START A PETITION 27,000,000 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x

Why I’m Giving Obama and Romney a B in Science

Why I’m Giving Obama and Romney a B in Science
  • 1 of 2

Scientific American and grassroots organization ScienceDebate.org have asked President Barack Obama and GOP presidential candidate Mitt Romney to respond to 14 questions on some of the biggest scientific and technological challenges facing the nation.

Romney Wins?

Romney fares better than you might think as  says on Slate.While Obama has the “most scientifically accomplished administration” including physicist and MacArthur genius John Holdren as his head science advisor and a roster on the President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology that is “lousy with university deans, officers of the National Academies of Science, and Nobel Prize winners,” Helmuth explains how Romney seems to have won the upper hand in this particular debate about science:

If you scroll through [the responses] quickly, one thing is immediately apparent: Mitt Romney’s team took this very seriously. His answers are longer, they have subtitles, they have bullet points. It’s not just great presentation: The Romney text is substantive, specific, and detailed. Obama’s answers to some of the same questions are single paragraphs that are vague, repetitive (two in a row start with “Since taking office”), and poorly written.

Indeed, Romney’s answers for some of the questions — (1) innovation and economy, (2) climate change, (4) pandemics and biosecurity, (5) education, (12) space —  are much longer, offer more details and cite outside studies (by Harvard researchers in all three instances). Helmuth singles out Romney’s answer for “pandemics and biodiversity,” about the diseases like the avian flu and biological warfare:

This question is an invitation to show strong leadership, expertise, creativity, and a sense of urgency. Obama’s answer starts like this: “We all are aware that the world is becoming smaller every day.”

Romney nailed it. An excerpt of his answer: “To further improve preparedness, we must continue to invest in the best public health monitoring systems that can be built. I will also encourage advancements in research and manufacturing to increase scientific understanding of new pathogens and improve response time when they emerge. The development of new countermeasures, from diagnostics to antibiotics and antivirals to respirators, will help protect human lives in the face of new bugs and superbugs.”

But if you can get past the occasional tepidness of Obama’s remarks, you can see that his team’s main error is that they took too literal a view of the task and just answered the questions without brio, but thoughtfully. Romney’s answers stray from the topic, thereby enabling him to assert certain pet points.

Obama Has Plenty to Say But He Could Dress It Up Better

For instance, Obama responds to the education question about “what role should the federal government play to better prepare students of all ages for the science and technology-driven global economy” in the most straightforward manner possible, by calling on efforts to “strength STEM education” in a simple, poorly organized paragraph.

Romney’s response looks great, with bold-face subject headings and bullet points, but a closer reading shows it to be a rehashing of his education platform, slightly adapted and complete with teachers union-bashing.

  • 1 of 2

Read more: , , , , , , ,

Graphic by Cain and Todd Benson

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it

86 comments

+ add your own
12:36PM PDT on Sep 17, 2012

Republicans have NO intention of EVER cooperating with ANY Democrat in office. They are against women, children and the middle class. Why they have become so obstructive over the years I can only guess is that they want more money in their pockets and to hell with the rest of the nation. Vote Republicans out of office in every state and at every opportunity.

3:26AM PDT on Sep 17, 2012

It sounds to me like Obama gets a B, being marked down for poor presentation.
Romney gets a D for failing to address the questions set, and an F- for his coursework (his "sound science" on climate change, for instance).

1:45AM PDT on Sep 17, 2012

let your voice be heard-VOTE

11:23AM PDT on Sep 16, 2012

Thank you.

9:53AM PDT on Sep 16, 2012

Thanks for sharing.

7:49AM PDT on Sep 16, 2012

What would the civilized world do without the opinion of Dr. Chew. We can always look to her unbiased absolutely mind boggling insight into things scientific. I am so glad that Stephen Hawkins,Shirley Ann Jackson, and Nikodem Poplawski have had the good fortune to be able to fall back on the amazing strength in knowledge of the scientific wunderkind Kristina Chew ! I am so glad Ms. Chew is so readily available to GRADE the scientific knowledge of politicians with her interpretation of the Mighty Chew exam for measuring scientific Knowledge ! Such amazing skill and insight and ability she demonstrates in her self confident judgmental journeys into academia ! Lo the fortune our specie enjoys being alive during her magnanimous tenure ! Really ? I mean Really ?

3:01AM PDT on Sep 16, 2012

thanks

5:23PM PDT on Sep 15, 2012

I'll take Obama any day of the week as opposed to ANY Republican.

3:17PM PDT on Sep 14, 2012

Thanks for sharing!

11:44AM PDT on Sep 14, 2012

So, in matters of fact, style outweighs substance? Sounds like a very Republican view.

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Care2 - Be Extraordinary - Start a Care2 Petition
ads keep care2 free
CONTACT THE EDITORS

Recent Comments from Causes

Whoa! Militant much? Even though what is pointed out is mostly true, making statements like "forget…

Shooting them is bad enough, but the use of horrifically cruel traps, long-acting poisons and hanging,…

oh Freddy you have out done yourself with the BS you post you really need to stop drinking the republinazi…

meet our writers

Kristina Chew Kristina Chew teaches and writes about ancient Greek and Latin and is Online Advocacy and Marketing... more
ads keep care2 free



Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.