START A PETITION 27,000,000 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x
925,350 people care about Women's Rights

Woman’s Life Endangered Because She Sought Treatment at a Catholic Hospital

Woman’s Life Endangered Because She Sought Treatment at a Catholic Hospital

In 2012, the world learned of the case of Savita Halappanavar, a pregnant woman in Ireland who died because a Catholic hospital refused to allow her to terminate the pregnancy of her 17 week fetus once she began miscarrying. Savita’s death sparked a roaring debate in the country over their abortion law, which is so strict that a patient literally could die while waiting for doctors to determine whether her life is in jeopardy enough to allow a procedure.

Here in America, even with legal abortion, some are still facing the same life or death situations, all because they have the misfortune to have a Catholic hospital as their nearest caregiver. It is because of this that the American Civil Liberties Union has filed a lawsuit against the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB).

The ACLU is representing Tamesha Means, a Michigan woman who in 2010 entered the only hospital nearby, having just had her water break at 18 weeks pregnant. According to the Detroit Free Press, Means was sent back home, despite the fact that having a broken water sac would leave her at high risk for infection. She was not offered any other care.

At 18 weeks, a fetus is still at minimum over a month away from viability, and there is absolutely nothing that can be done to continue the pregnancy for that much longer. To avoid any risk to her health, a traditional hospital would be likely to offer a surgical abortion to end the pregnancy before she could be put at risk of infection or induce the pregnancy so she could deliver the fetus (albeit too early for it to survive). But because this was a Catholic hospital, both options were not only refused to her, they weren’t even mentioned to Means as a way of safeguarding her health, because they would be seen as intervening to end a pregnancy early. Instead, Means was sent home, in pain, to wait to miscarry on her own. When she returned to the hospital to seek out treatment again, the process was repeated.

It was only on Means’ third visit to the hospital, this time with an infection and in the midst of finally delivering the baby, that the hospital allowed her to stay and treated her.

The hospital’s actions, according to the ACLU, is a direct result of the USCCB’s directives, which forbid any abortion or delivery of an infant pre-viability, even if the pregnant person’s life is in danger. Because of that rule, which is handed down from the USCCB itself, the legal team states that the USCCB is responsible for Means’ situation, as well as any person who may find themselves denied health care options and best practices because of a religious mandate.

“The best interests of the patient must always come first and this fundamental ethic is central to the medical profession,” Kary Moss, executive director of the ACLU of Michigan, told the Detroit Free Press. “In this case, a young woman in a crisis situation was put at risk because religious directives were allowed to interfere with her medical care. Patients should not be forced to suffer because of a hospital’s religious affiliation.”

The takeover of the health care system by religious hospitals that may not provide full spectrum care is a serious one in the country, as mergers continue to consolidate more health care facilities under fewer boards. As for-profit and public hospitals enter into partnerships with religious ones, it is often the Catholic directives that are followed as a condition of the merger, leaving patients with limited access to abortions, emergency contraception, tubal ligation and end of life decisions. These religious hospitals also act as barriers when it comes to states that are mandating that clinics that provide abortions get admitting privileges, even if the abortions are performed somewhere else. Each hospital that merges with a religious hospital becomes one more place where the directives of the USCCB, rather than the opinions and diagnoses of the medical practitioners, hold final sway over what treatments can be offered.

According to the Washington Post, one in six Americans will be treated in a Catholic hospital. If you end up that one, will you get the best medical care your doctors have to offer? Or will you only receive what the Catholic Bishops allow?

Read more: , , , , , , ,

Photo credit: Thinkstock

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it

168 comments

+ add your own
1:02AM PST on Jan 27, 2014

How sad that this woman had to die because someone didn't care about her life, only the life of a baby that wouldn't survive anyway.

7:12PM PST on Dec 20, 2013

reproductive rights are human rights. I answer to my own spiritual beliefs, and no one else

4:08PM PST on Dec 12, 2013

"First do no harm." Don and I CA! :-))

1:02PM PST on Dec 12, 2013

Mandy H, unfortunately there are many parts of the US where a Catholic hospital is literally the ONLY hospital in the area! Worse, since Catholic hospitals are allowed to let their religious beliefs run roughshod over a patient's rights, anyone with a DNR, needing contraception, abortion care, or sterilization is pretty much SOL. That kind of policy is bad enough, but for the hospital in question to refuse to treat this woman until she actually started to miscarry in earnest (and was in fact suffering from an infection as a result of medical neglect in the meantime!) should be considered criminal behavior! A nonviable zygote/embryo/fetus does NOT trump an already-born, living, breathing woman! I hope this hospital loses the lawsuit. Go ACLU!

8:12PM PST on Dec 9, 2013

Thanks for the post.

10:12AM PST on Dec 7, 2013

I hate to blame the victim but you've got to start asking why these women aren't going to a non-catholic hospital. Perhaps it's just in Australia but we've got several different types of hospitals all relatively near each other. Or you can just change the laws to ensure that the church owned hospitals CAN'T refuse a woman an abortion when her symptoms get to a certain level, every doctor knows the difference between concerning symptoms and ones that are near critical. The idea would be to make it law to give a woman an abortion once the symptoms are approaching critical but not yet life threatening. Or you could just tell the idiots to stop enforcing their stupid beliefs onto dieing women. I told the doctors in a Catholic hospital to give me a script for the pill because I wasn't going to spend another agonising week in hospital on medication to keep me from chucking up my guts and passing out from the pain. Believe it or not the doctor gave me the script but my dad had to go to a nearby pharmacy because the hospital pharmacy wasn't allowed to fill it.

7:53PM PST on Dec 6, 2013

Interesting question about DNRs and Catholic hospitals.

There's a lot out there (of course) on Google but here's one piece I found...

http://news.firedoglake.com/2009/11/24/catholic-bishops-enact-plan-for-300000-terri-schiavos/

4:48PM PST on Dec 6, 2013

TYFS...it is good to be aware of such things. Made me automatically think of DNR's and whether or not they would be honored as well. Very important for the patient and the family to be aware of such policies.

10:58AM PST on Dec 6, 2013

Thank you!

6:38AM PST on Dec 6, 2013

Thanks for sharing.

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

Care2 - Be Extraordinary - Start a Care2 Petition
ads keep care2 free
CONTACT THE EDITORS

Recent Comments from Causes

Great story so happy he got his dog back and nice the stranger had a big heart to befriend the dog and…

I'm happy these 8 rabbits were lucky enough to be taken in by Mino Valley. Too bad so many others must…

ads keep care2 free

more from causes

Animal Welfare

Causes Canada

Causes UK

Children

Civil Rights

Education

Endangered Wildlife

Environment & Wildlife

Global Development

Global Warming

Health Policy

Human Rights

LGBT rights

Politics

Real Food

Trailblazers For Good

Women's Rights




Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.