START A PETITION 27,000,000 members: the world's largest community for good
2,664,724 people care about Human Rights

How Much Are US Victims of Forced Sterilization Owed?

  • 2 of 2

Some have suggested $20,000 for a settlement. 57-year-old Elaine Riddick, who was sterilized at 14 after becoming pregnant from rape and whose illiterate grandmother signed the consent form with an X on the urging of social workers, has sued the state for $1 million. While her case was appealed to the US Supreme Court, it has refused to hear it.

62-year-old Charles Holt thinks $30,000 might be enough. Sent to a state institution for people with mental and emotional issues after “fighting at school and masturbating openly,” Holt undergoing a vasectomy seems to have been a condition of his being able to leave to begin his adult life. A social worker convinced his mother that he have the surgery, noting that it would protect him “in case he were falsely accused of having fathered a child.”

It takes my breath away to think that, had my teenage son Charlie, who’s on the moderate to severe end of the autism spectrum, lived just half a century earlier, he could have suffered the same fate as Ramirez, Riddick and Holt.

The Winston-Salem Journal has an extensive report about forced sterilizations in North Carolina, including records from the Eugenics Board. Whatever settlements the state of North Carolina decides on, I don’t think it can ever be enough truly to compensate for the pain, suffering and inhumane treatment experiencing by too, too many.


Related Care2 Coverage

China’s “Leftover” Women

Academia’s Favorite Group of Racists Holds Annual Meeting

N.H. State Senator: Mentally Ill Should Be “Shipped To Siberia”


  • 2 of 2

Read more: , , , , , , , , ,

Photo by A.M/ Kuchling

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it


+ add your own
11:17PM PDT on Jun 8, 2012

I know I won't be popular saying this, so I'll start by saying I love multiculturalism. I wouldn't ever want to live in a white only city. I enjoy walking down a street and hearing a variety of languages. That said, I don't owe anyone in the past for what was done in the past. I'm tired of this white guilt we almost have been steeped in. I am not responsible for what my ancestors may or may not have done.

Have the Japanese ever 'apologized' for their death marches and the brutal treatment of Allied soldiers? Have they ever apologized to the Chinese for their attempts at genocide?

But if you insist on doing this because you feel guilty, well I want compensation from the French Catholics for taking my Huguenot ancestor's lands, their possessions and drove them out of France or killed them outright. I'm sure there are other atrocities and indignities my ancestors faced so how much government guilt money can I expect?

7:30PM PDT on Apr 13, 2012

forcably steralizing the mentally ill is not a bad idea. No that there are more checks and balances in our medical system. And the civil rights movement is well underway, having politicians of color, there are less chance of error and wrongful accusation. Of course not without due process and fair reasoning.
Very unfair for Ms. Riddick to not be heard. @ 14 they know it was wrong for them to treat her as the perpetrator as many women are.

8:33AM PDT on Apr 13, 2012

Quite a lot, I suppose. (Would the US budget go bankrupt?)

6:51PM PST on Mar 9, 2012

As I read this, it is just sad, sad, sad. The human race has been barbaric for so long, and once in a while in a generation, a brave soul will speak out at injustice, and cause change, ... but this was so recent, it boggles the mind, that we were so primitive in our social thinking. I have no answers about compensation, because the horror of it, is so much more than money could recompense. Just sorry for the victims who have had to live in a time when this was done to them. so sorry

8:57PM PST on Dec 19, 2011

Whether or not to deprive anyone of a God given right is a monumental question, especially with such a significant action as sterilisation. As is usual, it's not the rule but the interpretation that's the problem.

At sixteen I went out with a boy whose older sister was severely mentally challenged. At 24 she started disappearing with boys/men who really only used her for sex and she often ended up a surprisingly long way from home with no idea of where she was or where to go.

She had no concept of reproduction other than babies were made while having sex so she believed she was pregnant. It was suggested to her parents she should be sterilised, an agonising thought for them, but her disappearances were traumatic, all the more so because of her incapacity, and had she fallen pregnant the baby would become the family's responsibility, or be adopted out.

They were not in a position to raise another child, they still had an 8yo late comer and were just scraping by financially. Pregnancy itself would have been extremely challenging and she would have been devastated to have the baby taken away. Mentally compromised people have human feelings and drives we all do.

Could they have given her the pill? Maybe, but maintaining that can be easier said than done and it's not infallible. In the end it was the best solution for all concerned. She continued to believe she could have babies but there was no longer the worry that she actually would.

9:54AM PST on Dec 15, 2011

I certainly know some people who should be sterilized. My family ended up with my step-sister, only to find out that her drug addicted mother is pregnant, and homeless again. Should she be sterilized and her current children be taken away? Definitely!!

10:47PM PST on Dec 13, 2011

I tend to agree with you, Linda V. I know a few who should not have procreated, and does the name Michelle Duggar mean anything? Let's see, how about Octomom? I know a few men as well, who should have been forced to be sterilized, and do think there are situations which advocate for doing that to a person, whether female or male. It shouldn't JUST because of race, poverty level, education or intelligence, although if one is absolutely unable mentally to care for a child, then yes, they should not create one. Same if they cann't afford to support a child............don't CREATE one. There needs to be some common sense used, and if I was told just because I didn't have "X" amount of money in the bank, or I was lacking a college education, then I shouldn't have a child, I'd be fighting tooth & nail about it. I think I have enough common sense, MYSELF to not want to do that if I couldn't support a child at that time, however, and nobody should make that decision for me. Now, IF I wasn't able t make such a decision, then maybe others should be given that ability. Does that make sense?

1:08PM PST on Dec 13, 2011

Really Teri - so have you volunteered to be sterilized? Stupidity is a family trait as is ignorance. I would think along with caring about Animals you should care about maintaining the human gene pool at its highest possible levels. Clearly, based on your statements your contributions should be minimized.

10:16AM PST on Dec 13, 2011

it's about time!!! there are way too many people in the world as it is, and i for one am tired of supporting every damn public aid baby and immigrant just because they were born in the united states and their ignorant parents can't provide for them. I DON'T WANT TO PROVIDE EITHER!! i totally support forced sterilization, especially for stupid people who continuously breed and breed and breed, just because they can and have someone supporting their unwanted offspring.

9:36AM PST on Dec 13, 2011

A reasonable assessment would have to take into account that the average American family has two children and would deduct the expenses saved by not having said children.

add your comment

Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Care2 - Be Extraordinary - Start a Care2 Petition
ads keep care2 free

Recent Comments from Causes

The man is a "mini Hitler." He wants to dictate the lives of those about him. Teachers who carried signed…

"Can Chaffetz’s Last Minute Bid for Speaker Work?" Nope. Not without approval of the tea baggers. He…

A very cute fox cub. Bravo to the rescuer! Great work.

meet our writers

Kristina Chew Kristina Chew teaches and writes about ancient Greek and Latin and is Online Advocacy and Marketing... more
ads keep care2 free

Select names from your address book   |   Help

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.

site feedback


Problem on this page? Briefly let us know what isn't working for you and we'll try to make it right!