START A PETITION 25,136,189 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x
1,852,869 people care about Human Rights

Hawaii Decides to Ship Homeless People Back to Mainland

Hawaii Decides to Ship Homeless People Back to Mainland

It sounds like the wave of a fairy godmother’s wand: the government will buy a homeless person a one-way plane ticket to live with her family far away.

It also sounds like deportation and budget-cutting: the government will compel a homeless person to leave its state or city so it can burden some other jurisdiction with the costs of shelter and other services.

In practice, it is both.

In July, Hawaii’s state legislature approved a three-year pilot project to send the homeless to stay with family on the mainland. It isn’t the first to dream this up: New York City has also bought plane and train tickets and even automobile gas cards to shoo the down-on-their-luck out of Gotham. San Francisco, Baton Rouge and Fort Lauderdale have also tried versions of the same approach.

What are they shooing people toward? Often it is just a different flavor of homelessness somewhere else. New York said it was delivering people to their families, but having relatives does not mean having a home. Cramming an extra body into a household is rarely a long-term solution. It tends to lead to couch-surfing, where a person without a home of her own moves from one household to another, forced to find new accommodations each time she wears out her welcome, until she runs out of sofas and ends up back on the street.

Think that family would never make a relative uncomfortable in their home, or even force her out on the street? Julie Bosman of The New York Times reported in 2009 on a family who had been living with the father’s mother until she threatened to kick them all out — including her grandchildren — when bills began to mount. The family had to resort to an intake center for homeless shelters.

In that case, the family was happy to go back where they came from, but that is not always the case.

Sometimes authorities offer one-way tickets only as the best of bad options, especially for people averse to shelters. According to the National Coalition for the Homeless, “Oftentimes local police departments run such programs offering the stark choices of going to a shelter, jail or hopping on a bus or plane home.”

What’s so bad about being forced into a shelter? Plenty. Some shelters are infested with lice, fleas, or bedbugs. Some guests have and spread communicable diseases. Violence is a problem. A particularly common complaint is theft of a guest’s meager belongings — perhaps most devastatingly, shoes. And shelters split families up into men-only and women-only buildings or rooms.

Even for those who prefer shelters to sleeping rough, gaining a berth in a facility for one night does not guarantee access the next night. Some places require the homeless to queue up beginning in the early afternoon; if someone can’t get there in time, maybe because they have a doctor’s appointment or a job interview or job training or a job, they won’t snag a bed.

Shelters can be such a raw deal, so a ticket to somewhere else may be the most appealing option. A new locale offers at least the hope that things will be better. And sometimes they are, but sometimes homeless individuals and families face the same obstacles — lack of education or training, a shortage of jobs, disabilities, addiction, mental illness and more — that they faced in the place that escorted them out.

For governments, on the other hand, it’s a cost-effective proposition. New York City reported that of all the people it ferried out of town, not a one landed back in a NYC shelter. There is no word on whether any of them showed up at a shelter in their new town.

Read more: , , , ,

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it

92 comments

+ add your own
9:05AM PDT on Sep 14, 2013

*epic double facepalm*

5:23AM PDT on Aug 15, 2013

I can only hope to never be a victim of being homeless.

It'd be an awful inconvenience for all getting used to a
different home, set of rules, probably different food
than what you'd really want. But, you can't really ask
for to many favors, they took you in, right?

6:20AM PDT on Aug 14, 2013

This could be a good or bad solution.

Has anyone considered the effect of Obamacare on homelessness? If you can claim someone as a dependent on your taxes, then you are responsible for their medical insurance. You don't have to actually claim them.

Suppose you are willing to take in your homeless cousin and her two kids. You are now providing all or almost all their support. If they live with you for six months and a day, guess what: you can now claim them on your tax return. I sure hope you have plenty of money for medical insurance!

1:30AM PDT on Aug 14, 2013

Homelessness and poverty can't be solved by punishing the homeless, surely.

9:26AM PDT on Aug 12, 2013

Politicians are our elected public servants & such should be obedient.However, once voted in they turn things on its head for their own benefit. Therefore non performing politicians must be given the boot, no time to entrench themselves in a comfy position.This is how it is throughout the world, politicians holding us all to ransom & its getting worse.

4:21AM PDT on Aug 12, 2013

Thanks for the information.

4:09AM PDT on Aug 12, 2013

I live on Maui and for years there has been the story and resentment that goes with it that agencies on the mainland were buying tickets to Hawaii for their problem people. I have no idea if it's true but I guess packing them up and sending them back is now the official plan. Good job everybody!!

8:39PM PDT on Aug 11, 2013

Thanks

6:25PM PDT on Aug 11, 2013

That sounds so crazy. It doesn't matter if the US is so rich, if you cannot afford a kid you should not have it in the first place. Also, the US is at the top of consumerism that makes it POORER!!

5:41PM PDT on Aug 11, 2013

noted

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Recent Comments from Causes

Entirely distressing. Their mindset must be horrible to not see women and girls as human beings.

I love rosemary and parsley as well, and have them growing in pots on my front porch. The weather is…

I dislike/ hate bull fighting a 1 sided outcome! living in Andalucia for much of the time I never have…

Story idea? Want to blog? Contact the editors!
ads keep care2 free

more from causes




Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.