START A PETITION 27,000,000 members: the world's largest community for good
2,267,157 people care about Health Policy

Dying Immigrant Denied Kidney Transplant Because He Is Undocumented

Dying Immigrant Denied Kidney Transplant Because He Is Undocumented


Written by Amanda Peterson Beadle

Jesus Navarro, a dialysis patient who will die without a kidney transplant, has private insurance. He has a donor to provide the needed kidney. But because he is an undocumented immigrant, hospital administrators at UC San Francisco Medical Center are refusing to allow the procedure, saying that there is no guarantee Navarro will receive the necessary follow-up care because of his immigration status. Now, Navarro is stuck in an “ethical gray area” for the hospital. “It puts the doctors in a very awkward and torn position,” said Arthur Caplan, a bioethics professor at the University of Pennsylvania. “You come into this trying to do good and find yourself stuck in the middle of a fight about immigration.”

For eight years, Navarro has used a home dialysis machine to cleanse his blood after his kidneys began to fail. He reached the top of the waitlist for a kidney in the spring, but doctors called off his transplant when they discovered his immigration status. Even after his wife offered her kidney for the transplant, administrators still refused to allow the surgery. Reece Fawley, executive director of transplantation at UC San Francisco, said in a statement that the hospital considers socioeconomic stability for all patients, including immigration status.

Navarro’s situation highlights a dilemma for hospitals when it comes to organ transplants for immigrants, especially if their undocumented status threatens their continued access to insurance:

Though no data are available, anecdotal evidence suggests clinics sometimes perform organ transplants on illegal immigrants, especially when the patients are young. In one high-profile case, UCLA Medical Center gave an undocumented woman three liver transplants before she turned 21.

But health administrators also reject patients because of their immigration status, though that usually happens when the patients lack insurance. Bellevue Hospital in New York attracted attention last year when it refused to transplant a kidney between brothers because they could not pay for the operation. [...]

Some bioethicists say the hospital should have performed the surgery because Navarro would not be taking resources away from other patients or putting his wife at serious risk.

After all, many legal residents fail to follow their post-surgical plan.

Some lawmakers would even want hospitals to check the immigration status for all patients. The Arizona legislature considered a bill that would require that, and Rep. Steve King (R-IA) said in November that it would not be going “too far” to have hospitals ask patients about their immigration status.

But in the meantime, Navarro’s private insurance from his job would cover the transplant and follow-up care, but he lost job last month after an immigration audit and his insurance could run out. If he is unable to extend his insurance and ends up in California’s Medi-Cal program, his problem would worsen because Medi-Cal would not cover the immunosuppressive drugs that prevent organ rejection after a transplant. “We don’t know what to do,” his wife said. “It’s like we’re on a ledge — we can’t go here or there.”

This post was originally published by ThinkProgress.


Related Stories:

Hospital: No Kidney Transplant For Girl With Disabilities

No Documents? Then No Health Care!

Profs Create Freedom University For Undocumented Students


Read more: , , , ,

Photo from niznoz via flickr

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it


+ add your own
8:24PM PDT on Mar 18, 2012

So he should get the transplant? What if a U.S. citizen needed it and it matched with him/her? Who should get it, the illegal undocumented immigrant or a U.S. Citizen??
What if it was you or one of your family members needing it and it was given to an undocumented immigrant instead. What would you say then???

2:08PM PST on Feb 16, 2012

WTF?! This is SO WRONG! He has the right to the transplant! What is wrong with you people?! He is a human being!

7:30PM PST on Feb 5, 2012

How does he have a job legally if he's an undocumented alien??

9:16PM PST on Feb 4, 2012

@ Christy E… “They should do the transplant” You haven’t explained WHY CAN’T THE MEXICAN HEALTH SYSTEM DO IT ?

8:08PM PST on Feb 2, 2012

This is a very sad state of affairs. They should do the transplant, but it seems that they would rather turn their backs and let the man die. Whether you're a citizen or not you should be able to get health care treatment, we are all citizens of the human race. Besides, the man had insurance, and until recently a job, so its not like he was 'gouging' the system as a lot of anti-immigrant bigots would like to say.

9:03AM PST on Feb 2, 2012

@ Mike B. The Mexican citizen can more appropriately get medical attention in his own country, Mexico. It isn’t far away, just across the border. Even Americans living in Mexico are happy with the excellent health care in Mexico. Many US citizens go without adequate health care, and you want to provide it for uninvited illegal border jumpers ? You don’t even qualify as having a brain.

11:21PM PST on Feb 1, 2012

the insurance is part of his compensation for years of hard work. his wife said she'll donate the kidney. and it's impossible to determine who will and won't get follow-up care. i remember a hand transplant patient who went m.i.a. even though they did extensive screening to find a good candidate. this man deserves to live.

11:12PM PST on Feb 1, 2012

Sad, thank you.

9:58PM PST on Feb 1, 2012

It is the duty of doctor to save life irrespective of his status as an immigrant and when he has personal insurance

8:43PM PST on Feb 1, 2012

Janet K,
If you think life is cheap here now just wait until Obamacare kicks in! You'll be paying through the nose for health insurance then if you need a kidney the "death panel" will tell you "sorry you're too old" now "go home and take a pain pill"

add your comment

Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Care2 - Be Extraordinary - Start a Care2 Petition
ads keep care2 free

Recent Comments from Causes

January 5/15 I moved to Sault Ste Marie, ON. I buy my groceries across the street from my apartment.…

Hope this beautiful and worthy little fox lives a long and deserving life. Kudos to the rescuer. Thanks…

I hope this cub doesn't get hunted down by the fox hunters

ads keep care2 free

more from causes

Select names from your address book   |   Help

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.

site feedback


Problem on this page? Briefly let us know what isn't working for you and we'll try to make it right!