START A PETITION 25,136,189 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x
919,670 people care about Women's Rights

Should Pregnant Drug Users Be Treated Like Criminals?

Should Pregnant Drug Users Be Treated Like Criminals?

A woman walks in to see a doctor. She is pregnant and she needs prenatal care. She also confesses something: She has a drug problem and is struggling to not use, but she’s sure that with this pregnancy as motivation, she will be able to stay clean.

Do you throw her in jail?

That’s the question that National Advocates for Pregnant Women is hoping will be answered by the federal courts. The advocacy group has filed a challenge as a result of the case of Alicia Beltran, a Wisconsin woman who confessed during a prenatal appointment that she was recovering from an addiction to painkillers. According to NAPW, Beltran was then arrested on July 18, 2013 under a law that protects any pregnancy from the moment of conception from a pregnant person who “habitually lacks self-control in the use of alcohol or controlled substances.”

“The Wisconsin law takes away from a pregnant woman virtually every right associated with constitutional personhood — from the most basic right to physical liberty to the right to refuse bad medical advice,” said Lynn Paltrow, executive director of National Advocates for Pregnant Women and a co-counsel to Beltram. “This kind of dangerous, authoritarian state-action, is exactly what happens when laws give police officers and other state actors the authority to treat fertilized eggs, embryos, and fetuses as if they are already completely separate from the pregnant woman.”

There is little doubt that states across the country are increasingly looking for ways to charge those who currently or formerly used drugs and became pregnant, even in cases where the person in question is actually doing things that are in the best interest of the child she is carrying or has given birth to. Bei Bei Shuai in Indiana was charged with murder despite doing everything that doctors requested of her to try to care for her baby both during pregnancy and after birth after she went in for treatment following a suicide attempt.

In an even more unsettling case in Alabama, a young woman is being actively sought by the police after leaving her newborn in the hospital after giving birth, after the baby tested positive for cocaine and opiates. Their goal? To find her and charge her with “chemical endangerment of exposing a child to an environment in which controlled substances are produced or distributed.”

The idea of pregnancy and drug abuse, either actual or potential, is a tough one for many people to rationalize as anything but a crime. Even advocates who have been the most supportive of women’s rights or most compassionate when it comes to the struggles of addiction tend to balk once an unborn child is added to the scenario. But in actuality, for anyone who supports women, the rights of those who struggle or have struggled with addiction, or children’s rights should be able to draw together in common cause.

Arresting a pregnant person who may have a drug problem does little to address the underlying reason for the addiction and could cause further physical harm to the fetus. Arrest as a precedent could also send others like Beltram from accessing prenatal care or fully informing medical professionals about their entire medical history of which the drug issues are a part. Children born without adequate prenatal care are going to be children who will be subject to a number of health risks regardless of what the mother may be doing during her pregnancy.

As bad if not worse is the threat of arresting a woman or girl who leaves her child at a hospital, a place traditionally covered under safe haven laws allowing a mother to abandon a child with no legal consequences. If a pregnant woman doing drugs willingly leaves behind a child she cannot or does not feel she can care for, that is in the infants best interest. If she is worried that she could be arrested if she leaves him or her behind, she may take the child with her, putting his or her life in danger.

If we truly care about the child, we need to care for the mothers. Get them real help, not handcuffs.

 

Read more: , , , , ,

Photo credit: Thinkstock

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it

92 comments

+ add your own
5:45AM PDT on Mar 13, 2014

This is not mostly true, while Pregnant Drug Users Be Treated Like Criminals. Using drugs in pregnancy effects more harms on your health and for your unborn baby. Addiction of drugs can not be short out so easily, but you want to cam out then you definitely overcome from this. You can get more helps and support in Drug Rehab Center, there are experienced doctor's supervisors that take extra care of you. By getting better treatment &medication you realize that you came back from addiction.

4:43AM PST on Nov 5, 2013

Well, let's see.....Taking Drugs, is Illegal, so, yes, that would constitute a Criminal Action. And, if anything happened to her Unborn Child, that would be Murder and once again, that is also a Criminal Action.

6:13AM PDT on Oct 16, 2013

This is like something from "A Handmaid's Tale"! I am a mother, too. And I adore my child. But I am a human being first & NOT just a walking incubator.
Plus, by threatening women with prison, you are just guaranteeing they will be afraid to confide or even go to their doctor. At what point does a women loose all her rights as a free citizen? Upon he fertility?

“No woman can call herself free who does not control her own body.”
~Margaret Sanger

12:02AM PDT on Oct 16, 2013

I hate to sound like a broken record, but there are lots of reasons for a woman to be pregnant when she does not want to be. Birth control methods fail; some men won't use condoms; there's rape; politicians make abortion impossible.

10:06AM PDT on Oct 13, 2013

in a word YES

4:16AM PDT on Oct 12, 2013

Thanks for sharing and caring

3:39AM PDT on Oct 12, 2013

Thank you!

1:58AM PDT on Oct 12, 2013

ty

11:53PM PDT on Oct 11, 2013

These women regardless of drug issues should always be helped and counselled.

6:03PM PDT on Oct 10, 2013

ty

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Care2 - Be Extraordinary - Start a Care2 Petition
ads keep care2 free
CONTACT THE EDITORS

Recent Comments from Causes

Anyone who thinks they need to eat meat should really go out and hunt for themselves instead of running…

I just wish to reiterate that: Animals are being abused as we speak, and helping them takes a lot more…

violence only begets violence. thanks

ads keep care2 free



Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.