START A PETITION 25,136,189 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x
1,367,302 people care about Politics

Is Kony 2012 Actually Helping Ugandans?

Is Kony 2012 Actually Helping Ugandans?

Editor’s Note: Due to the recent controversy over Invisible Children and their Kony 2012 campaign, we have two articles with differing perspectives for you. To read the other side, click here.

The recent viral video aimed at drawing attention to African war criminal Joseph Kony has drawn acclaim, but also harsh criticism. The video attempts to sum up, in half an hour, a 26-year conflict in Uganda and the surrounding regions of Africa – particularly the plight of child soldiers. None of this is a bad thing – it’s an issue that needs to be addressed. Whatever criticisms one might level against Invisible Children’s administrative policies or approach, the hearts of the founders are clearly in the right place.

Watching the video initially, I was moved by its message – but uncomfortable with what appeared to be a blatant merchandizing effort near the end, when Invisible Children promotes its $30 “action kits,” a collection of posters, stickers and bracelets meant to raise awareness about Joseph Kony, in the hopes that increased attention would pressure US lawmakers to support Kony’s capture. Is wearing a Kony 2012 t-shirt really going to do anything to help end a war in Africa? Turns out, that’s only the tip of the increasingly problematic iceberg.

Accusations that the video is inaccurate

First of all, as Joshua Keating of Foreign Policy points out, Joseph Kony is not actually in Uganda. In fact, he hasn’t been active in the country for 6 years. Not only that, but the Lord’s Resistance Army is not the huge fighting force portrayed in the video: their numbers are in the hundreds at most. This is not to say that the LRA is not continuing to cause trouble in Africa, or that Kony shouldn’t be brought to justice – but it’s not right for Invisible Children to misinform people about the nature of the conflict in Uganda.

This is a sentiment echoed by Adam Branch, a Senior Research Fellow at the Makerere Institute of Social Research – an expert, on the ground in Uganda. He describes the issues he’s had with Invisible Children’s videos and campaigns over the years, and questions Invisible Children’s promotion of US military presence as the answer to conflict in Uganda.

Some say the campaign ignores African voices

Rosebell Kagumire, a Ugandan journalist and blogger, even posted a video response to Kony 2012, in which she describes her frustration with the simplistic way the video portrayed the conflict in Uganda and her feelings on the stories of actual Ugandans being ignored and glossed over by Invisible Children:

An article by Semhar Araia in the Christian Science Monitor also took Invisible Children to task for not using the stories and voices of actual Africans involved in the conflict, and for imposing the idea that Americans are more suited to solving Uganda’s problems than the citizens of the country themselves are. The Atlantic also addressed this issue, even going so far as to say the campaign does more harm than good.

Mike Pflanz, a Telegraph correspondent in Nairobi, traveled to Uganda to get the feedback of locals who’d seen Invisible Children’s video. What he found was frustration and anger over the mischaracterizations of Kony’s current activities in the video. Those he interviewed argued that increased attention might simply spur Kony to go on the offensive, kidnapping more children and harming more people. Some were frustrated at the suggestion that US military action was the answer to the problem. A Ugandan government official even advanced the cynical suggestion that the video was made simply to further Invisible Children’s own agenda and raise money, rather than actually helping capture Kony.

Questions about Invisible Children’s financial practices

That’s not all – Invisible Children has also been accused of having shady accounting practices, with less than 1/3 of their income actually going toward helping children in Africa. Interestingly enough, in their response to the criticism, IC hasn’t disputed this, instead emphasizing that their campaign involves a three-pronged approach, and that the other 2/3 of the money they raise goes to advocacy campaigns and awareness efforts. There’s not anything necessarily wrong with how they’re allocating funds – it’s not illegal, but it may be disappointing to potential donors to realize how little of their money is actually going to programs in Africa.

Other charity efforts to help child soldiers in Uganda

Overall, it seems that the Kony 2012 campaign is well-intentioned, and IC is passionate about bringing a war criminal to justice. The fact that they’re targeting their efforts toward Americans, rather than working with Africans who are actually affected by the issue is problematic. The fact that they spend so much of the money they raise on producing videos and spreading the word, rather than funding programs in Uganda, bothers me. The response of Ugandans to a video they consider patronizing, simplistic and misleading doesn’t exactly bolster my willingness to financially support the organization.

