START A PETITION 27,000,000 members: the world's largest community for good
2,263,198 people care about Health Policy

The Rise of Catholic Hospitals Could Affect Your Care

The Rise of Catholic Hospitals Could Affect Your Care
  • 1 of 2

Written by Nina Martin

Over the past few years, Washington state’s liberal voters have been on quite a roll. Same-sex marriage? Approved. Assisted suicide? Check. Legalized pot? That too. Strong abortion protections? Those have been in place for decades.

Now, though, the state finds itself in the middle of a trend that hardly anyone there ever saw coming: a wave of mergers and alliances between Catholic hospital chains and secular, taxpayer-supported community hospitals. By the end of this year, the ACLU estimates, nearly half of Washington’s hospital beds could be under Catholic influence or outright control.

Many of the deals have been reached in near secrecy, with minimal scrutiny by regulators. Virtually all involve providers in Western Washington, which voted heavily for same-sex marriage last November and the Death with Dignity Act in 2008. The cultural divide between the region’s residents (Seattle recently edged out San Francisco as the area with the largest proportion of gay couples) and the Catholic Church (whose local archbishop led the effort against marriage equality and is overseeing a Vatican crackdown on independent-minded American nuns) couldn’t be wider. And yet more and more hospitals there — sustained by taxpayers, funded by Medicare, Medicaid and other government subsidies — could be bound by church restrictions on birth control, sterilization and abortion, fertility treatments, genetic testing and assisted suicide.

In affected communities, the news is not going over well.

“It’s the perfect storm here,” said Kathy Reim, president of Skagit PFLAG (Parents, Families and Friends of Lesbians and Gays) north of Seattle, where four area hospitals have been in merger talks this year. “We are the only state that has all these rights and privileges available to our citizens. Yet many of our hospital beds are being managed by a system that, for the most part, cannot and will not honor these rights and laws.”

Meanwhile, the deals just keep coming. Earlier this month, hospital commissioners approved a letter of intent between Skagit Valley Hospital and PeaceHealth, a Catholic enterprise that runs nine medical centers and dozens of clinics in three states. The week before, Franciscan Health System, which already has six hospitals in the region, said it would affiliate with an acute-care facility in the sprawling suburbs south of Seattle. In mid- September, UW Medicine, which includes the University of Washington’s teaching centers, signed a “strategic collaboration” with PeaceHealth to provide advanced specialized in-patient care.

In all, Washington has seen at least 10 completed or proposed Catholic-secular affiliations in the past three years, more than anywhere else in the country, says Sheila Reynertson of MergerWatch, a New York-based nonprofit group that tracks hospital consolidations. Three of the state’s five largest health-care systems are Catholic.

Catholic providers have actually been an integral part of Washington state’s health-care infrastructure since the late 1800s, when nuns from the East Coast and Europe braved rain and worse to minister to loggers and miners in remote outposts around the region. A century later, those historical ties — and their relative robustness — have made them attractive partners for community hospitals for whom the choice is: affiliate or get crushed.

“It’s harder than ever before for independent health-care organizations to thrive without alliances,” said PeaceHealth spokesman Tim Strickland. One of the main reasons: health-care reform. “It’s happening all over the country, with all kinds of providers,” he said. “We don’t perceive this trend as a Catholic scenario so much as a health-care scenario.” Indeed, the consulting firm Booz & Company predicts that a fifth of the nation’s 5,000 hospitals could merge over the next few years.

In some places, including big swaths of Western Washington, Catholic providers are becoming the only source of health care for an entire region. Approximately 8 percent of what the federal government calls “sole community hospitals” are Catholic.

The dilemma is that Catholic hospitals — there are 630 or so in the United States, representing 15 percent of all admissions every year — are not independent entities. They are bound by a 43-page document called the Ethical and Religious Directives for Catholic Health Care Services, which have been around in some form since 1921 and were last revised by the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops in 2009.

The 72 directives explicitly ban abortion and sterilization. They restrict other types of care as well, including emergency contraception for rape victims (“It is not permissible… to initiate or to recommend treatments [for sexual assault] that have as their purpose or direct effect the removal, destruction, or interference with the implantation of a fertilized ovum”); in vitro fertilization and artificial insemination (“contrary to the covenant of marriage, the unity of the spouses, and the dignity proper to parents and the child”); surrogate pregnancy; and anything that remotely resembles assisted suicide (the bishops’ preferred term is “euthanasia”).

