START A PETITION 27,000,000 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x

Climate Science Belongs In The Classroom

Climate Science Belongs In The Classroom

 

by Abbie Walston

According to certain special interest groups, climate change seems to be a hot topic when it comes to what should be taught in public schools. The arguments are that teachers tend to be alarmist or too liberal. I would like to share my own philosophy on climate change education based on my experience as an environmental educator.

Climate Change: What To Teach

First, let’s take a look at what the real experts on science education have to say. Climate change is included in standards for science education across the country. The recently released National Academy of Sciences’ “Framework for K-12 Science Education: Practices, Crosscutting Concepts and Core Ideas” states that:

“Global climate change, shown to be driven by both natural phenomena and by human activities, could have large consequences for all of Earth’s surface systems, including the biosphere.”

It also goes on to outline what students should understand about climate change by the end of grades 5, 8 and 12. Global climate change is included in my state’s Core Science Curriculum Frameworks, and students’ understanding is assessed on state standardized tests. The College Board’s course outline for AP Environmental Science also includes global warming as a topic, with the expectation that units will include discussions of “greenhouse gases and the greenhouse effect; impacts and consequences of global warming; impacts and consequences of global warming; reducing climate change; relevant laws and treaties,” and these concepts are included on the AP Exam at the end of the course.

If I want to follow the guidelines of the most respected national and local scientists and educators, then I must teach about climate change. If I want to prepare my students for standardized tests, I also must teach about climate change. I believe that it is important for my students to leave my classroom as scientifically literate, informed citizens who are able to make decisions relevant to their impact on climate change…whether that be how they choose to cast a vote or buy a new car.

The experts agree, but I’m also passionate about climate change education because I see it occurring on a local level and impacting my loved ones. As a member of a farming family that goes back generations, my life is intertwined with the seasons and the climate. For example, in my 30 year lifetime, I have witnessed a change in the maple sugaring season, a tradition that I hope to be able to pass on to my child. We used to tap trees in March, and now we tap them in February. If you pay attention, you can recognize the changes occurring right before your eyes, just as my conservative Yankee family has. This kind of connection between my life and science is what makes for a dynamic, exciting science lesson. I truly care about this topic, and my students can recognize that.

Climate Change: How To Teach

But it’s not just about what to teach, I believe that how I teach about climate change is incredibly important. My own philosophy of education is one of experiential, place-based learning, stressing the skills of problem-solving and critical thinking. I don’t expect my students to listen blindly to lectures and accept what I say as the ultimate truth. Instead, I prefer to allow students to draw their own conclusions. I choose to introduce the unit with data analysis, including atmospheric temperature anomalies, carbon dioxide concentrations and changes in sea level. Students construct graphs and look for correlations, discuss the validity and reliability of the data, who funds this research, and the possibility of hidden variables. I don’t stand at a podium and tell kids that the Earth is warming – they figure it out on their own.

There have been questions of whether there is room for differences of opinion in the curriculum. Perhaps we could read articles from climate change skeptics or have a debate? My simple answer is this:  I would not hold a debate on climate change any more than I would hold one on the Theory of Natural Selection or the Law of Gravity.

I don’t want to create the illusion of a debate, when in fact the data shows that the climate is changing and that anthropogenic carbon emissions are accelerating the rise in temperature. There is consensus among climate scientists and I don’t give any credence to climate change skeptics in my science classroom. However, I do think the story of Richard Muller, a climate change skeptic who decided to do his own research and subsequently changed his mind, is valuable for us to read and discuss. It’s an example of a scientifically literate person changing his conclusion when presented with data.

We discuss Milankovitch cycles and periods of natural cooling and warming, and we also talk about the importance of understanding the complexity of models that predict the impact of climate change. We discuss why the record snow falls last winter were actually an indicator of the kind of extreme changes in weather patterns that result from climate change, not evidence that the temperature isn’t rising. We also pay attention to the credibility of sources, look at who is funding research and think about what their motivations could be. While there is debate about exactly how our future will change because of climate change, there’s not scientific debate about the fact that the temperature is rising.

