Is ‘Baiting’ an Ethical Way to Photograph Wild Owls?

Owls make for stunning photography subjects thanks to their uniqueappearanceand air of perpetual astonishment, but they’re also the source of a hot debate in the wildlife photography community. The main point of contention? “Baiting,” or the practice of putting out mice or other treats to draw the birds of preycloser.

I first heard about this controversy while on an owling walk a few weeks ago, and I quickly found myself falling into a rabbit hole of an argument that reveals a lot about the ethics of wildlife photography.

The growing accessibility of camera equipment, paired with a reemergingappreciation for nature, means that more and more photographers areseekingthe perfect wildlife shot. An owl swooping down after prey can be visually striking, and also a rare moment for a photographer relying on timing and patience to get a picture.

My wildlife photographer friends rely on tactics like camera traps, camping out and waiting for hours, sometimes not even getting a single usable shot on any given day. But there’s a shortcut: Put out a meal or something that looks like one.

A Canadian birder wrote about an awkward and upsetting encounter when she got wind of an owl for her life list and went to check it out. When she arrived to see a great grey owl in person, she found a crowd of birders and photographers.

At first, she thought that the groupwassimply appreciating the bird, but she quickly realized that the photographers were tossing out mice to get better shots. The owl started behaving strangely, and she found herself in an ethical quandary, wondering if she should say something or not.

While baiting is not just used on owls, Scott Weidensaul of the Audubon Society notes that there are some particularethical issues with baiting owls and raptors. For starters, the birds can becomehabituated to humans if they’re fed — and that’s not good. We need raptors to stay wild and give people a wide berth.

In particular, birders have noticed an increase in vehicle deaths, noting that people may be baiting owls near or even on the road to get a clear, unobstructed shot from a very convenient location. The owls learn to associate people with food. As a result, the birds dismiss the road as a safety risk, so they’re often injured or killed by passing traffic.

Raptors shouldhunt for their own food, because it’s part of their healthy behavioral patterns. When they’re fed by photographers and others seeking to get acloser look, it can disrupt their lives, which isn’t good for the longevity of the species.

While biologistscan and do use bait in some settings while conducting research, they do so with ethical oversight — and sparingly — because they want to allow their subjects to live as naturally as possible.

It can be frustrating to take a trip to see owls or other wildlife and not spot a single individual. For instance, we saw a grand total of one on our owling walk, though we heard many others, including barn owls, screen owls, great horned owls and spotted owls.

Photographers sometimes travel hundreds or thousands of miles for that special moment, and some aren’t just snapping casual shots, but compiling books and exhibits.

The ethical divide over baiting is driven by birders and photographers who reject the practice entirely, and those who do it, but may have varying opinions on where and when it’s appropriate.

If you think it’s impossible to get a good shot without baiting, check out Ethical Owl Photography, which showcases images taken without baiting or harassment.

Happy Friday everyone! Congrats @joesulik on your feature 🎉 This shot of a Great Gray Owl coming into land is stunning! Take a moment to visit this artist’s gallery! Photo chosen by: @theafternoonbirder 🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹 @ethicalowlphotos enjoys the natural beauty of owls. Please do not tag baited or harassed pictures of owls or owls in captivity. Not sure if your photo qualifies? Read Audubon’s Guide to Ethical Bird Photography linked in our profile to find out. 🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹 Tag your ethical owls to #ethicalowlphoto for a chance to be featured. Share this account with your followers so we can 🔹spread awareness🔹 about ethical owl photography.

A post shared by Ethical Owl Photos (@ethicalowlphotos) on

For consumers of wildlife photography, like me, there’s another problem: If we think baiting is unethical and don’t want to support it, how do we know if a photograph features a baited owl, or one snapped in natural conditions? Some photographers are proactively describing the circumstances in which photos were taken, and specifically asking may serve as an incentive to let owls behave naturally.

Photo credit: Matt Biddulph

83 comments

Marie W
Marie W3 months ago

Thanks for sharing.

SEND
Margie FOURIE
Margie FOURIE8 months ago

I think we all try to bribe an animal with treats when we need to - like on a trip to the vet. Even the vets do this.

SEND
Georgina E M
Georgina M8 months ago

tyfs

SEND
Laura McGowan
Laura McGowan8 months ago

I had no idea this was a problem or that it even happened. As much as I love the awesome owl photos I've seen, I'd hate to know the owls were baited or harassed to get them. It could only lead to further mortalities in that the owls would see humans as food providers.

SEND
Rosslyn O
Rosslyn O8 months ago

Flagged spammer Denise B for the 8th time tonight...Like how many times do you have to flag them to get them off this site? Does anyone know?

SEND
Rosslyn O
Rosslyn O8 months ago

No baiting should not be allowed. Too many lazy human beings taking short cuts! These birds are wild and free, and stay away from humans, so how dare they feed them to ruin aeons of mother natures rules. It always take a human to wreck this planet and it natural laws.

SEND
Telica R
Telica R8 months ago

Thanks for sharing

SEND
Past Member
Past Member 8 months ago

Twila H. Never mind. I think i got my answer judging from comments. I honestly did not think this was big deal but if it harms them in any way then no.

SEND
Past Member
Past Member 8 months ago

Twila H. I am bit confused? Does this hurt them in anyway? If yes, then no baiting.

SEND
Twila H
Twila H8 months ago

As a photographer, I can attest to the hours and days spent working/waiting for that one great shot. Back in the days of film, I sometimes burned through a whole roll(s) and not have anything usable other than everyday/ho-hum photos to add to an album. No to baiting! Thanks for sharing!

SEND