START A PETITION 25,136,189 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x
3,467,876 people care about Animal Welfare

Photographer Jailed After Taking Aerial Pics of Cattle Feedlot

Photographer Jailed After Taking Aerial Pics of Cattle Feedlot

A world-renowned National Geographic photographer was arrested on June 28th after paragliding over a Kansas cattle feedlot to take photos.

George Steinmetz‘s speciality is aerial photography. Strapped into a paraglider, he captures stunning images ranging from desert vistas to African savannahs. It wasn’t unusual that he was once again aloft on June 28th, flying high over a feedlot near Garden City, Kansas to capture images for his current project on food issues.

Unfortunately, Steinmetz and his paraglider instructor, Wei Zhang, apparently didn’t get permission from the landowner to park their vehicle on its property or to launch their paraglider from there.

A feedlot employee reportedly noticed the paraglider circling above the facility, as well as the unfamiliar vehicle parked on the property, and alerted the local police. Steinmetz and Zhang moved to a different location, but were arrested anyway.

County law enforcement officials took Steinmetz and Zhang into custody and charged them with misdemeanor criminal trespass. They were held briefly and released after posting $270 bond.

“We had an obligation to the property owner, since they had driven on the property without permission and it was clearly posted,” Finney County Sheriff Kevin Bascue told NorthJersey.com.

Since Steinmetz did not coordinate his overflight or picture taking with the feedlot, the operators had no way of knowing why he was up there. The Kansas Livestock Association (KLA) believes this easily could have been a food security issue.

KLA spokesman Todd Domer told Hutch News that a situation like this is a biosecurity matter for the facility. “Any unauthorized and suspicious activity should be reported to local law enforcement,” he said.

So far, this is not an “ag-gag” case, though the buzz surrounding the circumstances gives it that feel. In 1990, Kansas passed the United States’ first “ag-gag” law, known as the Kansas Farm Animal and Field Crop and Research Facilities Protection Act. Among other things, it prohibits individuals from entering and taking pictures or video in an animal facility that is not open to the public.

Whether Steinmetz could be charged under the state’s “ag-gag” law is questionable. By flying over the facility, did he “enter” the property? There’s no clear answer. The issue of how far above the ground ownership of property legally extends remains unsettled.

According to an article prompted by this incident at Slate.com, the federal government considers the area above 500 feet to be navigable airspace in uncongested areas. Arguably, this means private ownership of airspace “probably ends somewhere between 80 and 500 feet above the ground.” This factor may be why the charges against Steinmetz and Zhang so far have not included an “ag-gag” allegation in addition to trespassing.

The Finney County Office of the County Attorney released a statement clarifying the nature of the charges in this case, which said:

Much discussion has ensued surrounding the arrest of Mr. Steinmetz and his employee regarding the right to air space and to take photographs. The charges in no way are related to those two issues and focus on the landowners right to privacy and control over their property.

A well-publicized attempted prosecution for violation of a state “ag-gag” law occurred earlier this year in Utah. Activist Amy Meyer was arrested and charged with violation of Utah’s law for standing on a public street and using her cell phone to videotape a bulldozer being used to move a downed cow. After much public outcry, authorities dropped the charges.

It’s not yet clear what the future holds for George Steinmetz. He apparently noted in an interview some time ago that he has been arrested before while taking aerial photographs, so this adventure may be familiar territory to him.

National Geographic issued a statement that said, in part: “We believe [Steinmetz] did not break any laws and have reached out to local officials about the incident. We are awaiting more information. If the matter does require legal action, National Geographic will provide for his and his assistant’s defense.”

Related Stories:

Woman Arrested for Dastardly Crime of Filming a Slaughterhouse

Ag Gag Bill Introduced as Butterball Worker is Convicted of Cruelty

California and Indiana Kill Ag-Gag Bills. But the Fight’s Not Over

Read more: , , , , ,

Photo Credit: Thinkstock

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it

117 comments

+ add your own
7:26PM PDT on Sep 8, 2013

Jane R. and Kyle N.. Wrong! They are Kansas terrorists indulging in horrific animal cruelty and Monsanto or USDA environmental destruction. They do what the mafia or psychopaths do to cover up their crimes.. pass laws with the help of their criminal government partners like "Ag-gag" to kill any messengers. I have no sympathy for terrorists calling themselves "farmers" or "ranchers". They should be bankrupted, their so called "property" ripped from them forever, and then thrown in jail as domestic terrorists. What part of that don't you get?

2:57AM PDT on Aug 8, 2013

thanks for sharing

1:01PM PDT on Aug 1, 2013

People, they were not arrested for taking pictures of the feedlot. They were arrested for TRESPASSING! Once the worker reported a vehicle on the property the law had no choice but make an arrest.
"We had an obligation to the property owner, since they had driven on the property without permission and it was clearly posted,” Finney County Sheriff Kevin Bascue told NorthJersey.com."

They should have cleared it with the property owner first, nut maybe they thought he'd charge a fee, which I think he should!

4:53AM PDT on Jul 28, 2013

First thought; what are they hiding?

12:57AM PDT on Jul 28, 2013

unlike Texas where you dont even own the rights to the property under your house...where fracking pipelines can pump tons of chemicals under your house, poison your water and its legal...but this guy cant take pictures in the sky...this country is doomed..watch GASLAND ON HBO if you want to know more about Texas..and fracking....its downright scary how our rights are being trampled by big business...and no one in the government is speaking out

6:11PM PDT on Jul 25, 2013

Feedlot must have something to hide. Yes, people should have a right to know what they are being sold as food.

11:29PM PDT on Jul 24, 2013

Way to go, Steinmetz and National Geographic! And they can afford really good lawyers, so if the feedlot or whoever pushes it, not a wise choice. And they don't and shouldn't own the sky. Obviously!

5:28PM PDT on Jul 21, 2013

Nothing illegal occurred here by Steinmetz and Zhang who were filming -- they should not have been arrested nor monetarily penalized -- the money should be returned to them along with interest accrued. Society has the right to know the activities of the feedlot -- after all, how does this rancher earn his living? Does the feedlot have anything to do with his earning a living? Even if said feedlot had something to do with a hobby and NOT earning a living, does society have a right to know what activities go on? I say, YES! On the other hand, if you have something to fear, come out with it -- let's get it out there!

7:25AM PDT on Jul 21, 2013

ty

6:11AM PDT on Jul 20, 2013

Maybe he should have got permission first!!

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

ads keep care2 free

Recent Comments from Causes

WE owe THEM ! Stop hunting and stop pollluting our oceans ! NO TO GILL NETS !

I wish that we (humans, the intelligent kind!) were even remotely as kind and gentle and tender as a…

This shouldn't even be a question asked,this abusing judge should be made to resign.

Story idea? Want to blog? Contact the editors!
ads keep care2 free

more from causes

Animal Welfare

Causes Canada

Causes UK

Children

Civil Rights

Education

Endangered Wildlife

Environment & Wildlife

Global Development

Global Warming

Health Policy

Human Rights

LGBT rights

Politics

Real Food

Trailblazers For Good

Women's Rights




Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.