Black Cat Balderdash

Knock at our door on Halloween prepared to be greeted by Bombalurina, Grizabella, Jennyanydots, the most Magical Mr. Mistoffelees, Mungojerrie, Old Deuternonomy, Macavity, Rumpleteazer, Rum Tum Tugger, Skimbleshanks, or – depending on our whim each year – any other Jellicle that prowled on and offstage during Andrew Lloyd Weber’s delightful musical Cats. No flimsy, disposable approximation for the Garey girls; we go all out with homesewn, faux fur costumes and artfully applied makeup to recreate our favorite characters, and with little prompting, my daughter treats our visitors to her Broadway-worthy version of “Memory.”

Accompanying Amanda is a veritable orchestra of angry, hostile and thoroughly disgusted musicians, their caterwauling emanating from a room deep within the house. Each has a distinct musical howl, yet they all have one thing in common – they are black cats from throughout our neighborhood, here to spend an evening in secure seclusion because October 31st is the most dangerous night of the year for their kind.

In a society driven by statistics, I am unable to provide an absolute number, but based on personal experience and reports from cat-fancying friends and acquaintances, there is a marked increase in the maiming, disappearance and even destruction of black cats this time of year. Coincidence? Perhaps. Occult rituals? Possibly, in some cultures so inclined. Cruelty? A definite probability. Stupidity, superstition and outright ignorance? Unfortunately, even in this age of enlightenment, a very real and horrible likelihood.

As a species, Felis domesticus once was held in highest esteem in Egypt, then considered the civilized world. In fact, the most commonly held superstition – the fear of a black cat crossing one’s path – is comparatively modern and antithetical to the honor and reverence shown toward felines when history records they were initially domesticated around 3000 B.C.

Europe during the Middle Ages was fraught with a dread of cats, particularly in England, and especially directed toward black felines. Distrust and fear were fed by their innate independence, stealth and nocturnal behavior, coupled with an inexplicable and sudden overpopulation in major cities. Strays were often fed by reclusive elderly ladies, and when witch hysteria struck Europe, and many of these homeless women were accused of espousing the dark arts, their cat companions (especially black ones) were deemed guilty of witchery by association.

One popular British feline urban legend illustrates the thinking of the day. In Lincolnshire in the 1560s, a man and his son were startled one moonless night when a small creature darted across their path into a crawl space. Casting stones into the opening, they saw an injured black cat scurry out and limp into the adjacent home of a woman suspected by the town of being a witch. Next day, the two encountered the woman, her face bruised, arm swathed in bandages. And she now walked with a limp. Rumors arose. Gossip ensued and from that day forward, all black cats in Lincolnshire were suspected of being witches in night-disguise.

Many societies in the late Middle Ages strove to drive cats into extinction. As the witch scare mounted to paranoia, many innocent women and their harmless pets were burned at the stake. A baby born with eyes too bright, a face too canny, a personality too precocious, was actually killed for fear that it hosted a spirit that would eventually become a witch by day, a black cat by night. In France, thousands of cats were burned monthly until King Louis XIII, in the 1630s, halted the shameful practice. Given the number of centuries in which black cats were slaughtered throughout Europe, it is surprising that the gene for the color black was not deleted from the species . . . Unless the cat does possess nine lives.

Of significant historical irony is that felines may well have saved humanity from extinction. Bubonic Plague, a disease spread by flea-riddled rats and also referred to as the Black Death, was one of the deadliest pandemics in human history, peaking in Europe between 1348 and 1350. The plague was thought to have killed 30% to 60% of Europe’s population, reducing the global census from an approximate 450 million to between 350 and 375 million in 1400. The Great Plague of London of 1665-66 was the last major outbreak of Black Death in England, killed an estimated 100,000 people or 20% of London’s population. With no pharmaceutical cure or preventative available, it is now acknowledged that spread of the disease was halted by elimination of the vector source thanks to natural means – the predatory nature of starving, ordinary alley cats.

