START A PETITION 25,136,189 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x
1,446,637 people care about Health Policy

Can There Be a Cure For Autism?: A New Drug Raises a Much-Disputed Question

Can There Be a Cure For Autism?: A New Drug Raises a Much-Disputed Question

Last week Novartis announced that, following a small clinical trial involving a few dozen patients, a new experimental drug had been found to bring about significant ‘improvements in the behaviors associated with retardation and autism in people with fragile X syndrome.’ According to the April 29th New York Times

 

The Novartis trial, which began in 2008 in Europe with data analysis completed this year, was too brief to observe effects on basic intelligence. Instead, researchers measured a range of aberrant behaviors like hyperactivity, repetitive motions, social withdrawal and inappropriate speech. They gave one set of patients the drug and another a placebo, and after a few weeks switched treatments, with both doctors and patients unaware of which pill was which.

 

The results of the trial were something of a jumble until Novartis scientists noticed that patients who had a particular, undisclosed biological trait improved far more than others.

 

There have been a other reports of experimental drugs for treating Fragile X; the Novartis drug, it is reported, might also positively benefit autistic individuals who do not have Fragile X. (Go here for more information about autism and Fragile X Syndrome.) Said Katie Clapp, president and co-founder of the Fraxa Research Foundation, a nonprofit organization dedicated to financing fragile X research, and the mother of an 18-year-old son with Fragile X,
 

“This may be the key to solving the mystery of autism and other developmental disorders.”

 

The new drug, then, has the potential to stir up one of the thorniest and most divisive topics in discussions about autism, namely the question of a ‘cure for autism.’

Is a cure possible? Desirable?

Is autism something inborn and intrinsic to a person or is it something that a person can ‘grow out of’ or even ‘recover from’?

More and more autistic self-advocates, parents, and others speaking up about the strengths of being on the autusm’ spectrum. But others argue that, it’s fine for those who are ‘high-functioning‘ (a term that us itself the cause of much dispute) and who have Aspergers Syndrome to advocate for ‘neurodiversity‘ to not wish for a cure—but what a ‘cure’ about those who are (again, a disputed term) ‘low-functioning‘ and severely autistic?

Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius recently announced five new members of the Interagency Autism Coordinating Committee (IACC), a federal advisory committee that seeks to ‘accelerate progress in autism spectrum disorder (ASD) research and services.’ Among the new members are self-advocate Ari Ne’eman, the founding president of the Autistic Self Advocacy Network; the chief science officer for Autism Speaks, Geraldine Dawson, Ph.D.; the scientific director for the Simons Foundation, Gerald Fischbach, M.D.; the co-founder and board development chair of the Southwest Autism Research & Resource Center (SARRC) and the mother of an 18-year-old on the autism spectrum, Denise Resnik; and a member of the Faculty of the Medical Investigation of Neurological Disorders (MIND) Institute, Marjorie Solomon, Ph.D. The number of scientists and researchers appointed to the IACC outweighs the number of individuals who are themselves on the spectrum; as Autism Speaks’ mission statement says that it ‘dedicated to funding global biomedical research into the causes, prevention, treatments, and cure for autism,’ it seems that the question of a ‘cure’ might arise in some capacity.

 

I don’t know that there will ever be consensus about this issue. My own sense is that ‘cure’ isn’t really the right term to use. My son Charlie has certainly benefited from the numerous educational, therapeutic, and medical protocols that have been developed in the past several years. He has some speech (though it’s minimal, but he can talk); he’s learned to do a number of things—riding a bike, playing piano (at a very basic level)—that he might never have been able to; he is able to live with my husband Jim and me in our house in our community, despite my son having what I would refer to as ‘textbook autism nightmare without end” sorts of behavior challenges

Certainly we always seek to find new ways to help him better communicate and learn, and to minimize his most difficult behaviors. But even if he could speak in full paragraphs, could read and write and do schoolwork at his grade level (8th grade), and had none of the serious behavior challenges that he does, Charlie would still not be what some refer to as ‘normal’ or ‘typical.’ He’d have (I would hope) fewer challenges at school and in general and his activities and opportunities might not have to be as limited as they are. But there’s something unique about Charlie to the core and whether or not he could be cured of that—-if he were, I’m not sure, would he still be Charlie?

