START A PETITION 27,000,000 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x
926,997 people care about Women's Rights

Tyra Banks: Role Model for Women?

Tyra Banks: Role Model for Women?

As we bid farewell to 2009, we look forward to a new year – one without (of all things) the Tyra Banks show! 

Hooray!

This week Banks announced she’d be ending her show after five seasons in the Spring of 2010.

If you’ve ever sat through an episode of the Tyra Banks Show you understand my excitement at the show’s end but I must admit (full disclosure) that I loathe Tyra Banks. I think she is egotistical, hypocritical, and to be honest, a bit off her rocker.

What I find most infuriating about Banks, however, are her often misguided “rah-rah women,” “you-go-girl” charades. 

Let’s not forget the “bathing suit incident.”

After several paparazzi pictures of an unflattering Banks in a swimsuit surfaced back in 2007 and rumors began circulating that she’d gained weight, Banks took to her TV show to show America that she was proud of her body. Appearing on TV in the same pictured swimsuit, Banks gave an “inspired,” tearful speech of her body telling haters to “kiss my fat ass.” The women in the audience cheered and gave Banks a standing ovation. 

For two years Banks maintained her pride in her “curvier” shape, but then in 2009 she shed 30 pounds and this time dedicated an entire show to her weight loss success secrets. 

In an interview with People Magazine, Banks said: “I feel good about my curves and my imperfections – my booty, my boobs, my thighs – I embrace it all. Now I really can say … kiss my fit – and still fat – ass.”
 
If you’ve seen pictures of the trimmed down model you know her ass is far from fat. If you ask me she wasn’t fat with the 30 “extra” pounds but what happened to make her change her mind? When did the 30 pounds that were once happily accepted as part of who she was become so undesirable? 

In her infamous “kiss my fat ass” speech Banks claimed: “If I had lower self-esteem I would probably be starving myself right now.”

Well, what happened to that self-esteem? Where did it go and more importantly why did it go away?

From defending her fuller figure to gushing over her svelte new shape, Banks’ body war is a classic example of her misguided attempts to be the positive role model she so desires to be for women and girls.

I realize this is only one incident in the career of a woman spanning many years, but for me it was one of those “Seriously?” “Are you kidding me moments” that stuck.

I know that Banks has also made strides in incorporating “plus-size” models in her other hit show America’s Next Top Model which can be seen as a positive step, but having one token “plus-size” model among a sea of size zero contestants isn’t the best approach to accepting and appreciating fuller figured women.

On the plus side, I’m a big fan of Banks’ Tzone camp for girls which empowers girls to be “fierce, focused, and in control of their futures.” But as it turns out, the camps are no longer offered and Tzone is now a grant-making foundation so that’s a wash.

With the end of her talk show in sight, Banks has revealed the launch of Bankable Studios, a NY film production company which aims to bring “positive images of women to the big screen” and “redefine beauty for women in film.”
 
These goals sound too good to be true and with Banks running the show that frankly may be the case.

Honestly, I’m hesitant to exude any excitement on this new project but hope that Banks will use this opportunity to demonstrate some consistency in her attempts to provide the world with a wider (no pun intended) definition of beauty – we certainly need it.

I just hope this isn’t another “one step forward, two steps back” moment. That we don’t need.

Read more: , , , , ,

Pictures courtesy of People and Life & Style magazines.

quick poll

vote now!

Loading poll...

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it

127 comments

+ add your own
9:39PM PDT on Jul 2, 2013

Thank you.

9:38PM PDT on Jul 2, 2013

Thank you.

9:37PM PDT on Jul 2, 2013

Thank you.

9:36PM PDT on Jul 2, 2013

Thank you.

9:51PM PDT on Aug 30, 2010

Monica,
"to find an idol in the media, is like finding a whole basket of eating disorders, self-esteem problems and competition."

Again, if you never watch tv, how could you possibly know? And how could you decide which celebrities (who, btw, ARE real people, thrown into the spotlight of public scutiny), how could you decide which of them anyone of us is allowed to choose as an idol?

The question is whether TYRA is a role model for women. You can only answer that with any semblence of reason if you actually know all she's done over the years.

