START A PETITION 25,136,189 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x
1,383,573 people care about Politics

RIP Trolls: Social Critics? Just Sick and Offensive?

RIP Trolls: Social Critics? Just Sick and Offensive?
  • 1 of 2

RIP trolling — in which anonymous persons leave less than kindly, if not downright mean and cruel, remarks on Facebook and other social media profiles of the deceased — would seem to be, hands down, one of the most despicable phenomena to arise on the internet. What kind of individual spends their time posting hateful comments on memorial pages, many for teenagers who have died tragically in accidents or in ways more terrible and violent?

In Loling at tragedy: Facebook trolls, memorial pages and resistance to grief online, an article in the online journal First Monday, University of Oregon Ph.D. student Whitney Phillips examines the “emergence” of such “organized trolling behavior”; highlights the “parasitic” relationship among RIP trolls, Facebook protocols and mainstream media outlets; and suggests that such behavior is — hard as it is for most of us to consider — a sort of social critique. Those who engage in RIP trolling are engaging in a “pointed critique of a tragedy–obsessed global media,” by calling into question “grief tourists” who “have no real–life connection to the victim and who, according to the trolls, could not possibly be in mourning”; whose expressions of sorrow are not truly authentic but rather, according to one “Paulie Socash,” the result of “boredom and a pathological need for attention masquerading as grief.” RIP trolls who seek out Facebook memorial and fan pages “laugh at death” and “force their victims to confront precisely those things that motivate the popularity of memorial pages — fear of helplessness, fear of losing a loved one, fear of human parts.”

RIP trolls also, says Phillips, seek to call into question the mainstream media and, in particular, its focus on cyberbullying:

Mainstream outlets in America and Britain placed each story on a blood–stained pedestal, breathlessly pouring over every mean thing anyone ever said to the victim pre– and post–mortem, often jumbling the timelines so badly as to suggest that the RIP trolls were somehow responsible for pushing the (already dead) teens to suicide. In Britain, the Daily Mail lead this charge, often affecting the same gristly tone as the trolls they purported to condemn. “‘Help Me, Mummy,” the headline of one 2011 article began, quoting from a macro posted to 15–year–old Lauren Gelder’s memorial page. “‘It’s Hot Here in Hell’: A Special Investigation Into the Distress of Grieving Families Caused by the Sick Internet Craze of ‘Trolling’” (Carey, 2011).

According to Phillips, media coverage simply serves to reinforce and “reinscribe the same ‘sick and disgusting’ language of trolls in order to maximize reader outrage.” By focusing so much emphasis on the trolls’ despicableness, the media are engaging in the same sorts of behavior that they criticize RIP trolls for.

So are RIP trolls the unsung social critics of our times in the manner of no one less than the ancient philosopher Socrates, who once characterized himself as a gadfly stinging the lazy old horse of Athens into action?

  • 1 of 2

Read more: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Photo by sboneham

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it

100 comments

+ add your own
4:38PM PST on Jan 16, 2012

Trolls are "social critics" in the same way that grafitti vandals are "artists."

4:25PM PST on Jan 16, 2012

Christina B.

are the trolls on your forum real ones or are people on your forum blithering idiots? people even think the police can take away your computer for being a "troll".

they only take your stuff if you are getting to cozey with minors.

take this site, the people here think any slight disagreement is trolling. better yet "you have a differnt opinion than me and the topic at hand. because you talk about it you are a troll"

you don't go into a burger resturant and demand a chow mein pizza.
so you don't say Eskimos should be allowed to wear fur, on a site where people would let their child die before a flea does.

2:56PM PST on Jan 9, 2012

I was annoyed by the suggestion that trolls are "social critics". Sometimes, I just think people write articles with absolutely no meaning at all.

Trolls crave attention. They may be very smart individuals, but their trolling comments have nothing to do with promoting discussions or offering counter-arguments. They just like creating havoc. It's as simple as that. As a mod in another forum, I should know.

7:29AM PST on Dec 27, 2011

since values and morals are mostly taught by example, this says something very disturbing about humankind....

12:54AM PST on Dec 26, 2011

Thanks for the article.

4:47AM PST on Dec 21, 2011

Bridget M.

what is worse, meaning it or not? if the people who trolled that dead girls memorial were "christain" and the dead girl and her family not christain, or if she were lesbian-momosexual(the people of Lesbos island want their name back) they they would be protected by free speech. I think, but they indrude on territory and attack an individual.

http://blogs.sparenot.com/godsmacks/

if anything, many should strive to be a RIP troll for these nutters. rape your free-speech powers and do it.

12:18PM PST on Dec 20, 2011

And, at any rate, I didn't do this anonymously.

12:16PM PST on Dec 20, 2011

I have to admit - I did do a "Troll" drive-by on my ex's RIP, not on FB, but on some Memorial.com site and on Classmates.
I felt I had to since this person not only beat and raped me with impunity, but I found out that he's been stalking me for almost 18 yrs. without my knowledge.
Because of this, my relationship with my brother and sis-n-law have been irreparably damaged.

So - YEAH - it's been 8 months since I did it and I'm still waiting to see if any guilt surfaces.

I have a feeling it won't.
But I still feel terrible when it happens to innocents.
From what I've been able to piece together, my rapist was innocent to NO ONE.

9:18PM PST on Dec 19, 2011

Trolling may be covered under the constitution as free speech, but it is still disturbing to see people upping the ante with the amount of cruelty they can inflict on others. The anonymity afforded by the Internet is intoxicating for the worst offenders, but I suspect that many would be just as rude in person if they felt it was justified. It seems like we're not all carrying the same rule book when it comes to general cordiality.
Care2 is a venue for personal commentary and debate, but certain subjects invariably cause trolling behavior to rise to the surface. It isn't quite as vicious as the RIP trolls, but it is sometimes less about fair debate and more about insulting one's opponent and their allegedly inferior belief paradigm. Security in one's beliefs does not require attacks. Intelligent discourse and respect will get you further than the degradation of nasty words and trolling.

2:11PM PST on Dec 19, 2011

by which kind? give an example. I will laugh if you mean saying "Heifter international is great, I will buy some poor people in Africa a family of goats, they can breed goats, milk the goat, make cheese, sell baby boy goats for food, grow more goats, make money off the hides"

or "lol, this iz balls, grow a spine and take an ethnic/racist/sexist joke"

ah. I'm just mad because I don't know how to get money from the meat industry for troll'n this sites animal welfare. that would be great. I'd ask for 4,000 a month to advocate eating our barnyard friends.

Or do you mean trolls as left/right wing'ed screaming ninnies? bible humping homophobes.

really. I don't think people on this site would know they are trolled or not. If I say "oh no Eskimos are eating seals, let's force them to convert to fake meat, and make factories for such on their homelands. They can be hired to work in it"

I get friggen green stars for that.

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

ads keep care2 free

Recent Comments from Causes

Sounds awfully disrespectful.

"Everyone benefits from a vegan diet"?? Does that "everyone" include the animals & trees whose…

My son in law, is an engineer specalizing in coal fired power plants. I know the technology exists…

meet our writers

Kristina Chew Kristina Chew teaches and writes about ancient Greek and Latin and is Online Advocacy and Marketing... more
Story idea? Want to blog? Contact the editors!
ads keep care2 free

more from causes

Animal Welfare

Causes Canada

Causes UK

Children

Civil Rights

Education

Endangered Wildlife

Environment & Wildlife

Global Development

Global Warming

Health Policy

Human Rights

LGBT rights

Politics

Real Food

Trailblazers For Good

Women's Rights




Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.