If you’re still moved by the video and want to help efforts to help former and present child soldiers, capture Kony and improve conditions in Uganda, but have been turned off by all the negative publicity surrounding Invisible Children, the Huffington Post has a great article detailing seven other charities dedicated to the cause.

Your opinions?

What do Care2 readers make of the controversy surrounding Kony 2012? Are you going to participate in the April 20th campaign to spread awareness? Are you going to lobby your representatives and senators on the issue? I’d love to hear your comments and thoughts.

Related Stories:

Rush Limbaugh Backs Child Kidnappers

Rebel Army Conducts Mass Abduction Campaign

Ugandan ’Kill Gays’ Bill Reaches Back into US Politics

Read more: , , , , ,

Photo credit: Chris Shultz

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it

77 comments

+ add your own
6:13AM PDT on Mar 26, 2012

This has been a very interesting debacle to follow, with so many conflicting views and my own personal view. I was touched by the video however the misleading facts aggravated me and it makes me sick to think that they fail to mention that Kony himself has actually been missing for 6 years and a lot of the fighting has simmered down. Now just because I see these facts doesn't mean that I don't want the violence to stop.
I also believe that encouraging the US to go around poking into more foreign affairs is a very good way to cause a lot of trouble and massive loss of life, not just those who are 'guilty' but also innocent Ugandans. It would be a much better idea to help the local Ugandans come together and fight the problem of child solders and the LRA that way rather then having the US come in all guns blazing.
Raising awareness is one thing but raising the wrong awareness and misleading others in order to gain money is wrong. Especially when you go around upsetting the locals.
I've not said this in any aims to upset anyone or come across as insulting I'm simply voicing my views.

8:38AM PDT on Mar 25, 2012

Years ago I was a little obsessed with what was going on in Uganda as well as other countries in Africa. I think it is great to raise awareness. When I first saw the video that was my first thought, but agree that the focus should be on empowerment and less on "us" swooping in to help. I think that aid work and US involvement is a very useful tool but again the focus of this video is misplaced. There is much we could be doing right now in post war efforts and rehabilitation of rescued children. I think more funds should be going towards that and less towards the Ugandan army, especially when Kony is not in Uganda. Had this video been made 6 or 7 years ago it would be more to the point but again way to simplified. Thanks for this.

11:17AM PDT on Mar 16, 2012

thanks

7:45AM PDT on Mar 16, 2012

@ Mary E. : with regard to child slavery and exploitation ~

I believe we should all be opposed to all slavery in total all around the world, irregardless of our widely differing political and philosophical leanings on here ~ slavery and slave trading is probably one of the topics that the overwhelming majority on here will unite against...

NOT just child slavery, or sex slaves, or forced labour in some remote African mines and farms ~ but ALL cases of "bonded" labour, forced labour, sold or stolen children and women, political prisoners in "re-education camps" ~ wherever and whenever it is happening ..

There are STILL tens of millions of people being held and used as slaves around the world, largely in parts of Africa and Asia (with some regularly smuggled into western countries..); more than 2 million of these being "traded" every year, and over 250,000 being smuggled/transported across borders as well.

While child slavery and the sex slave trade get most of the public attention, those sectors are still only small parts of the much bigger picture..

ALL forms of slavery are perverse and abhorrent...

8:21PM PDT on Mar 13, 2012

It is good to see this video. Thank you for sharing it with us

8:05PM PDT on Mar 12, 2012

This is the office statement of Invisible Children in regard to the criticism they have faced,http://s3.amazonaws.com/www.invisiblechildren.com/critiques.html

3:30PM PDT on Mar 12, 2012

Interesting reading.

3:28PM PDT on Mar 12, 2012

I don't know if this is helping or hindering the Uganda efforts; but if child slavery is happening there, whether in Uganda or other areas, it should be stopped. I watched the video and was very upset by it. It reminded me of the movie Blood Diamonds.

1:43PM PDT on Mar 12, 2012

Thank you for your post and information.

1:34PM PDT on Mar 12, 2012

Thanks for the article!

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Recent Comments from Causes

Actually real Satanists, unlike these play-pretend ones, aren't a joke. They tend to be active Nazis,…

First, I'm not certain you can make this statement "Some of the antibiotics found included drugs that…

There would be no need to officially close off areas to the public if said public showed decency &…

meet our writers

Julie M. Rodriguez Julie M. Rodriguez is an arts, green living, and political writer based in San Mateo, CA. Her work... more
Story idea? Want to blog? Contact the editors!
ads keep care2 free

more from causes




Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.