Is is unreasonable to expecet a role model to never make mistakes? - YES. Tyra is human, just like us.
Is it unreasonable to expect Trya to present herself in the most flattering manner at all times? - YES. Tyra isn't being paid to have a certain look every waking hour. She is allowed to travel and even wear a bathing suit on a bigger body than she's used to having, without being ridiculed for being human.

Oprah and Ellen are wonderful role models. Barbara Walters, and the rest of "The View." are great. Regis and Kelly are great role models.

People... role models are people you look up to and want to emulate, according to what you know about them. I would love to see more people finding the Greorge Clooney in themselves, or the Oprah/Ellen inside themselves.

What a classier world this would be.

9:40PM PDT on Aug 30, 2010

Monica,
If you don't watch tv, then why should anyone believe you when you say " it is 99.9% empty junk."?

Animal Planet-junk?
Childrens learning programs-junk?
CSPAN-junk?
Planet Green-junk?
Sports channels-junk?
Art channels-junk?
Travel channel-junk?
Food Network-junk?
Discovery Channel-junk? (except for Sarah Palin's gig - GROSS)
National Geographic-junk?

You must have an extremely low opinion of home-bound people, whose only source of exploration of the world are through channels like these, and those I haven't listed.

I feel sorry for you for being so elitist that you feel you can demean everyone else who watches tv, simply because you have the ability to choose a different path for yourself.

LOL, I have always enjoyed Jon & Kate Plus 8 (now Kat Plus 8) becasue even as a kid, I was fascinated with multiples. And when I grew up and eventually found out that I could never give birth, I became even more enamored with watching other people's children (hoping to adopt someday).

I love watching the children grow up and interact with each other and the world around them. It's something I will never get close to in my personal life. So it isn't junk for me.It's partially filling a very hurt empty spot in my life, and making it hurt just a little less.

But, according to you, I am dissatisfied with the fact that I don't have children; and you are correct. Why do YOU have a problem with that truth?

6:06AM PDT on Aug 27, 2010

to find an idol in the media, is like finding a whole basket of eating disorders, self-esteem problems and competition.

Celebrities Nude

6:05AM PDT on Aug 27, 2010

I don't even know who Tyra Banks is. I don't watch TV and the only celebrity news I see is in the grocery store line. I think we would all feel better if we just focusd on the real people in our lives and paid less attention to the worship of celebrities and fame. It is an industry that feeds off of people's insecurities and dissatisfaction with their lives. And turn off the TV- it is 99.9% empty junk and a waste of time. I don't think anyone at the end of life ever says "I wish I had watched more TV".

Celebrities Nude

3:27PM PST on Jan 22, 2010

Babatope,

Almost every daytime talk show over the years, on occasion, discusses topics that are inappropriate for children. But, every time this happens, there is a disclaimer at the beginning of the show, and usually upon the return from every commercial, to have children leave the room.

Homeschooled kids should not be watching tv, they should be studying. If the parents don't know what the topic of the show is, why are they letting their children watch it? And why would any school-aged child be watching tv at 10am Mon-Fri? And why would any child younger than that be watching a talk show?

Think about who is REALLY watching Tyra during school hours. It's adults, who might just be recording certain shows for their children to learn from.

7:32AM PST on Jan 19, 2010

A role model? She cannot possibly be. I just turned to a channel which has her encouraging people to share disgusting threesome fantasies-not to mention calling in on audience members who may want to join in...) She cannot possibly be a role model for anyone with values and a working brain. Are our kids supposed to be watching this?-It's 10 in the morning for crying out loud!! Some kids may be home schooled. My my!! Money is not everything...when we die we rot along with it. Put your money into better use.

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Care2 - Be Extraordinary - Start a Care2 Petition
ads keep care2 free
CONTACT THE EDITORS

Recent Comments from Causes

II have not been drinking for over 30 years now . I thought it was that people DO know when they start…

Um, Randi L. You must be confusing gene modification with cloning. The cloned animal is STILL that…

THANK YOU for your time and for posting! TOO SWEET!

meet our writers

Colleen H. Colleen H. is an Online Campaigner with Care2 and a recent transplant to San Francisco from the East... more
ads keep care2 free



Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.