START A PETITION 25,136,189 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x
3,155,695 people care about Animal Welfare

Death of SeaWorld Trainer Prompts Congressional Hearing

Death of SeaWorld Trainer Prompts Congressional Hearing

Prompted by the death of trainer Dawn Brancheau, who was drowned by SeaWorld’s Orca whale Tillikum, the U.S. House Natural Resources Committee, Subcommittee on Insular Affairs, Oceans, and Wildlife, held a hearing on Tuesday on Marine Mammals in Captivity: What Constitutes Meaningful Public Education?

Voices on both sides of the debate were heard on whether there’s any actual educational advantage to keeping whales and dolphins in tanks.

There are approximately 200 zoos and aquariums currently licensed to keep and show marine mammals. Facilities need to prove that they offer education or conservation programs based on industry standards in order to be eligible for a license. 

The National Marine Fisheries Service, which issues the permits, has never issued specific rules that define the standards, does not review the facility for compliance once the permit is issued and has never revoked a permit from such parks,

The problem with that is that there is no independent oversight for what constitutes these programs, leaving the industry to self-regulate. Most of these facilities are run for a profit, making for an interesting conflict of interest. “Our programs bring in a lot of money. Eh hem, I mean of course our programs are educational.”

That was the stance taken by those in support of keeping these shows running, including SeaWorld’s curator Julie Scardina, who stated that “are designed to inspire visitors to conserve our valuable natural resources by increasing awareness of the interrelationships between humans and the environment.”

What defines our relationship with these mammals? Is it to exploit them for our own interests? Or should the lessons of these educational efforts foster a respect of their place in the environment and respect of their needs to be wild and free in their natural habitat.

The other side of the debate argued that aside from the cruelty of confining these animals to tanks these educational programs aren’t even accurate.

Naomi Rose, a senior scientist for Humane Society International.cited mistakes in SeaWorld educational materials, including the life expectancy of killer whales. In a teacher’s manual, SeaWorld had said the animals live “25 to 35 years,” she said, when in fact males live up to 60 years in the wild and females up to 80 years.

“It is irresponsible of those in the captivity industry to compare orcas and dolphins to playful happy pets who do tricks for food when it serves to entertain an audience, and then compare them to wild predatory animals when they need an explanation for extreme and abberrant behavior. From dolphin collisions to orca attacks, the question is not whether but when the next tragedy for marine mammals in captivity will occur,” said Louie Psihoyos Executive Director of the Oceanic Preservation Society and Director of The Cove

Psihoyos also notes in his testimony that there has never been a reported case of an Orca killing a human in the wild, whereas Dawn Brancheau was Tillikum’s third victim. He adds that the “educational benefit of these unfortunate facts should be to alert everyone involved in marine mammal captivity that they are in fact responsible for inducing abnormal behavior.”

For more info, check out The Case Against Captivity.

Sign Animal Defenders International’s pledge not to support marine parks that keep animals in captivity. 

Read more: , , , , , , , , , ,

creative commons

quick poll

vote now!

Loading poll...

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it

89 comments

+ add your own
8:27AM PDT on Apr 8, 2013

Killer whales should not be kept captive for the entertainment of humans!

3:57AM PDT on Jul 31, 2012

I am only for animals held in captivity if they cannot survive in the wild due to permanent injury, handicap, or held in temporary captivity due to transporting them away from oil spill areas to relocate them in safer waters.

If a whale or, actually, any mammal/animal of any breed is born in captivity, they will not survive in the wild or would struggle to survive. There have been cases where this is true.



Read more: http://www.care2.com/causes/death-of-seaworld-trainer-prompts-congressional-hearing.html#ixzz2283viUCy

6:25PM PDT on Jul 30, 2012

All creatures should be free to make their own choices in life. Who are we, as humans, to say what is right or wrong for another? We can sometimes assist for a greater good but it is not our right to enforce our will. Personally I would always choose freedom and if I were to die by making that choice I would at least die free.

12:28PM PDT on Jun 4, 2010

it's a WILD animal...wake up

2:58AM PDT on May 18, 2010

These Whales and Dolphins are our closest genetic ancestors (this is true - check it out ! ) , and we are treating them like this. It is so shocking and so unbelievably cruel. It makes me feel so ill, also, how easy would it be to create a large protected area in the Sea by the coast so that these non-human people are able to at least swim free, it can be done.

10:45AM PDT on May 9, 2010

There should be better regulations concerning the care and living conditions of all animals in captivity. Banning captive populations isn't the answer.

1:44AM PDT on May 7, 2010

Noted and sign !

2:07PM PDT on May 6, 2010

MY GOODNESS THEY KNOW THE DANGERS AND THEY KNOW HOW EVERYTHING GOES, WHY ON EARTH ARE THEY BLAMING THE KILLER WHALE, POOR THING. OH GOD ITS TERRIBLE.

2:06PM PDT on May 6, 2010

MY GOODNESS THEY KNOW THE DANGERS AND THEY KNOW HOW EVERYTHING GOES, WHY ON EARTH ARE THEY BLAMING THE KILLER WHALE, POOR THING. OH GOD ITS TERRIBLE.

2:05PM PDT on May 6, 2010

MY GOODNESS THEY KNOW THE DANGERS AND THEY KNOW HOW EVERYTHING GOES, WHY ON EARTH ARE THEY BLAMING THE KILLER WHALE, POOR THING. OH GOD ITS TERRIBLE.

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Care2 - Be Extraordinary - Start a Care2 Petition
ads keep care2 free
CONTACT THE EDITORS

meet our writers

Colleen H. Colleen H. is an Online Campaigner with Care2 and a recent transplant to San Francisco from the East... more
ads keep care2 free



Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.