A court case will start this week in the small Central American nation of Belize challenging that country’s criminalization of homosexuality. The case is supported by a new British-based group which hopes to challenge such laws throughout the world.
The Human Dignity Trust (HDT) was established by a high-powered group which includes the former attorney general of India; the former secretary general of the Commonwealth; Lord Woolf, former lord chief justice of England and Wales; and a former judge at the Intra-American court of human rights.
Criminalisation causes misery to all of those affected, compromising people’s identity through illegality. It also reduces human beings to their sexual acts.
We hope to bring approximately five to 10 cases globally each year. Where necessary we will fund cases. In the event of a prosecution, we can assist lawyers in preparing a defence challenging those laws. If appropriate, we may bring cases in our own name.
Most such laws are a legacy of British colonial rule. Countries formerly ruled by Belgium, Portugal or France generally do not have such laws.
The former British attorney general, Lord Goldsmith, will be among the team of lawyers taking on the constitutionality of section 53 of Belize’s criminal code, which says that: “Every person who has carnal intercourse against the order of nature with any person or animal shall be liable to imprisonment for 10 years.”
The case has been brought to court by United Belize Advocacy Movement (UNIBAM) and its Executive President Caleb Orozco.
Local churches have united in their opposition to decriminalization and will be present at the hearings. Amongst the evidence they say they will present will be that homosexuality can be “cured.” They will also tout the ‘foreign influence’ line as well as the ‘victimhood’ line flowing from US evangelical objections to LGBT human rights, saying:
“In every country that has granted a new ‘right’ to homosexual behaviour, activists have promoted and steadily expanded this ‘right’ to trump universally recognised rights to religious freedom and expression.”
The legal challenge is on the basis of international agreements which states are party to and, according to the Trust’s Chief Executive Jonathan Cooper, a human rights barrister, means that criminalizing homosexuality is illegal.
“We hope there will be a domino effect eventually, with countries recognising [that they will lose the test cases] and saying ‘Why don’t we just decriminalise?’”
Cooper told The Guardian that the Trust’s patrons “are not pursuing this as part of a lesbian and gay agenda. It’s an international rights law agenda.”
The criminalization laws were an issue at the recent Commonwealth Heads of Government meeting with the Commonwealth-appointed Eminent Persons Group, who cited their abolition as a key recommendation in an extensive Commonwealth reform document.
The legal challenge is supported by LGBT groups from throughout the region.
In the below video, Belizean Prime Minister Dean Barrow comments on the government’s position regarding the UNIBAM lawsuit to legalize homosexuality in Belize.
Notice the condescending tone.
Photo credit: World homosexuality laws map Wikipedia