Then there’s this:

5. Catholic health care services must adopt these Directives as policy, require adherence to them within the institution as a condition for medical privileges and employment, and provide appropriate instruction regarding the Directives for administration, medical and nursing staff, and other personnel.

Over the years, the ERDs have had their greatest impact on women and people too sick or poor to look around for another provider. Some states, including Washington, have laws requiring emergency birth control, but there have been numerous reports of Catholic-affiliated doctors and nurses who were prevented from treating female patients, including pregnant women with serious complications, in accordance with best medical practices and the patients’ own wishes. In a study last year by researchers at the University of Chicago, 52 percent of OB/GYNs affiliated with Catholic providers reported having conflicts over religious policies dictating medical care.

  • 1 of 2

Read more: , , , , , , , ,

Photo Credit: Mercy Health

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it


+ add your own
12:00PM PST on Nov 10, 2013

When my mother had her hip replacement last year she had to go to a Catholic hospital and nursing home. She requsted a minister, she's Lutheran, before surgery, after surgery, and at the nursing home. They had a candy stripper give my mother a fabric cross because they didn't give other religious reps access to their facilities. I requested a minister and the nurse told me that he wouldn't be allowed. So much for Catholic charity...

7:26AM PDT on Oct 28, 2013

We've gone through decades of very conservative papacies appointing very conservative bishops, so we presently have a hierarchy that is completely out of touch with reality and badly needs a smackdown from legislators and courts. Of course, over this same period, we've had court packing from conservative elected officials, so that may be harder than it looks - thought not in WA, where they are taking the first steps to tell the Church to back off.

The good news is that the Vatican is now run by a Jesuit hippie who couldn't care less about birth control or bullying gay people, and he'll appoint others who think like he does, so we can expect the Conference of Catholic Bishops to make a sharp left turn within the next decade, at which point we can expect the American Church to start focusing on poverty. The breakup between conservatives and Catholics will do wonders for the country.

5:40PM PDT on Oct 26, 2013


12:03PM PDT on Oct 26, 2013

My recollection is that in Montgomery County (a suburb of Philadelphia) , Pennsylvania, there were talks of merging a public hospital with a Catholic one. When the medical staff of the public hospital learned about the policies of the Catholic hospital, they mobilized and stopped the merger.

Here''s hoping that the medical people all over the country do the same!

4:52PM PDT on Oct 25, 2013

(I see "Jacob" is off his meds again.)

2:26PM PDT on Oct 25, 2013


1:17PM PDT on Oct 25, 2013

A 5 przykazanie mówi "nie zabijaj", dlatego katoliccy lekarze, a wg mnie wszyscy lekarze nie mogą zabijać dzieci nienarodzonych - jest to tym bardziej okrutne, że zabija matka, a one nie mogą się bronić. A tym bardziej niemoralne jest zmuszanie kogoś do zabójstwa.

11:44AM PDT on Oct 25, 2013

This is most disturbing. Especially since the Pope has made the ideology speach. Enforcing Catholic dogma or beliefs upon the public is a violation of the separation of church and state. As Robert C much more aptly states, if you serve the public then you need to follow the law.

8:05AM PDT on Oct 25, 2013

Why is it that people forget, that before Medicaid and before Medicare, Catholic Hospitals, as well as those from other religious groups, were the source of care and comfort to people without other means. This was done in most cases regardless of the faith or lack thereof bf the patient. This is a free country and Catholic hospitals have the right to heir beliefs, but one has to remember that when the chips are down, Catholic hospital have saved more lives thant any other type of health care organization.

5:06AM PDT on Oct 25, 2013

Dale O. - thank you. In my comment where I refer to the Catholic Church buying up hospitals.
while closing parishes and schools wasn't meant as a question of why, in as much it was
meant on my part as being a "sarcastic comment". Sublimely, meaning there is MORE PROFIT
in hospitals then there are in supporting parishes and schools.
John C./Houston, Tx.

add your comment

Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Care2 - Be Extraordinary - Start a Care2 Petition
ads keep care2 free

Recent Comments from Causes

What's happening to animals in factory farms every day is horrible. Suffering, fear and death is reality…

Of course Super PAC donations are bribery, openly, clearly, unapologetically. In days of old it used…

meet our writers

Kristina Chew Kristina Chew teaches and writes about ancient Greek and Latin and is Online Advocacy and Marketing... more
ads keep care2 free

Select names from your address book   |   Help

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.

site feedback


Problem on this page? Briefly let us know what isn't working for you and we'll try to make it right!