START A PETITION 27,000,000 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x
3,150,967 people care about Animal Welfare

Does Darwin the IKEA Monkey Have the Right to Choose?

Does Darwin the IKEA Monkey Have the Right to Choose?

When Darwin the rhesus monkey became an internet sensation after he was found roaming a Toronto IKEA store on Sunday, no one could have predicted what would follow would be an argument over whether Darwin has the right to choose where it is he wants to live.

Darwin has become a media darling since a video surfaced of the juvenile monkey, in a child’s coat, having escaped from his owner Yasmin Nakhuda’s car at an IKEA store in North York.

Watch the story below:

Nakhuda had taken on the task of caring for the monkey five months ago and, though she had thought of giving him up before, had found she was unable to return Darwin because of the attachment they had formed with one another.

That Nakhuda is devoted to Darwin is apparent in a number of videos she has posted on YouTube of Darwin wearing several different outfits, brushing his teeth and more. That’s why the events following Sunday’s great escape have been especially distressing for Nakhuda.

After Sunday’s incident Darwin was taken in by Toronto Animal Services, who fined Nakhuda for breaking animal control laws. They placed Darwin with Story Book Farm Primate Sanctuary, but Nakhuda has now indicated she may be willing to go to court to argue her claim and that, in an interesting twist, Darwin should have a right to choose where he lives.

Nakhuda is quoted as saying:

“How do we know what he needs unless he’s given the right to choose?” she asked CP24 early Tuesday. “I think he should be given the right to choose. If he chooses something else than me, that’s fine. For me, it has never been about me, it has always been about him.”

In previous interviews she said the monkey “cannot live without me” and that “he needs his mother like a child needs his mother.”

“Is anyone at the sanctuary willing to have Darwin on their backs for 24 hours a day and 7 days a week?” she questioned in her e-mail. “For this is how he lived with me. There were no signs of him being unhappy or stressed out when he was in my care.”

Nakhuda has said she believes that Darwin cannot live without her and that he has in the past shown signs of extreme distress when separated from her.

The sanctuary has indicated that, while it is sympathetic to Nakhuda’s attachment, Darwin has shown few signs of emotional distress over their separation, though they admit that as yet Nakhuda has been prevented from seeing Darwin. The sanctuary has also said it would fight all attempts at a legal challenge because, they say, Darwin would likely become more and more of a handful as he gets older given that rhesus macaques are wide ranging and robust monkeys.

Matters are further complicated by the fact that the sanctuary is now raising funds using its famous resident in a Darwin-themed fundraiser.

Legal analysts have suggested that animal welfare may well be a concern should Nakhuda bring this case before the court.

While Nakhuada’s argument that Darwin should be given the right to choose may to some sound like an extraordinarily naive approach to this issue, it would be wrong to state that rhesus monkeys are not intelligent enough that we should exclude completely the notion of their emotional well being. Indeed, some studies have shown rhesus monkeys possess what are termed human-like traits such as some sense of self agency. Other research has shown they are able to discriminate faces much in the same way as humans.

Whether that means Nakhuda’s claim to care for Darwin should be given more weight remains to be seen. In the court of public opinion at least, some have called Nakhuda’s attachment to Darwin unhealthy and have said that, by virtue of his escape on Sunday, she has already proved that however well meaning, she cannot provide Darwin a safe environment.

A final word in this story may, however, be the overriding concern that, while juvenile rhesus monkeys are largely docile, adult males — and especially Darwin’s fellow rhesus macaques — can be aggressive and, in addition, carry a type of herpes that is especially dangerous to humans. These facts may provide reason enough to say Darwin’s emotional attachment to his former carer may have to be given less weight against his need to be in an environment in which he poses no risk to others and therefore does not run the risk of lethal measures from animal control.

 

Related Reading:

Rhesus Monkey at Canadian Ikea Store

Are Monkeys Self-Aware? Does it Matter?

Activists Protest Company’s Plan To Test Monkeys

 

Read more: , , , , , , ,

Image credit: Thinkstock.

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it

172 comments

+ add your own
1:02AM PDT on Apr 21, 2013

Thanks

6:25PM PDT on Apr 13, 2013

if she wants love, she should adopt a chuld or something, and he already chose to run off. enough said

1:08PM PDT on Apr 13, 2013

Thank you for sharing.

12:55PM PST on Dec 30, 2012

Wild animals belong in the wild. Not dressed up as human babies. Not in sanctuaries, used for human amusement and donations!

9:05AM PST on Dec 25, 2012

Something just occurred to me, yesterday (do not worry, I am only on here, during Christmas Day, to use up time until I can Gmail Video Chat with my Parents, Brother and his family)-
Any & All businesses and governments (beyond just stores, including “pet” stores, and towns -by The Federal Governments of the world; convention centers, arenas and etc.) that allows these captives from the wild into their locations MUST PAY A CONSEQUENCE FOR CONTRIBUTING TO THESE WILD BEINGS BEING KINAPPED FROM THEIR WILD ENVIRONMENTS!!
This would shut down the genocides extremely quick, by such actions usual time tables.
I suggest tons of volunteerism in organizations trying to save the wild beings, in their native countries and habitats (like what they try to do in Africa), MOST IMPORTANTLY tons of days of rehabilitation (done by organizations that truly care about other Beings, like PETA and NOT SPCA & HSUSA) and huge financial fines (for each Being and day they are in their locations and etc.; collected by UN’s Beings saving departments)!

9:03AM PST on Dec 25, 2012

Something just occurred to me, yesterday (do not worry, I am only on here, during Christmas Day, to use up time until I can Gmail Video Chat with my Parents, Brother and his family)-
Any & All businesses and governments (beyond just stores, including “pet” stores, and towns

11:08AM PST on Dec 24, 2012

thanks for sharing

11:56AM PST on Dec 20, 2012

Monkeys should never be pets. While it may cause Darwin some emotional stress right now, being young he will likely adjust to this more suitable lifestyle. Alternatively, if something were to occur when he is an adult (as is often the case; people realize they simply cannot handle the animal full grown) it would be much harder for him to take.

6:52PM PST on Dec 19, 2012

I'm interested to see how this plays out.

12:46PM PST on Dec 18, 2012

In one of my first-posts here, I agreed with making Toronto IKEA store having to create the best possible Wild habitat in The Toronto IKEA store. That was and is rediculious; I am sorry for such a short sighted and not critically thought out solution.

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Care2 - Be Extraordinary - Start a Care2 Petition
ads keep care2 free
CONTACT THE EDITORS

Recent Comments from Causes

We need to treat All creatures humanely.

HUMAN ENCROACHMENT ... the root of all evil. New development of roads, railways, factories and houses…

Great video!!! Such a happy puppy! I love that her ears are not cropped, too!

meet our writers

Steve Williams Steve Williams is a passionate supporter of Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Trans (LGBT) rights, human... more
ads keep care2 free

more from causes

Animal Welfare

Causes Canada

Causes UK

Children

Civil Rights

Education

Endangered Wildlife

Environment & Wildlife

Global Development

Global Warming

Health Policy

Human Rights

LGBT rights

Politics

Real Food

Trailblazers For Good

Women's Rights




Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.