START A PETITION 25,136,189 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x

Why Divorce Might Be Good for Gay Marriage in Texas

Why Divorce Might Be Good for Gay Marriage in Texas

Texas doesn’t recognize same-sex marriage, but can it allow gay couples to get divorced? That’s the question facing the state’s supreme court in a legal fight that, ironically, could help the marriage equality cause.

The couples involved, H.B. and J.B. of Dallas and Angelique Naylor and Sabrina Daly of Austin were both married in Massachusetts. H.B. and J.B. are now seeking a divorce that the lower courts refused to grant because they believed they didn’t have the power to do so, while Naylor and Daly were granted a divorce by a trial court judge.

In the latter case, Texas Attorney General Greg Abbott appealed the decision. He argues that as Texas does not recognize same-sex marriage, there is no marriage to dissolve and therefore no divorce can be granted. Abott wants the marriages to be voided or, in other words, declared invalid from the start.

However, the Texas Supreme Court appeared leery of that during Tuesday’s hearing. While the nine justices agreed that the question of whether Texas’ gay marriage ban is legal may be linked to whether the state can allow a same-sex divorce, voiding those marriages carries wide ranging legal questions.

That’s because this case goes beyond the 2005 amendment to the Texas constitution that codified a ban on  same-sex marriage within the state to directly tackle the question of whether Texas has the authority to deny the legal recognition that was conferred by Massachusetts. Voiding the marriages would mean directly encroaching on Massachusetts’ power to recognize marriages as it sees fit, something that no state would do lightly. This issue is further complicated by the fact that the federal government does now recognize the couples’ marriages as valid even though the state does not.

The couples’ lawyers argue that the supreme court must either grant the couples a divorce or rule that the state’s gay marriage ban is unconstitutional.

They argue that the constitutional ban Texas is using says nothing about divorce and that the particular framework for divorce actually falls under separate sections of Texas family law. As such, they argue, divorces can be granted on that basis without necessarily recognizing same-sex marriage within the state.

Justice Phil Johnson disagreed with that contention, saying that the state must recognize a marriage before it can grant a divorce. Similarly, Justice Don Willet is quoted as saying, “Don’t you have to presume there is a legal marriage [to grant a divorce]?”

The couple’s lawyers shot back that the state only has to recognize the legitimacy of the fact that the couples were married under Massachusetts law.

The all Republican court also seemed interested as to whether Texas’ gay marriage ban was “driven by irrational animus” against gay and lesbian people. This is of course in reference to the U.S. Supreme Court ruling in Windsor v. United States that was handed down in June of this year. That ruling overturned Section 3 of the federal Defense of Marriage Act on the grounds that it directly sought to treat gay couples unequally and was only driven by the moral disapproval of Congress.

When it came to the Attorney General’s arguments, Justice Phil Johnson was particularly critical of the notion of “voiding” the marriages, noting that as a matter of course, states often recognize out-of-state marriages that the jurisdiction itself does not allow, for instance when it comes to legal marrying ages and marriages between cousins.

The court isn’t expected to issue a ruling for several months yet, but the case suggests a profile that could carry an important ruling in terms of access to same-sex marriage rights. At the very least, a right to same-sex divorce appears to be in the cards. A slightly more ambitious ruling could see Texas’ ban on same-sex marriage undermined with the state’s supreme court deciding that the state cannot legitimately refuse to recognize same-sex marriages from out of state.

A ruling overturning the state’s gay marriage ban in its entirety appears unlikely but it is easy to see how these cases would appear to erode Texas’, until now, staunch refusal to recognize marriage equality. The fact that it may happen as a result of the state attempting to deny the couples in this case the right to divorce is rather funny but serves to show just how precarious the nation’s same-sex marriage bans now appear.

Read more: , , , , ,

Photo credit: Thinkstock.

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it

51 comments

+ add your own
10:43PM PST on Feb 23, 2014

http://ourhappyschool.com/extracurricular/divorce-bill-online-survey-and-open-friendly-debate

10:42PM PST on Feb 23, 2014

I know that some women experiencing a physical violence from their husband,, but for me, Its better that before they got married, its better that the two of them is know each other specially their attitude. Because if they are get divorce, what happen to their children? They are the one who get hurt, or emotionally hurt because of that situation.

http://ourhappyschool.com/extracurricular/divorce-bill-online-survey-and-open-friendly-debate

10:32PM PST on Feb 23, 2014

I know that some women experiencing a physical violence from their husband,, but for me, Its better that before they got married, its better that the two of them is know each other specially their attitude. Because if they are get divorce, what happen to their children? They are the one who get hurt, or emotionally hurt because of that situation.

http://ourhappyschool.com/extracurricular/divorce-bill-online-survey-and-open-friendly-debate

10:20PM PST on Feb 23, 2014

http://ourhappyschool.com/extracurricular/divorce-bill-online-survey-and-open-friendly-debate

10:16PM PST on Feb 23, 2014

I know that some women experiencing a physical violence from their husband,, but for me, Its better that before they got married, its better that the two of them is know each other specially their attitude. Because if they are get divorce, what happen to their children? They are the one who get hurt, or emotionally hurt because of that situation.

10:15PM PST on Feb 23, 2014

Divorce bill is very important, because of the reason that some married couple is not comfortable with their partner and some woman is experiencing a physical violence from their husband.

10:12PM PST on Feb 23, 2014

Marriage is a very important thing to all of us. It's a lifetime commitment that we need to respect and value, and it's against the rule of God. Most important to all, it's not good to the children to see their parents are not together, so before you get married. It is important that each partner to know each other, so that they will not regret their decision.

10:04PM PST on Feb 23, 2014

According to OurhappySchool.com "DIVORCE (OR THE DISSOLUTION OF MARRIAGE) is the final termination of a marital union, canceling the legal duties and responsibilities of marriage and dissolving the bonds of matrimony between the parties.

1:52AM PST on Feb 22, 2014

Thank you Mr carlito for approaching my comment. Yes , I know that some women experiencing a physical violence from their husband,, but for me, Its better that before they got married, its better that the two of them is know each other specially their attitude. Because if they are get divorce, what happen to their children? They are the one who get hurt, or emotionally hurt because of that situation.

1:36AM PST on Feb 22, 2014

Hi Mr. Meinrad. I'm Sorry but I'm not agree with your statement,, For me, Divorce bill is very important, because of the reason that some married couple is not comfortable with their partner and some woman is experiencing a physical violence from their husband.

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

ads keep care2 free

meet our writers

Steve Williams Steve Williams is a passionate supporter of Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Trans (LGBT) rights, human... more
Story idea? Want to blog? Contact the editors!
ads keep care2 free



Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.