START A PETITION 25,136,189 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x
773,100 people care about Education

Can Recess Before Lunch and Later School Start Times Improve Student Performance?

Can Recess Before Lunch and Later School Start Times Improve Student Performance?

Change the time school starts from 7.25am to 8.30am; SAT scores rise significantly.

 

Move recess to before lunch; not only is less food wasted (i.e., tossed into garbage cans by kids scurrying out to play in the time allotted), but students’ academic performance improves, a bit.

 

Small and seemingly commonsensical innovations that, according to some school administrators, have made a difference for students. As Tara Parker-Pope in the January 25th Well blog on the New York Times, writes, school districts in Montana, Arizona, and New Jersey have shifted to “recess before lunch,” with promising results. Besides less food wasted, children are “less likely to become hungry or feel sick later in the day” and “to the surprise of school officials, moving recess before lunch ended up adding about 15 minutes of classroom instruction.”  

 

In the January 23rd Guardian, Po Bronson and Ashley Merryman note that children today sleep an hour less than they did 30 years ago, with 60% of high school students reporting “extreme daytime sleepiness.” Studies vary but “anywhere from a fifth to a third are falling asleep in class at least once a week.” No surprise to hear that secondary students sleep only a bit more than 6.5 hours a night. Bronson and Merryman cite the example of Edina, an “affluent suburb of Minneapolis,” where changing the start time for high school to 8.30am resulted in the “best and brightest” students’ SAT scores going up by 56 points in math and a “whopping 156 points” on the verbal test.

So why don’t all school districts at least consider such changes?

 

The simple reality of logistics, for one thing. Parker-Pope notes that 

 

Children often have to return to hallways and classrooms after recess for bathroom breaks and hand washing and to pick up lunch bags. The North Ranch Elementary School [in Scottsdale, Arizona] regularly fields calls from schools in colder climates with questions on how to deal with coats, hats, galoshes and mittens. “In Arizona, we don’t have to deal with that,” said Dr. [Sarah] Hartley, the principal.

 

What might work in suburban (and, in particular, affluent) school districts, may well (as child experts point out) not in urban ones. Lower-income children may come to school without breakfast; having to wait even long during recess to eat lunch may not be possible, or advised. And a later start to the school day can wreak havoc on morning routines for households with parents who need to get to their jobs. As much as administrators might welcome the increases in test scores and increased time for academic instruction, fewer than 5 percent of the nation’s elementary schools schedule recess before lunch, according to The Journal of Childhood Nutrition & Management. I’m sure any school official would have her or his interest piqued by those SAT scores but—considering that Edina is, as noted, an “affluent suburb,” it’s certainly possible that other factors (parental involvement, more access to tutors) might have played a role. 

 

As a parent myself, I can speak to the beneficial effects of a later start time for school. My son’s former public middle school started at 7.45am; he now attends a public center for children on the autism spectrum, with a start time of 8.45am. Try as he might, Charlie just could not make 6.45am wake-up times (to catch a 7.15am bus) part of his routine, and many a morning started with frantic running around, not to mention tears. Now he, and we, have plenty of time to get ready in a (more or less) calm and collected fashion.

 

And regarding “recess before lunch.” Charlie doesn’t have recess anymore but he does have Adapted Physical Education form 9 – 9.30am. He’s able to have a snack afterwards which sometimes turns into a mini-lunch (brunch, that is). He’s been generally focused and in good spirits for the rest of the day with a break at what is actually lunchtime. He doesn’t want to eat any breakfast at home, and I’m thinking that those 30 minutes of physical activity whet his appetite so he eats, feels satisfied, is ready for learning.

 

Of course, administrators at Charlie’s current school are able to make the necessary accommodations for students with many needs like him. Public schools with far larger populations, and much bigger groups of children to move in and out of cafeterias and playgrounds, have many more logistical problems to content with, not to mention parents who say they’re fine with an 8.30am start time, but please be sure to make arrangements for kids who get dropped off early by working moms and dads.

 

And so apparently commonsensical solutions start seeming a lot more complicated and, unfortunately, not so feasible.

Read more:

Photo of children on a playground by DC DPR.
Kristina Chew, Ph.D., is Associate Professor of Classics at Saint Peter's College in New Jersey. Since 2005, she has been blogging about autism, disabilities, and education, previously at Autism Vox and now at We Go With Him, a daily journal about life with her 12 1/2 year old son Charlie.

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it

48 comments

+ add your own
1:31PM PDT on Apr 2, 2010

thank you

9:09PM PST on Feb 24, 2010

In Australia, school times start at 9.00 am generally (primary and secondary schools). Some church schools start a little earlier - 8.30 am. There is a recess usually at 11.00 am for about 20 minutes, & lunch at 12.30 pm for 1 hour (high school). School finishes at 3.00 pm - 3.30 pm. I think starting classes at 7.30 am is way too early, and no break before lunch-time is not in the best interest of children's health or learning capacity.

11:53AM PST on Feb 7, 2010

moving the school times later is a good idea. provide a daycare/playtime at school if it presents a problem with parents and work. its safer for the kids waiting for the bus if they are out there later as well. having a recess has improved grades/test scores than not having recess.

4:24PM PST on Feb 6, 2010

I'm not sure about later start times...but I would think recess after lunch would be a much better idea!

12:28PM PST on Feb 2, 2010

KIds should have recess, and gym later on too!

12:09PM PST on Feb 2, 2010

Absolutely. When I was a child we had morning and afternoon recess. We started school at 8:30 and I can remember just about dozing off in class at around 10:30 but after a 20 minute recess of running around in the fresh air I was suddenly interested in math or history again. In fact I still have recess every morning and afternoon - I call it a coffee break.

7:17AM PST on Feb 2, 2010

I also remember who early my daughters had to get up to go to school and they were always tired too. So I think the hours should be changed, but then I now have a grand son that goes to school a little before 9 and gets off the bus at 4:45P, is this better I don't know, seems like an awful long time to me..

9:19AM PST on Feb 1, 2010

I really think it's important that children are given regular breaks. In the office, most workers take a coffee break and a lunch break. Why aren't our kids getting even better breaks than adults? Their minds and bodies aren't set up to deal with long school days with short breaks. Administrators hope that making more of the day academic will increase test scores are dead wrong. It makes our children discontented, inattentive, inactive, and bored. K-5 should be fun learning years. Happy learners simply learn more, and won't be burned out at elementary.

8:26AM PST on Feb 1, 2010

I think the early start was a problem for my kids. I don't recall school starting as early as it has in more recent years.

5:51PM PST on Jan 31, 2010

Teenager's internal clock is set for a later start. I would love a later start for my daughter and myself. My son slept through his first couple of classes almost everyday. I tried to get them to shift non-important classes first.

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

ads keep care2 free

meet our writers

Kristina Chew Kristina Chew teaches and writes about ancient Greek and Latin and is Online Advocacy and Marketing... more
Story idea? Want to blog? Contact the editors!
ads keep care2 free

more from causes




Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.