Still, superstitions persisted and, in time, crossed the pond to America. The notion of witches transforming themselves into black cats in order to prowl streets unobserved became a central belief in New England during the Salem witch hunts. Thus, an animal once looked on with Egyptian approbation became a creature dreaded, reviled, despised and maligned. Fortunately, once the idiocy of this practice was acknowledged, cats regained their rightful place in millions of American hearts, hearths and homes, yet their autumnal mystique continues to this day.

Next page: Warnings! Samhain, All Hallows’ Eve, and El Dia de Los Muertos – things you should know.

Black cats have so long been associated with witches and witchcraft that during October, the month of Halloween, they are favorite icons used for costumes, home decor, and party themes. This folk lore embellished trend is so embedded in modern society that we’ve forgotten that the holiday we celebrate today had ancient beginnings still held in reverence today:

* Samhain: The religious year of Pagans starts and ends with Samhain, which is also the beginning of the Celtic new year, as well as an occasion to honor one’s ancestors;

* All Hallows’ Eve: Roman Catholics celebrate the first of November as The Solemnity of All Saints. October 31st is thereby designated as All Hallows’ Eve, since the saints celebrated on November 1st are considered hallowed. The following day is observed as All Soul’s Day;

* El Dia de Los Muertos: This Hispanic holiday focuses on gatherings of family and friends to pray for and remember friends and family members who have died. Traditions include building private altars honoring the deceased, using sugar skulls, marigolds, and the favorite foods and beverages of the departed, and visiting graves with these as gifts.

As the merriment approaches, please pay heed to the vulnerability of all cats, regardless of color, at this time of year:

* Don’t leave your cat out in the yard on Halloween; the reasons are obvious;

* Trick-or-treat candies are not for pets: Chocolate is poisonous to a lot of animals, and tin foil and cellophane candy wrappers can be hazardous if swallowed. [An aside - it is my humble opinion that throughout recorded history, only ONE batch of "candy corn" has ever been produced, gets collected worldwide surreptitiously, repackaged, and redistributed annually.];

* Be mindful of animals around candle-lit pumpkins: Pets may knock them over and cause fires. Curious kittens especially run the risk of getting burned.

* Don’t dress kitties in costumes; arched backs, fur on edge and glittering, slitted eyes are purr-fect all by themselves!

From the Kitten Smittens – Good Samhain, Blessed All-Hallow’s, Felicidades por el Dia de Los Muertos, and a Boo-tiful Happy Halloween!

Love This? Never Miss Another Story.


Annie Flanders
Annie Flanders1 years ago

another beautiful story from our dear janet.

blessings to all who keep her stories alive

Mariniki Liani
Past Member 2 years ago


beverly g.
beverly gannon5 years ago

I LOVE cats, all cats, i am a cat lover fanantic all cats all over the globe, domestic and wild. Above all, i love all animals and they should not be hurt, but treated with respect and warmth and kindness. Have a PURRFECT Halloween everyone, everywhere.

mr Crowley
mr Crowley5 years ago

interesting, thanks!

Autumn Rose
Autumn Rose5 years ago

I think it's dumb to be racist against anyone let alone a cat!

Jean Lord
Jean Lord5 years ago

Black cats are beautiful. I have had several and mine were strictly indoor.

gerlinde p.
gerlinde p.5 years ago

i just took in 2 black kittens for fostering, but they get along so well with my other pets,i`ve decided to keep them.

Sue A.
sue A.5 years ago

lovely story - thanks Janet!

Alisa C.
Alisa C.6 years ago

such a nice story

Martina F.
Martina F.6 years ago

Hi Starlite,
I read the article and it actually says that it is inconclusive as to whether or not black cats (or any cats for that matter) are more at risk at Hallowe'en. So I think that describing Janets article as perpetuating an urban myth is stretching it just a little...:)