Don’t Worry, Those Cows Are Just Crying Over the Loss of Their Babies

Strange noises coming from Sunshine Dairy Farm in Newbury, Mass., during the night last week prompted concerned residents to contact police, who in turn told everyone it was nothing to worry about. The noise was just from cows who were grieving the loss of their newborns.

According to Newburyport News, Newbury police Sgt. Patty Fisher said the department received calls over “inhuman” noises coming from the farm, which prompted her to post a message on the police station’s Facebook page:

Residents in the area of Sunshine Dairy Farm may notice loud noises coming from the dairy cows at all hours of the day and night. We’ve been informed that the cows are not in distress and that the noises are a normal part of farming practices.

Fisher stated that the separation of mother cows from their calves is a yearly occurrence and is a normal part of dairy farming. She’s right about it being a standard practice, but saying they were not in distress is dead wrong. For mother cows, having their calves ripped away from them shortly after they’re born is distressing, and it’s exactly why they were crying out.

Something that seems to get overlooked is that in order to produce milk dairy cows have to give birth, but because we steal their milk from them, calves have to be removed.

These little ones are torn from their mothers shortly after being born and are fed milk replacer and calf starter, instead of being allowed to drink their mother’s milk, which is intended solely for them. They won’t otherwise get to enjoy the comforts of being raised and nurtured by their mothers. Instead they’ll spend their first few weeks of life isolated in calf hutches or pens.

The females will likely follow in their mother’s footsteps and will be raised to replace them, while the males are left to face a sadder fate. They’ll likely be sold for veal because they have no other value. Selling calves for veal is nothing more than a way for the dairy industry to make a profit off of what it would otherwise have to deal with as waste. We can boycott veal all we want, but it won’t do any good if dairy products are still being consumed.

For mother cows, after about a year of producing milk, they’ll be impregnated again, and the whole process will start over and be repeated until their bodies are spent. This usually happens when they’re around five — about two decades shy of their normal lifespan – at which point they’ll be sold for slaughter. This is the continuous heartbreak that an estimated 9 million dairy cows in the U.S. face again and again, and it has nothing to do with the size or type of dairy operation they’re kept at, whether it’s a small family farm or a large factory farm.

The only difference here is that the sounds that were so disturbing to residents were heard. Our typical ignorance, or apathy, about the processes involved in milk production is something the dairy industry banks on. It may seem to cause less harm to cows because it’s just a byproduct, but as Gary Francione said, “There’s probably more suffering in a glass of milk than a pound of steak.”

Photo credit: Compassion in World Farming


Elaine W
Elaine Wabout an hour ago

I am sorry about this ;(

Mari 's
Mari 's3 months ago

Sad! A 2013 memory for me and I'll never forget reading this tragic story

Jim Ven
Jim Venabout a year ago

thanks for the article.

James Campbell
James Campbell1 years ago

It is common for humans to say that a cat (for example) can be ‘cruel’ when it stalks and captures a mouse. The fact is, no other species can outdo human beings for conscious cruelty. We have it drilled into us from childhood that WE (and only we) are made in the “image of God”. All other species are therefore of less importance. This attitude is then translated into how non-humans are treated with their rights put aside in the name of OUR needs. Much of the suffering we inflict has little or nothing to do with our survival. It is one thing to use a rifle to defend ourselves, quite another to trophy hunt. Humans do not need cows’ milk, we use it because we like it. Most people do not intend to be cruel, but our acceptance of certain products does cause harm that by any measure, IS cruel.

Karen Murray
Karen Murray1 years ago

There was a time when this wouldn't have been the picture of dairy farms anywhere -- and not that long ago, either. Only we have figured out how to industrialize, streamline and efficient-ize everything. Fake milk for calves, fake food for humans (because fresh can't be shipped thousands of miles without going off). Marketing has taught us to expect everything cheap and plentiful and this is the only way that can be done. If you eat only vegetables, you're probably eating the suffering of an immigrant harvester. The whole system is the problem.

Naomi Dreyer
Naomi Dreyer1 years ago

Upps! Maybe I won't go vegan but will try vegetarian first.

Naomi Dreyer
Naomi Dreyer1 years ago

I'm considering going vegan.

Tony L.
Away L1 years ago

Interesting and sad... TY for this.

Amy Thompson
Amy Thompson1 years ago

This is so very sad:,(. And some people think animals don't have feelings and that it's ethical to treat them as property devoid of emotion.
They should be sharing this type of info to all children in school, so they I'll grow up to be compassionate adults.

Luca Lotto
Luca Lotto1 years ago

in vitro meat for my cats and dogs lentils (protein) and rice ... they're alternatives. have to check how much taurin is in that lab meat and particularly where to get it.