New York City has agreed to pay $70 million over accusations of Medicaid fraud for a program intended to provide services for individuals with disabilities in their homes. For a decade, the city approved personal in-home care costing $75,000 to $150,000 a year for a number of individuals, but without “physically obtain[ing] the required assessments from doctors, nurses or social workers.” In other cases, the city also did not have periodic “independent medical reviews” conducted; these are required any time there is a dispute about the care involved. But while the settlement is being hailed for preventing abuses of the system, any sense of victory is already waning.
After Fraud Settlement, NYC Is “Paranoid” About Violating Medicaid Rules
Disability advocates say that their elderly clients are already being told by the city that it now intends to reduce or simply end 24-hour services such as bathing and toileting, services that had made it possible for many people to still live in their own residences rather than in nursing homes. That is, the $70 million settlement has caused the city to become ”so paranoid about violating Medicaid rules that it was threatening to withdraw services from patients,” as organizations including the Legal Aid Society and Selfhelp Community Services wrote in a letter to the United States attorney for Manhattan, Preet Bharara, and to the federal Medicaid administrator, Dr. Donald M. Berwick.
Robert Doar, the city’s commissioner of human resources, who oversees Medicaid in the city, said Friday that the city would not cut off services to people who needed them, but he acknowledged that as a result of the settlement, the city was being more vigilant about the rules.
Valerie Bogart, a lawyer at Selfhelp who signed the letter, said city officials had told her that 100 people received notices in the past week that their services would be discontinued.
City officials disputed that number, saying that notices were routine, and that if people believed they needed more hours, they could appeal the decision.
In other words, the people who genuinely need the services provided under Medicaid — which the federal government pays for about half of, and the state and city the rest — are being penalized because other people abused the system and because, it could also be argued, officials were not providing sufficient oversight.
1,200 Developmentally Disabled Adults Died of “Unknown” Causes in New York State Care
As for why people might prefer to live in their residences with the the support of in-home aides, one need only to read a separate New York Times article about the disturbingly high number of deaths of developmentally disabled adults in New York‘s state and privately run group homes and other institutional residences.
Photo by Just Jefa
Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may
not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.