So what if students still choose not to believe that climate change is real? My goal is to make my students think critically and draw their own conclusions. I feel I have accomplished my goal as a teacher if my students are aware that there is consensus among climate scientists, they are able to express their arguments using scientific data and can discredit pseudoscience…even if they don’t agree with me.

Please take action with Moms Clean Air Force.

 

Related Stories:

More Creationism Bills Advance

Climate Denier Teaches University “Climate Science” Course

Climate Change Denial Sweeping Into Public Schools

 

Read more: , , , , ,

Photo credit: gpkdesign

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it

90 comments

+ add your own
8:44PM PDT on Apr 5, 2012

cont. -- Hopefully, it is this second group that will start waking up to reality and will develop the courage and strength to stand up to the greedy, heartless, destroyers of our planet. It must be this group that wakes up, as the greedy, stupid, perpetrators of this crime against the environment/people are too addicted to their greed to every care about anything other than more money.

Obviously, the truth, and education, is the only way to truly wake people up to this critical issue that’s at hand!

8:42PM PDT on Apr 5, 2012

I think we're dealing with two very different opposition groups in regards to this issue.

One group is very intelligent and knows very well that their actions of destroying our environment, cutting down millions of acres of trees, burning excessive amounts of fossil fuel, deterring research into alternate fuels, etc., etc., is causing massive detrimental changes to our climate. This group, however, is extremely greedy and heartless, and just wants to rape the land for all it’s worth, with absolutely no concern or compassion towards all life current, and that comes after them.

This group, sadly, is extremely wealthy and powerful, for the most part, and tends to get away with horrendous actions against our environment, as they have bought every politician they‘re able to. And, they use their money and conniving to distort reality through direct lies, or via keeping science out of people’s reach and understanding. And, they are exports at using propaganda to confuse the issue, and confuse the people who don’t have the time or ability to truly grasp what’s going on.

And, of course, the second group is this group that falls sway to the propaganda and buys into the BS these greedy, wealthy individuals and corporations spew, for the sake of them amassing more millions/billions at the sake of our precious environment, our climate, and the common people who also live on this planet.

Hopefully, it is this second group that will start waking up to

6:19PM PDT on Apr 5, 2012

Meme M. said "blah, blah, blah."

You clearly know nothing of the underlying Physics of radiative forcing. So, please drop the pretense at being sufficiently informed so as to be able to speak rationally on the subject of global warming.

You have been duped by those Big Businesses whose ability to generate $$$$$$$$ depend on your consuming hydrocarbons as rapidly as possible.

1:18PM PDT on Apr 2, 2012

Yes!

11:53AM PDT on Mar 27, 2012

Thanks

1:51PM PDT on Mar 25, 2012

Thanks!

7:56AM PDT on Mar 25, 2012

Exposure to all types of science should be included in K-12 curriculae if the US wants to be competitive economically in the future.

12:33AM PDT on Mar 25, 2012

A very well written and enlightening article. Thank you.

11:53PM PDT on Mar 24, 2012

Educating children in the classroom or in the home, on not being big polluters, recycling or how important it is to walk and ride a bike, using public transport, instead of relying totally on a car will have a huge impact on that childs life and many other children thereby influencing the planet for the better. Good teachers can have enormous influence on us for the better and contributing to Society in a really positive way.

5:01AM PDT on Mar 24, 2012

thanks

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Care2 - Be Extraordinary - Start a Care2 Petition
ads keep care2 free
CONTACT THE EDITORS

Recent Comments from Causes

Happy bunnies make for a happy day. Thanks for sharing. Merry Happy Christmas to all who observe!

Stories like this restore my faith in some humans. It's a shame that there are so few people in this…

That was weird and funny! I tried that with my black lab and he hated it.

ads keep care2 free



Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.