Professor Receives Death Threats After Glenn Beck Targets Her

A 78-year-old CUNY professor, Frances Fox Piven, has found herself not only the target of criticism from conservative radio and TV talk show host Glenn Beck, but also the recipient of what amount to death threats.

TAKE ACTION: Sign the petition asking Glenn Beck to stop his attacks.

On his News Channel program, which more than 2 million people watch, and on one of his Web sites, The Blaze, Beck has turned Piven into the ‘primary character’ of his ‘warnings about a progressive take-down of America,’ according to the January 21st New York Times.   Piven, says Beck, is the author of a plan that will ‘“intentionally collapse our economic system.”‘

Piven has received threats via e-mail and anonymous comments on The Blaze have called for her death: ‘“Somebody tell Frances I have 5000 roundas ready and I’ll give My life to take Our freedom back”‘ and “ONE SHOT…ONE KILL”  (spelling and grammar have not been edited). 

The article,  “The Weight of the Poor: A Strategy to End Poverty,” that Beck has seized upon was published in 1966 and written by Piven and her late husband, Richard Cloward. According to the New York Times, the article

proposed that if people overwhelmed the welfare rolls, fiscal and political stress on the system could force reform and give rise to changes like a guaranteed income. By drawing attention to the topic, the proposal “had a big impact” even though it was not enacted, Ms. Piven said. “A lot of people got the money that they desperately needed to survive,” she said.

In Mr. Beck’s telling on a Fox broadcast on Jan. 5, 2010, Ms. Piven and Mr. Cloward (who died in 2001) planned “to overwhelm the system and bring about the fall of capitalism by overloading the government bureaucracy with impossible demands and bring on economic collapse.” Mr. Beck observed that the number of welfare recipients soared in the years after the article, and said the article was like “economic sabotage.”

He linked what he termed the Cloward-Piven Strategy to President Obama’s statement late in the 2008 presidential campaign that “we are five days away from fundamentally transforming the United States of America.”

Piven is a long-time columnist for The Nation, which published an editorial about the threats to her:
For a responsible journalist and a responsible media outlet, such an incident would have spurred a process of intense self-scrutiny. But this is Glenn Beck and Fox, and as is evident from the campaign against Piven, nothing of the sort occurred. In the hundreds of posts about Piven on The Blaze, there is not one admonition to tone down the violent rhetoric, not one clear instance in which an editor intervened to moderate the thread. In fact, commenters seem at liberty to egg one another on: one poster pointedly noted that Piven lives in New York City and teaches at CUNY; another then linked to a website that listed Piven’s home address and phone number. “Why is this woman still alive?” asked capnjack. 

Beck’s fixation on Piven’s 1966 article also leads me to wonder if he’ll be digging up other academic articles by professors whose scholarship—loook out for those Marxist literary critics—-might (in Beck’s view) somehow contribute to the ‘”progressive take-down of America.”‘ I guess it might be a way for him to get more fodder for his shows and site.

Saying that Beck quoted Piven ‘accurately and had never threatened her,’ Fox News has indicated that it will not order him to stop discussing the professor and her work. 

It is extremely unfortunate that Fox News has taken such an irresponsible stance. Even though the above comments were made on The Blaze, Beck’s targeting of Piven began on his show on Fox News. By not requiring Beck to cease his attack on Piven, Fox News is tacitly condoning the threats of violence against her.  

And there’s nothing academic, or ethical, about that.

Sign the petition letting Fox News know that it’s not okay to incite this kind of violence through spreading falsehoods.

Photo by david_shankbone.


jane richmond
jane richmond5 years ago

Anything for ratings!

Tiffany P.
Tiffany P5 years ago

People have just got to stop watching Fox. I've never heard a good or rational thing about or from them. They pander to the demographic that pays for them and incites the morons to do the rich men's dirty work. Gosh.

Martha Eberle
Martha Eberle6 years ago

I don't know how Glenn Beck continues to hypnotize people -- after a few weeks, his bombast is old and tired. It's so obvious. But words have consequences, and violent words have violent consequences. I believe he says he's a christian, but Jesus would never have incited people the way Beck does.

Marsha Aronson
Marsha Aronson6 years ago

Harlow's earlier comment here was important, relevant, and perfectly explained. It's the whole "us" vs. "them" way of thinking that has gotten us into the mess we're in.

By the way, I'm a liberal, too, but the older I've gotten, the more very wise and educated people I've met who didn't necessarily get that way from having a formal higher education. They have come from all walks of life, and have found creative and hard-won ways of improving themselves and expanding their knowledge on their own. I may have a Master's Degree, but I respect their intelligence and opinions, too.

I echo Harlow's comments - please, let's not use any patronizing comments here. We'll leave that to Beck and his Faux News cohorts.

Harlow R.
Harlow R.6 years ago

Liberals,and I'm a `liberal', do not help themselves when they write "all of you should have gone to college." It's an elitist and illogical statement-'only college educated people use critical thinking skills while those who have not attended or finished college are followers of Beck and his ilk.'
What a patronizing and presumptuous thing to say. It doesn't help anything and in fact, sounds like ther way Glen Beck thinks-degrade an entire group of people while making the group one associates with the superior group.

lyn L.
l L6 years ago

Until Glenn Beck is jailed Glenn Beck will keep doing what he is doing. Glenn is crazy and everyone knows this man doesn't have the sense God gave him if he ever had any and he is so dangerously irresponsible. And he is aided and abetted to put peoples lives in harms way and everyone let's it happen. we already had the last incident. How many more is he going to cause and the ones who support him? Do your dirt and sit back and say it wasn't me. We let it happen. So glenn the nut will proceed. heil america

Annmari Lundin
Annmari Lundin6 years ago

Cathleen S.: Why don't we bring back the glory days of slavery while we're at it? Isn't that what you're aiming at when you say only property owners should be allowed to vote, as it were when this country was established. Property as in owning other human beings. I almost get dizzy reading comments like yours. Dizzy from not knowing if to laugh at the ridiculous statements you're making or puke right out at the comments you make and descriptions you put on your neighbors. I bet you are an xtian! You sound like one of those full of their holyness and knowing what's right for everyone else. If you are so fed up with things and can't stand to see poor people and insist on calling people derogative names and also accuse people of all sorts of devious acts, I suggest you either form a new nation with your allies at Fox, the tea bags and likes or go back under that rock you obviously crawled up from. I don't care if you decide to answer me on this. I will certainly not take the time to read it let alone waste time answer it. I just hope that in time people like you and your freinds at Fox, et al, will cease to exist when compassion, understanding, inclusiveness and equality runs amok in this country!

Cathy H.
Cathy H6 years ago

David C. I can't believe that you are familiar with Piven. Don't believe Beck listen to her own videoes and her lectures then tell me Beck is not right. If you go to the horse's mouth you can not deny what you are hearing.

David C.
David Connally6 years ago

Right on Paula G. Beck’s strategy has much in common with Hitler.

In Hitler’s "Mein Kampf", "violence"/"violent" appear 40 times, always with "bad" guys using violence against "good" guys. He includes "violent" attacks from the Jewish controlled press. "Good" guys are "ordinary" Germans or Nazis. "Jew…" appears 200 times in the first half of the book (when I stopped counting). Hitler does not advocate violence against Jews, he just says they are responsible for Germany's ills. His supporters took it from there.

Beck’s supporters say he does not overtly advocate violence. But he demonizes progressives (“Jews”) blames them for all woes & he suffers from attacks by the liberal (“Jewish”) media. Doesn’t that sound familiar? Create an enemy, a scapegoat. Don’t advocate violence – arouse your base and let them go.

Beck has demonized an obscure academic (Piven), claimed she's a leader of progressives and the source of all ills. Garbage. Ask 100 progressives that don’t listen to Beck – they wouldn’t have heard of her. There is no evidence her beliefs influenced progressive thought. Beck made the idiotic suggestion that because Obama went to a conference at which Piven spoke, he adopted Piven’s views. That makes about as much sense as me becoming a Beck follower because I saw a Beck’s program. (btw I couldn’t believe what I heard from Beck. Progressives gave us proh

Marsha Aronson
Marsha Aronson6 years ago

Cathleen S., you are a piece of work, as they say. Weren't you around when President Clinton (a Democrat) actually did end the welfare system as it used to be? Maybe if there were adequate birth control available to everyone who wants it, as well as meaningful sex education, as well as publicly-funded abortions when all else fails, then maybe there would be fewer "slugs" around. (What a word!) I am always appalled when I read diatribes against the poor like yours, because you probably call yourself a Christian. You're about as Christian as Osama bin Laden.