START A PETITION 27,000,000 members: the world's largest community for good

ForestEthics Declared “Enemy of the People of Canada” for Criticism of Oil Sands Projects

ForestEthics Declared “Enemy of the People of Canada” for Criticism of Oil Sands Projects


Written by Lloyd Alter

In his book, Crude World: The Violent Twilight of Oil, Peter Maass showed how oil isn’t just environmentally dirty, it is an ethical and moral poison as well. Canadians are getting a taste of that poison right now, as the Prime Minister and his government unleash an unprecedented attack on those who oppose the Northern Gateway pipeline proposed to carry bitumen from the Alberta Tar Sands to the Pacific Coast.

First we had the Minister of Natural Resources attacking those against the pipeline as “radical groups” who:

use funding from foreign special interest groups to undermine Canada’s national economic interest. They attract jet-setting celebrities with some of the largest personal carbon footprints in the world to lecture Canadians not to develop our natural resources.

Now it appears that they are using Canadian tax rules as a hakapik to club charitable organizations into silence and submission. Yesterday Andrew Frank, until recently the Communications Director for ForestEthics, released an open letter that made a series of claims:

Today, I am taking the extraordinary step of risking my career, my reputation and my personal friendships, to act as a whistleblower and expose the undemocratic and potentially illegal pressure the Harper government has apparently applied to silence critics of the Enbridge Northern Gateway oil tanker/pipeline plan.

As I have detailed in a sworn affidavit, no less than three senior managers with TidesCanada and ForestEthics (a charitable project of Tides Canada), have informed me, as theSenior Communications Manager for ForestEthics, that Tides Canada CEO, Ross McMillan,was informed by the Prime Minister’s Office, that ForestEthics is considered an “Enemy of the Government of Canada,” and an “Enemy of the people of Canada.”

This language was apparently part of a threat by the Prime Minister’s Office to challenge the charitable status of Tides Canada if it did not agree to stop funding ForestEthics, specifically its work opposing oilsands expansion and construction of oilsands tanker/pipeline routes in Canada.

He was not planning on speaking out, but was apparently frustrated that nobody in the organizations involved was.

After waiting more than two weeks for Tides Canada to go public with this story, it has become clear to me that the organization is too afraid of reprisals from the government to act. Tides is responsible for the employment of hundreds of Canadians and dozens of crucial environmental projects like the Great Bear Rainforest, and has been understandably paralyzed in challenging the Prime Minister’s Office on this matter. I on the other hand, am speaking out as a private citizen because I feel that the rights and civil liberties of my fellowCanadian citizens, including freedom of expression and freedom of speech, are at risk.

Read the entire open letter here.

Andrew Frank was immediately fired from ForestEthics. In a press conference call, co-founder Ziporah Berman said, “He was let go because he broke confidentiality and trust; any person who acts unilaterally as an individual, then it is unprofessional and a breach of trust.” She also describes the atmosphere among supporters and donors, the almost McCarthyite scare that is going around:

Lets be clear, the tone of the Minister’s letter really do in a lot of ways harken back to another era, and people are extremely surprised and concerned. Canadians value democracy and free speech, and the government has overplayed its hand. Whatever you think about the pipeline, many agree that his government should be governing and not serving the oil industry…. and a lot of donors are getting scared that giving will result in reprisals, and this has made it difficult to plan.

Valerie Langer, Director of BC Forest Campaigns, said in a press release:

We share these concerns with Andrew Frank, who is clearly concerned about the government trying to silence Canadians. Andrew worked with us for many years and was a valued part of this organization. He is no longer a member of ForestEthics’ staff because he violated the confidence of the organization, and we are unable to carry out our work without a solid foundation of trust between colleagues.

But the bigger picture remains: It is a dark and chilling day for Canadians when our government tries to silence and intimidate non profit organizations like ForestEthics, and the thousands of citizens and civil groups who, like us, are concerned about the direction this country is taking and are speaking out.

In Canada, donations to approved charitable organizations are tax deductible. Charitable status is hard to get, and the rules regarding what charities can actually do are controversial and open to interpretation. The Canada Revenue Ministry regulations state that Charities may not participate in political activities, which include where the charity

Explicitly communicates to the public that the law, policy, or decision of any level of government in Canada or a foreign country should be retained (if the retention of the law, policy or decision is being reconsidered by a government), opposed, or changed.

However it also makes very clear that a small proportion of political activity is inherent in almost every charity, so they set limits, usually 10% of the charity’s assets.

After the Minister of Natural Resources specifically attacked Tides Canada and “foreign jet-setters”, Tides responded:

Merran Smith, director of Tides Canada’s Energy Initiative, says all Canadians deserve a voice in these conversations. “This contrived funding ‘debate’ is a red herring,” says Smith. “These are critical issues with long-term implications for Canada. We live in a democracy where all voices should be heard. It is totally appropriate for Tides Canada to support Canadian engagement in our public processes.”

It is not the least bit surprising to me that Stephen Harper would use the CRA and every tool at his disposal to stifle dissent; he is turning Canada into a Petro-state and turning himself into Hugo Chávez.

Alan Broadbent, a board member of Tides, summarized it nicely in the Globe and Mail:

Canada would be served better if the government let science speak, let the affected communities be heard, and let the full light of day shine. Demonizing the charitable and philanthropic sector is not in the national interest.

This post was originally published by TreeHugger.


Related Stories:

The Numbers Don’t Lie: We Don’t Need More Drilling

Victory! State Dept. Denies Keystone XL Pipeline Application

Top 10 US Species Threatened By Fossil Fuels


Read more: , , , , ,

Photo from NWFblog via flickr

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it


+ add your own
6:58AM PDT on Apr 6, 2013

Thank you for sharing.

9:30PM PDT on Mar 14, 2012

Thanks for the article.

5:48PM PST on Feb 23, 2012

Harper and his thugs are not only the enemies of Canadians, they are the enemies of humanity. The Nuremburg trials should be brought back and they get the same punishment as the Nazis who supported concentration camps.

2:24AM PST on Feb 23, 2012

There will be blood?

2:15AM PST on Feb 23, 2012


6:28AM PST on Jan 31, 2012


5:40PM PST on Jan 30, 2012

Harper is an absolute disgrace to the nation of Canada, and thinks that acting like an American republican like the imbecile George Bush, makes Canada better. Obviously, Harper is making the same mistake republicans in the USA have made.

12:21PM PST on Jan 29, 2012

Nothing will change until we break our addiction to oil.

11:03AM PST on Jan 29, 2012

Thanks for the information.

9:33AM PST on Jan 29, 2012

Noel S. - copy the petition website address from Susan's remarks. That's what I did to get to it.

add your comment

Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Care2 - Be Extraordinary - Start a Care2 Petition
ads keep care2 free

Recent Comments from Causes

Its so important that the dog has the against rabies injection at regular intervals you are protecting…

Good article, your all provided information is all right, keep your blogs on- Greets.

I couldn't possibly evict our cats from the bed! They're so cuddly and warm and very comforting when…

meet our writers

Beth Buczynski Beth is a freelance writer and editor living in the Rocky Mountain West. So far, Beth has lived in... more
ads keep care2 free

more from causes

Select names from your address book   |   Help

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.