessio.fiorini@provincia.tn.it,angela.ferrari@provincia.tn.it,giordano.deparis@provincia.tn.it,federico.conci@provincia.tn.it,alessandro.borzaga@provincia.tn.it,cristina.bertol@provincia.tn.it,daniele.bonetta@provincia.tn.it,sandra.bortolotti@provincia.tn.it,stefano.berlanda@provincia.tn.it,mariella.bazzucco@provincia.tn.it,alessa

8:54AM PDT on Sep 11, 2014

Dear friends, the poor bear Daniza was killed tonight due to a "mistake" while they were trying to capture her. Her cubs are alone now and will probably die.
These are the consequences of the INSANE decision made by the DECEREBRATED responsibles of the province of Trento. As tourism is particularly important for that area, please write to the following addresses, expressing your OUTRAGE and telling them you will NEVER VISIT the Province of Trento:

isabella.barozzi@provincia.tn.it,gabriella.borgogno@provincia.tn.it,laura.boschini@provincia.tn.it,mauro.facchinelli@provincia.tn.it,maurizio.fontana@provincia.tn.it,maurizio.francescon@provincia.tn.it,alessandra.giacomozzi@provincia.tn.it,manuela.goglio@provincia.tn.it,zaira.meloni@provincia.tn.it,fabrizio.nardelli@provincia.tn.it,gaetano.patti@provincia.tn.it,barbara.simonetti@provincia.tn.it,maurizio.tava@provincia.tn.it,mirco.tomasi@provincia.tn.it,rosaria.tovazzi@provincia.tn.it,mariafiore.zandonai@provincia.tn.it
mariafulvia.zonta@provincia.tn.it,valerio.valenti@provincia.tn.it,luisa.bellin@provincia.tn.it,alessandro.franceschini@provincia.tn.it,paolo.kovatsch@provincia.tn.it,luigino.leonardi@provincia.tn.it,laura.murru@provincia.tn.it,davide.pozzo@provincia.tn.it

presidente@provincia.tn.it,nadia.casata@provincia.tn.it,luca.nicoletti@provincia.tn.it,erica.slaghenaufi@provincia.tn.it,moreno.tait@provincia.tn.it,alessandra.labalestra@provincia.tn.it,lorenza.dallarosa@provincia.tn.it,dina.fedrizzi@provincia.tn.it,gabrie

8:26AM PDT on Sep 11, 2014

Daniza has been killed. I have no words. I am ashamed to be Italian.

10:05PM PDT on Aug 28, 2014

Animals should not be killed for protecting their territory, food or young.

2:04PM PDT on Aug 28, 2014

No wild animal should ever be killed if they attack people unless they are rabid. We are the ones taking away their land that they live in. They are only doing what's natural to them. Protecting themselves and their babies. Leave them alone! It's so upsetting when I read about an animal being killed because a person was in the woods in their home and got attacked. DUH! Seriously no one thinks that won't happen?

12:47PM PDT on Aug 28, 2014

Signed

7:43AM PDT on Aug 28, 2014

Anything humans have interefered with, historically has just been a disaster. Humans need to leave nature alone!!! It cannot ever be stressed enough.

5:55AM PDT on Aug 28, 2014

I lived in Great Smokey Mountain National Park; one of our teachers was killed and partially eaten by three bears. It was the first known attack on humans in 50 years there. Normally bears who become 'nuisance bears' (those who come into town, raid stores, and show no fear of people and stay around people), are tagged, moved higher up out of the area. The rule is "Three Strikes and you are dead". Those bears stalked her, and took her down. She was carrying no food, or anything to lure the bears. An autopsy on the bears showed they were not hungry, so they had become a danger.
Because of so many tourists, bears lost their fear of people. They needed to learn to be leery of people and avoid them. A program was started to discourage bears from getting close to people... Now the problem is to educate people to leave wild life alone! We have idiots, normally women, down here in FL who have been leaving food out for gators, or going down to the lake and when they see a gator, throw food to them. Now we have gator attacks.
Wild animals live in many areas; they have been reintroduced into habitat. BUT PEOPLE insist on being 'involved' and as a result, the animals suffer the conseequences, as often do people. Unprovoked attacks can be a different story... The deaths of those 6 bears here in FL was just plain STUPID!

5:09AM PDT on Aug 28, 2014

merci pour vos commentaires et à toi Lizabeth

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

ads keep care2 free

Recent Comments from Causes

Wonderful when multiple winners come out of the same idea!

Barbara D. "Valerie, organic growers can, by law, use *organic* pesticides many of which are much more…

May they remain safe and happy.

Story idea? Want to blog? Contact the editors!
ads keep care2 free

more from causes

Animal Welfare

Causes Canada

Causes UK

Children

Civil Rights

Education

Endangered Wildlife

Environment & Wildlife

Global Development

Global Warming

Health Policy

Human Rights

LGBT rights

Politics

Real Food

Trailblazers For Good

Women's Rights




Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.