my care2
make a difference
healthy & green living: more than 5,000 ways to enhance your life

customize your free newsletter

Customize your Healthy & Green Living newsletter now


2 Cookware Materials to Avoid

posted by Annie B. Bond Nov 4, 2008 5:00 pm
2 Cookware Materials to Avoid
33 comments

To run a greener kitchen and household, some cookware materials are better than others. Whether you simply dabble in the kitchen or cook up a storm, there are some kinds of cookware to steer clear of when buying pots and pans. Here’s a good rundown about two materials you don’t want to be eating but that are commonly found in cookware, from Easy Green Living, a new book by Renee Loux:

Aluminum
Aluminum conducts heat brilliantly, but it’s really dangerous to allow it to come in direct contact with food. It’s a soft, highly reactive (especially with acidic foods) metal that can leach into food. It’s toxic, genotoxic (can cause genetic mutation), and may disrupt hormones. The most dangerous danger is that aluminum is neurotoxic; it can cross the blood-brain barrier and may be linked to Alzheimer’s disease. Proponents of aluminum cookware say it’s debatable how many aluminum molecules get into food, but many scientists and doctors say it’s a serious health risk. I won’t use aluminum foil to come into contact with cooking food at all costs. Aluminum cookware that is coated with stainless steel is safer–in fact, some of the best heavy-bottomed stainless steel pots and pans have aluminum in their bases to better conduct heat. However, I would advise you to avoid non-stick-coated aluminum pots and pans at all costs because I believe that both materials are really bad for you.

Teflon-coated and other non-stick pots and pans
The chemicals used to make pots and pans non-stick are toxic and hazardous to humans, wildlife, and the environment. They’re widely believed to be carcinogenic, bioaccumulate in tissues over time, and persist in perpetuity in the environment because there is no known mechanism that can break them down. Non-stick chemicals have consistently been linked with developmental disorders, birth defects, and cancer and have been shown to be highly toxic to the liver, kidneys, and blood. Companies that manufacture non-stick products insist that they’re safe and they won’t break down or emit fumes under normal cooking conditions. But it doesn’t take a doctoral degree to contest that pots and pans can get very hot very fast and that they scratch easily, which means flecks of the coating can end up in food.

The original manufacturers of non-stick chemicals, 3M, even stopped making them, citing “principles of responsible environmental management,” but one company (ahem, DuPont) keeps up production despite the EPA’s campaign to reduce and eliminate the use of these dastardly chemicals for the sake of all beings on the planet. The bottom line is, don’t buy them. If you have them, don’t use them for cooking.

Unfortunately, there is no way to recycle non-stick pots and pans, but a good idea might be to send them back to the manufacturer with a little note saying, “Enough is enough, stop with non-stick chemicals already. Quit harming humans and the world at large.”

More on Health & Safety (196 articles available)
More from Annie B. Bond (3247 articles available)

33 comments

Go to the Source

33 comments

add your comment »
33 comments add your comment
Dorothy O.

My mom used heavy aluminum cookware many years while I was growing up. Aluminum foil was a staple in the kitchen, going camping, etc. We never used under-arm protection with aluminum. I doubt that food cooked in aluminum is really a problem. I think aluminum sitting on the skin is worse as it can be absorbed directly. I have gradually quit using aluminum or coated cookware as it deteriorates with age. I use glass or pottery in the microwave oven, which I enjoy. I have good steel/copper pots and pans that lasted many years. I have several crock pots which I use a lot. It seems I'm using the right things.

Marietta P.

I already wrote in on another thread that all of my birds died three weeks ago yesterday because of an oven liner that got compromise over a year and a half usage and set off PTFE fumes. My African Grey was like a child to me and died in my hands on the way to animal emergency just 20 minutes after being exposed. My cockatiels were dead in their cage when I got home. This liner manufacturer does not mention PTFEs or danger to pet birds in any packaging or website. I knew about teflon but since it is a trademark name for Dupont products other manufacterers do not need to mention it in their materials. I found out the hard way. My birds were NOT in the kitchen when I had the oven in use for 25 minutes at only 375 degrees and were no in the same room as each other, yet they all died of lung hemmoraging, cause by teflon toxicity. Be forwarded!

Brad S.
  • Brad S. says
  • Nov 11, 2008 8:05 PM

I BOUGHT A SCANPAN FROM THE KITCHENSTORE. I talked to them about safety. I thought it ws a good choice. I would like to know more.

Elizabeth A.

Another question: Where does the danger from non-stick items come from? By that, I mean, what is it exactly that poses risks? Is it the off-gassing, the potential to transfer to food during cooking, chipping and exposing the materials underneath or is it just the manufacturing process and all the chemicals that are used for that? I generally stay away from such items, but I'm curious to learn more about it and know the specifics of the dangers related to using the items.

Elizabeth A.

Does anyone know if the risks associated with using non-stick items is reduced if the food doesn't actually touch the pan? I'm thinking specifically of when I BAKE with non-stick items but use parchment paper so the goods don't actually come in contact with the pans/sheets.

Susan S.

Recycling old Teflon pans is possible. I cashed mine in at the local metal recycling business in my area. These pans are catagorized as dirty aluminum which pays out less than aluminum. This way you get to recycle them and make a couple of dollars. BONUS!!!!

Jack N.
  • Jack N. says
  • Nov 8, 2008 10:28 PM

Has hard anodized aluminum cookware been lumped in with all aluminum cookware for the purposes of this article? It is my understanding that anodized is much safer and poses no real health concerns, but it would be great to get a definitive answer on this.

Dennis M.

Hello, Annie: Thanks for sharing your concerns about non-stick (aka Teflon) cookware. Your articles led me to do a little research of my own. Thusfar, I have been unable to find any collaborative cautions expressed by either the FDA or the EPA. Both agencies seem to be satisfied with the safety of Teflon non-stick cookware.

Some clarification is in order, however, concerning DuPont's $16,000.000 fine. Anti-nonstick advocates continue to confuse this issue in the belief that Teflon non-stick coatings are poisonous and contain unsafe levels of chemical "C-8." Health and wellness literature, both electronic and print, are still riff with such warnings. DuPont was not fined for excessive levels of C-8 in non-stick cookware. They were fined for C-8 environmental contamination and for exposing their employees to hazardous materials (C-8) without adequate protection. Equally unconscionable, but, not the same.

While C-8 is used in the manufacture of non-stick coatings, it is not a component of the finished product. This is to say that residual traces that might be found are measured in parts per billion and are viewed as safe, in such miniscule amounts. One part per billion being comparable to one second in 31.7 years.

Do you suppose that the cookware industry itself is behind these safety rumours? I mean, what if we all throw away our non-stick pans, only to later discover that they were safe, all along? Most likely, we would go out and buy more. Wouldn't that

Paul Za

What about titanium? I know that titanium is being offered in cookware for camping due to its strength to weight ratio. Very light but stronger than steel. And I also read that it is an inert metal like stainless steel. Any thoughts anyone?

Adria Frenzel

Does anyone know anything about cookware called a Scan Pan? Not sure if is is safe though it advertises being ecofriendly!!

Please enter your comment.
Or, log in with your
Facebook account:
1500 characters remaining

who's talking about this story?

Disclaimer: Care2.com does not warrant and shall have no liability for information provided in this newsletter or on Care2.com. Each individual person, fabric, or material may react differently to a particular suggested use. It is recommended that before you begin to use any formula, you read the directions carefully and test it first. Should you have any health care-related questions or concerns, please call or see your physician or other health care provider.

1011124

Copyright © 2009 Care2.com, inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved