START A PETITION 25,136,189 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x
769,053 people care about Education

Why Are Parents Putting Wires On Special Ed Students?

Why Are Parents Putting Wires On Special Ed Students?
  • 1 of 2

Stuart Chaifetz had his 10-year-old autistic son, Akian, wear a recording device after school officials at his school in Cherry Hill, New Jersey, said that the child had started to hit staff. According to NJ.com, Chaifetz listened to the recording and heard a number of things that he “believed … took place because the class only contains children with autism who have trouble communicating.” Chaifetz made a YouTube video about what he heard on the recording:

In the tape, one staff member can be heard bragging to another about how much she drank the night before. …

Later in the recording, a teacher speaks to students in a harsh tone, then tells a student — allegedly Akian — “shut your mouth.”

More clips are presented later in the recording, allegedly showing teachers dismissing and mocking Akian as he cried, but it was unclear from the audio what was being said.

Chaifetz has called for the teachers to issue a public apology to Akian and to resign from their jobs but said he is not planning to sue the school district. He is calling for a legislative bill under which teachers who bully students must be fired.

Chaifetz said that he has turned the tape over to the school district and the  Philadelphia Inquirer reports that the school personnel heard on the recording are no longer employed.

More Reports of Parents Having Special Ed Students Wear Recording Devices

An animal rights activist and former school board candidate, Chaifetz went on a week-long hunger stirke five years ago to call attention to a lack of state funding for developmentally disabled children and children at risk. He is not the first parent who has had a child with disabilities secretly wear a recording device. Last year, an an Ohio mother had her teenage daughter with special needs wear a wire to record abusive comments made by classroom staff in a resource room; an aide was heard telling the student that she was “dumb,” a “liar,” “lazy” and overweight. The family was awarded $300,000 for the bullying by school staff.

In addition, in 2008, a mother of an autistic boy, Stefan Ferrari, sewed a microphone into his shirt after suspecting that he was abused in his Atlanta classroom. Stefan’s parents sued the school district and his former teacher, Sherri Jones, was charged with making abusive comments; Stefan had also been physically abused and had bruises on his legs. While the judge ruled that he had been hit by an adult at the school, who was responsible for the abuse has yet to be determined and Jones herself has denied physically abusing Stefan. The school district was ordered to pay Stefan’s family about $236,000, almost $800,000 for the district’s and own lawyers and ”a certain amount of money,” into a trust fund for Stefan’s education.

As Nirvi Shah writes on Education Week’s On Special Education blog, “is this what it has come to?” Is this what it’s like to work in and be a student in a special education classroom today, an atmosphere of potential verbal and physical abuse and deep distrust between school personnel and parents?

Creating a Contention-Free Special Education Parent-School Relationship

My autistic son Charlie will be 15 years old next month and has only been in special education classrooms and schools for his entire education.

  • 1 of 2

Read more: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Photo by basykes

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it

46 comments

+ add your own
11:16AM PDT on Aug 16, 2012

if you don't do well with kids under pressure or special circumstances, do NOT be a teacher

10:06AM PDT on May 9, 2012

Grazie per l'articolo.

8:30PM PDT on May 6, 2012

I think it's a great idea. One of my school bullies was a teacher. They have cameras on some school buses and I've often wondered why they didn't have them in classrooms.

11:04AM PDT on May 2, 2012

DISGUSTGING. FIRE THESE MORONS NOW.

12:37PM PDT on May 1, 2012

I can't believe anyone would defend the horrible people at these schools that did this by rationalizing away that there shouldn't be an expectation that they are trained to deal with autistic kids. NOTHING justifies bullying or demeaning kids or acting so unprofessionally, regardless of any other factors.

Also, recording in private requires consent or some other warranted justification, but recording in public does not, so in a public school, there would have been nothing illegal about what these parents did, and the contents would be allowable as evidence of the wrongdoing that they discovered.

7:56AM PDT on Apr 30, 2012

Petition on this issue:
http://www.thepetitionsite.com/521/740/238/apologize-to-akian-and-end-teacher-bullying/

I do address the privacy issue. I think in this case, the parent felt he had exhausted other options trying to figure out why his child was acting out at school, when he saw no evidence of such behavior in other settings.


Also, as I understand it, this was a class of all autistic children. I would assume those in charge were or should have been trained to deal with and understand special needs.

7:20PM PDT on Apr 28, 2012

Recording ANYone without their full KNOWLEDGE and CONSENT is illegal under the current laws of the US. Any judge who knows anything about the law will have this, and other, illegally obtained recordings, banned from evidence.

Nothing I read says anything about whether this was a school especially for special needs students, or whether it was a class of special needs students in a "regular" public school.

The post-secondary schooling necessary to earn not only a bachelor's degree but a teaching credential as well is often five to six years, and expensive as hell. Expecting ALL teachers to spend even more money and more time taking the additional courses necessary to deal with students outside the "normal" classification is neither fair to the teachers nor fair to the system itself.

It seems rational to expect special needs students to attend schools designed to accommodate their needs, and to be taught by teachers who WANT to be there and who have TRAINED to be there. And NO, this is no more segregation than are special schools for the performing arts (remember the film and tv shows titled "FAME"?), or special vocational high schools, or charter schools that only accept high-IQ students (Lowell High in San Francisco).

I am surprised that so many parents of special needs students don't seem to "get" that their kids are actually being short-changed by being sent to schools that are not designed to satisfy those needs.

5:34PM PDT on Apr 27, 2012

They should all be wired up and these places should have cameras too. In fact All schools should have CCTV. Make education transparent, not as some secret society. If anywhere needs surveillance it is where ever children and the disadvantaged are.

11:57AM PDT on Apr 27, 2012

Even if these children are difficult to deal with, no teacher has any business saying things to a child such as, 'shut up' or 'you're fat' or any other emotionally hurtful statement. There are ways of indicating your dislike of a students behavior without hurting their feelings.

2:46AM PDT on Apr 27, 2012

I know I too wanted to wire up my daughter before she would go to school each day...I would worry that the special ed teacher was going to throw her out of a window if she acted up... you could see the animosity in his eyes when he'd discuss her behavior issues and he never said one positive thing. I look back now and we were trail blazers but at what cost? We were encouraged by ARC members to either take them to task or conversely to be nice and work with them. I'm not sure anymore if that's the correct approach. My thoughts were that my girl wanted to be like everybody else and being in a public school system she might mirror positive role models which would improve her behavior but alas, every day when she'd arrive home from school she threw a major temper tantrum and as a parent you have to try to undo the negatives that haunted her daily...perhaps there aren't that many positive role models to make the difference. Perhaps parents should reconsider public education for their impressionable children. All I know is that her behavior improved once she graduated...what would be your conclusion?

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Care2 - Be Extraordinary - Start a Care2 Petition
ads keep care2 free
CONTACT THE EDITORS

Recent Comments from Causes

12 reasons not to eat turkeys 1. Newborn turkeys search and call for their mothers 2. Turkeys love…

I think he should have waited and sued over this newest order on immigration reform...not Obama's job…

meet our writers

Kristina Chew Kristina Chew teaches and writes about ancient Greek and Latin and is Online Advocacy and Marketing... more
ads keep care2 free



Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.