 

Read more:

Photo by Nancy Wombat.

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it

68 comments

+ add your own
4:22PM PST on Nov 24, 2012

1. The increase in ASD/autism at the expense of decreasing mental retardation is intriguing. A lot of lay folks in Waldorf, MD couldn't tell the difference. But they still practiced psychology diagnosing me as MR.

2. ASD and cannabis. Should I be smoking pot, then? Never tried...

4:18PM PST on Nov 24, 2012

But the question of whether removing autism/Asperger would remove personality, or beneficial traits like intelligence? I am sort of sure the same genes that govern mathematical, scientific, technological prowess in my family and Asperger are related or the same. It is anecdotal that a lot of Aspies are proficient computer programmers (The Geek Syndrome, Wired). And yes as the article noted, also receive special education services (around Silicon Valley) as I did in southern Maryland.

We might eliminate good traits by eliminating bad traits. Anyone watch Nutty Professor 2, The Klumps? Sherman got rid of Buddy but also progressively lost his intelligence. I can't help thinking about Aspies in that movie...

4:14PM PST on Nov 24, 2012

Aspie and have to comment. Extremely fortunate as Aspies go, live independently, work in IT (and when unemployed seldom unemployed longer than 2, 3 months), drive a 1998 Chevy Cavalier, cook, the whole nine yards. I do let the apartment go because I tell myself I work, although I can keep a place up. Like others on Dad's side of the family have autistic symptoms and have greatly delayed relationship building. But since weight also runs on that side of the family, I am not sure what is responsible for what.



4:10PM PST on Nov 24, 2012

Great post Kristina.
Working with Autism, located in Los Angeles, has helped hundreds of children with an Autism Spectrum Disorder to achieve their maximum potential for independence. www.workingwithautism.com

12:32PM PDT on May 29, 2010

The crux of the "cure" question regarding autism seems to me to be whether one regards everything about autism as 100% bad, horrible, defective, and so on, or whether one is prepared to make the sometimes nuanced distinction between autism /per se/ and disability related to autism.

If we could get everyone to focus on mitigating *disability* related to autism, there would be far less conflict and wasted energy. The major autism organizations would no longer engage in rhetoric that alienates adults living with the condition, and the insights, energy, and perspectives of those adults would be better leveraged -- a win-win for all.

1:28PM PDT on May 28, 2010

No thanks, I have two autistic sons and i would not use it at all.

8:18AM PDT on May 28, 2010

Thanks for the information, but I have onhand experience. I have seen a dramatic change in my nephew once we took him off of dairy and a few other dietary adjustments. I think two years is not long enough to base a new drug. In 5 years they will find out that it is making people grow an extra head or something. More research is needed.

4:49AM PDT on May 22, 2010

I think psychiatric medication is highly dubious and spiritual and psychological treatment much to be preferred

9:16AM PDT on May 14, 2010

Thanks for the article

10:53PM PDT on May 9, 2010

Upon reading the article, it is quite noticeable that there is no concensus on whether to possibly treat with drugs or leave it altogether.
One of the comments suggested that much more should be done to try and find the reason for autism,
I personally find this a much more logical way to go!
In any case, the study done on a few dozen persons with the new drug, is certainly not the total answer!

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Care2 - Be Extraordinary - Start a Care2 Petition
ads keep care2 free
CONTACT THE EDITORS

Recent Comments from Causes

I so love these magnificent creatures, elephants. They may look different from us humans, but we hold…

My state? Alabama? Bahahahahahahaaaa!

meet our writers

Kristina Chew Kristina Chew teaches and writes about ancient Greek and Latin and is Online Advocacy and Marketing... more
ads keep care2 free

more from causes

Animal Welfare

Causes Canada

Causes UK

Children

Civil Rights

Education

Endangered Wildlife

Environment & Wildlife

Global Development

Global Warming

Health Policy

Human Rights

LGBT rights

Politics

Real Food

Trailblazers For Good

Women's Rights




Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.