START A PETITION 25,136,189 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x
2,490,857 people care about Environment & Wildlife

Why Saying Shark “Attacks” Is Just Plain Wrong

Why Saying Shark “Attacks” Is Just Plain Wrong

Most shark attacks are not “attacks” at all, so say Christopher Neff, a social scientist at the University of Sydney in Australia, and Robert Hueter, a marine biologist heading the shark research center at the Mote Marine Laboratory in Sarasota, Florida, in a new study in the Journal of Environmental Studies and Sciences. Noting that “few phrases in the Western world … evoke as much emotion or as powerful an image as the words ‘shark’ and ‘attack,’” Neff and Hueter argue that we need to change the scary and sensationalistic terminology we use about sharks.

It is not only that it is inaccurate to say that most encounters between sharks and humans are “attacks” that result in injury and even death. What are really “random acts of nature” when a human encounters a wild animal in its native habitat, the ocean, are wrongly portrayed as premediated “crimes.” Talk of “rogue” sharks is really based on fictional portrayals in popular movies such as Jaws rather than on studies of actual shark behavior.

Shark “Attacks”: A Highly Misleading Term

Florida is routinely called the “Shark Attack Capital of the World.” The International Shark Attack File (ISAF) lists 637 confirmed cases of unprovoked shark “attacks” in its waters between 1882 and 2012. But, as Neff and Hueter point out, fatalities occurred in eleven out of those many cases, a total of only 2 percent. 98 percent of incidents involving sharks were non-fatal and would more properly be termed “shark encounters,” “shark bites” or even “shark sightings.”

In reevaluating 200 shark “attacks” between 1900 and 2009 in New South Wales in Australia, Neff and Hueter found that 38 resulted in no injury. As some of the “attacks” were from “relatively benign species, the wobbegong shark (Orectolobus spp.), they recategorized these as shark “bites.”

One reason for rising numbers of human and shark encounters (and reports of these in the media) is indeed because of “increases in the number of recreational water users choosing to surf, kayak, body board, and paddle board.”

More Accurate Ways To Talk About Shark “Attacks”

Neff and Hueter propose that media outlets adopt new labels that can more “properly inform the public of the overwhelming number of human–shark interactions that are not life threatening.” “Shark sightings” occur when the animals are near but no contact actually takes place; “shark encounters” are a “close call with a swimmer or a surfboard” involving no injury; “shark bites” occur when only “a single bite and only minor injury” result. The term “fatal shark bites” can be used for the small percentage of incidents that end in death.

As Neff and Hueter write, “the time has come to codify our contemporary understanding of human–shark interactions into new categories that move beyond the ‘Jaws effect’ and acknowledge the public value of a balanced, outcome-based approach.” The routine portrayal of sharks as “man-eating” creatures who go out of their way to “attack” humans is driving sharks “into extinction,” AFP says. Talking about shark “attacks” may be great for headlines but it is “misplaced scientifically and misleading to the public” and keeps untrue, and unfair, stereotypes about sharks alive. At a time when sharks face extinction, such “inflammatory” misrepresentations are only endanger their already fragile existence more.

Related Care2 Coverage

3 Victories in Fighting the Illegal Wildlife Trade

Sharks Have Brains Like… Ours

Australia Okays Hunting of the Great White Shark

Read more: , , , , , , , ,

Photo from Thinkstock

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it

161 comments

+ add your own
3:50AM PDT on May 10, 2013

Very interesting thank you!

11:04AM PDT on May 8, 2013

when you get into the ocean you are risking being bitten by the native wildlife. Not just sharks either. My brother was stung by a jellyfish. I am not sure why people get so worked up, if we sent kids to play in the middle of the jungle we would expect a spider bite or a wild animal "attack".. why are we so shocked when ocean life reacts the same way? Attacks fuel fear, like the killings in 1916, and we simply can't afford to kill sharks. They are key elements of the oceans biodiversity and eco system. They are DINOSAURS in their own right, history swimming powerfully in the depths.

8:13AM PDT on Mar 16, 2013

We kill more sharks in a year than sharks have killed people in general. 73 million sharks were killed last year over this crazy shark fin soup. A coconut kills more people in a year than shark attacks. We should be signing wavers every time we choose to swim in an ocean that belongs to sharks and other marine life. If we were slaughtering cats and dogs like we are sharks, there would be an outrage of supporters. I'm sure we will wipe out the pitbulls just like we are doing to sharks

9:02PM PST on Feb 20, 2013

Everything needs to eat... don't want to be attacked? Get out of the water when you hear the music

12:35PM PST on Feb 18, 2013

when it gets tangled around your leg: Jellyfish ATTACK!

When you step on it in the water:Starfish ATTACK!

When you stub your toe on it at the beach: Seashell ATTACK!

8:22PM PST on Feb 17, 2013

Thanks

11:25AM PST on Feb 17, 2013

humans attac is always right.
ty

5:38PM PST on Feb 16, 2013

I think that when humans enter the oceans or any body of water, they are invading a habitat. They should respect it and realize that there may be some dangers. It is much more dangerous to drive a car. Sharks do not attack people to hurt them or kill them. It is either mistaken identity, or curiosity. It all depends on how people interperet the word attack. Get out your thesaurus...let's see, strike, foray...I don't know. Maybe you could state it "There was an incident involving a human and shark..."

7:33AM PST on Feb 16, 2013

interesting article, thanks for sharing :)

7:23PM PST on Feb 14, 2013

It's a tricky one. I live in Western Australia, the shark "attack" capital of the world, and grew up going to the beach regularly. My first reaction to the article was to think "PC gone mad again", but unfortunately even today some people do see sharks as rogue killers, out to chase down humans. We very recently had an awful incident here where some morons chased down a shark, hung it up on their boat, beat it and tortured it, laughing while videoing. This was supposedly revenge for a shark "attack". Of course, it wasn't the same shark, but as I said, these guys were morons. This might sound crazy but I think most of the problems with sharks is simply that they don't have hands; like puppies, if they want to investigate anything it goes straight into their mouths. Most of them get us confused with seals, especially when we wear black rubber wetsuits with flippers. Nearly all of them don't like the taste of people, and spit us out when they realize what we are. Unfortunately, some of them are so huge that by the time this happens the person is dead or seriously injured. I must add that I've nothing but sympathy for the injuries and fear experienced by people who have survived this experience.

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Care2 - Be Extraordinary - Start a Care2 Petition
ads keep care2 free
CONTACT THE EDITORS

Recent Comments from Causes

It's sad that the little boy lost his life, but Onion basically lost his life also. He was taken away…

Only 10 saved ? So what happened to the others and how many were killed? Not much of a happy endin…

Magnificent and intelligent creatures, thanks for posting

meet our writers

Kristina Chew Kristina Chew teaches and writes about ancient Greek and Latin and is Online Advocacy and Marketing... more
ads keep care2 free

more from causes




Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.