START A PETITION 27,000,000 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x
3,177,974 people care about Animal Welfare

In a Move Surprising No One, Animals Feel Emotions, Making Humans Feel Threatened

In a Move Surprising No One, Animals Feel Emotions, Making Humans Feel Threatened

The New York Times published an op-ed on October 5th that has the internet abuzz. The point of the piece is that dogs look forward to things they enjoy.

This is not news to anyone who has ever had a dog, or known a dog, or been awake in the vicinity of a dog. They wag their tails — sometimes their entire rear ends — when something happy this way comes. They do not keep their excitement secret.

The only truly newsworthy morsel in the Times piece, which was written by Emory scientist Gregory Berns, is that for the first time, MRI machines have captured images of dogs’ brains when they learn that something they like is being offered. Those images look a lot like pictures of humans’ brains when they are in the same situation.

A region of the brain called the caudate nucleus is in charge of anticipating good things in humans. The new MRI results make it hard to dispute that the same structure does the same thing in dogs. It lit up when dogs in MRI machines (wearing earmuffs, because those contraptions are ear-bleedingly loud) saw hand signals that indicated food and when they smelled a familiar human.

No one had done this research before because they couldn’t get dogs to enter and stay still in MRI machines without sedating them. Berns and his colleagues used positive reinforcement to persuade dogs to cooperate, allowing the machines to take pictures of their brains while they were awake and could respond to stimuli. Dogs who didn’t like it could leave. All of them were members of local families, starting with Berns’s own rescued dog Callie.

It wasn’t Berns’s result that got netizens jumping, but the conclusion he drew from it: “dogs are people, too.” He contended that their ability to experience positive emotions makes it wrong to treat them as property, which we currently do.

Asserting that there is a moral distinction between an animal and dirt, and that there should be a legal distinction between them too, invariably draws howls of protest because it’s hard to justify exploiting animals if we aren’t better than they are in some important way. This doctrine is known as human exceptionalism. The more similar we are to other animals, the more uncomfortable people become with eating, wearing and caging them.

Science is doggedly knocking down every wall exceptionalists have thrown up between humans and other animals. In the past using tools, using language and transmitting culture down through generations have all been brandished as the final frontier between us and them, until scientists found nonhuman animals who do each of these things. The new battleground is emotion. The Washington Post notes, “The idea that animals have emotional lives and are capable of detecting emotions in others has been gaining ground for decades.”

In 2011, an experiment demonstrated that rats feel empathy, so much so that they will selflessly give up their own food (chocolate chips, no less) to a rat having a bad day who didn’t get any. The bad day consisted of being locked in a cage; researchers found that a free rat would figure out how to open the cage and would release the other rat even without the expectation of a reward.

Evidence that one of the species we malign most can feel, sympathize with, and take action to remedy another’s pain drove people nuts — including the one who studied the rats. Instead of allowing that we should be kinder to rats, or that we shouldn’t assume we are the only creatures on the planet who can be nice to others, they announced that empathy is meaningless. Neurobiologist Peggy Mason, who ran the study, believes that empathy is “closer to a reflex than a thought.” Primatologist Frans de Wall agrees, saying that selflessly helping others who need it is a “fairly automatic” process.

Contrast that with the great pains religions have taken for eons to browbeat people into doing what the rats did. It is said that all of Judaism can be boiled down to one directive: treat your neighbor as you want to be treated. Christianity and the Golden Rule teach the same thing. To be a good person, if you find your neighbor trapped in a cage, let her out. If you are truly virtuous, you might even give her some of your chocolate chips.

As long as that edict distinguished human beings, it merited countless hours of sermons and Sunday school. Apparently it was accepted that it would take a lot of repetition to get the lesson into our selfish skulls.

Now that we know other animals practice the Golden Rule, though, people have suddenly decided that it is just an automatic process. If you aren’t doing it, you aren’t a sinner in need of confession; your automatic processes are on the fritz and you should get thee to a doctor. No word on a treatment for the poor diseased non-empathizers.

In short, people will sacrifice their highest spiritual ideals if it means they can keep treating animals like dirt without remorse. Even rats know better.

Read more: , , , , , ,

Photo credit: Thinkstock/iStock

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it

128 comments

+ add your own
8:32AM PDT on Jun 9, 2014

thanks for sharing :)

11:07AM PDT on Mar 24, 2014

the part when the rats give up food is so awesome!!

10:43PM PST on Dec 1, 2013

ty

3:55AM PST on Nov 27, 2013

The two emotions are not conflicting, but complementary

6:39PM PST on Nov 24, 2013

Thanks for sharing this great article!

6:23PM PST on Nov 24, 2013

Humans in general are a lesser form of life that have yet to prove they have any right whatsoever to share this earth with animals and plants.

8:00AM PST on Nov 14, 2013

great article

9:29AM PDT on Oct 26, 2013

you're absolutely right! Scientists recently did an MRIi that shows that dogs have feelings! Something we animal lovers knew without an MRI

6:40PM PDT on Oct 24, 2013

Please do NOT lump all people as being threatened by animal emotions. Any pet owner, zoo worker, animal rescue or foster person would tell you, we've all known this and don't need anybody to verfy that wildlife feels. Not one of us feels threatened. On the contrary, I believe most of us would tell you we feel blessed to be trusted by our various family members, or charges. To be trusted by an animal is the highest compliment I can think of.

4:15PM PDT on Oct 21, 2013

It is humans who don't have emotion and feeling. They will kill anyone or destroy anything that is in their way, or whatever they desire to have, they will do so in the name of their own benefits. That's what I know about humans. Didn't we prove ourselves by looking into what we have done to this planet?

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Care2 - Be Extraordinary - Start a Care2 Petition
ads keep care2 free
CONTACT THE EDITORS

Recent Comments from Causes

I'm glad to hear that Russo was reunited with his dog. As for the ex, she is one nasty piece of work.…

Well, very interesting of a dog that was rescued and opening one of his Christmas presents!

So very sad...and an insulting, stupid ad campaign.

ads keep care2 free



Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.