Blood Type Diet Debunked

Dr. Peter D’Adamo’s book Eat Right for Your Type makes the astounding claim that people with different blood types should eat different foods. Type O’s, for example, are supposed to be like the hunter and eat a lot of meat, whereas type A’s are supposed to eat less. A 2013 systematic review of the evidence supporting blood type diets was published in one of the world’s most prestigious nutrition journals. The researchers didn’t find any.

The researchers sifted through over a thousand papers that might shed some light on the issue, and none of the studies showed an association between blood type diets and health-related outcomes. They†conclude that “there is currently no evidence that an adherence to blood type diets will provide health benefits, despite the substantial presence and perseverance of blood type diets within the health industry.”

Ten years earlier, the Journal of the Norwegian Medical Association released a number of papers that came out of a day-long scientific seminar held by the Norwegian Society for Nutrition. 40,000 copies of the Eat Right for Your Type had been sold in Norway, and so the researchers sought to determine whether blood type diets were visionary science or nonsense. They also concluded that they are nonsense.

The author of the blood type diet book responded to the review on his website, saying that “there is good science behind the blood type diet, just like there was good science behind Einstein’s mathematical calculations.” He says that if blood type diets were just tested in the right way, like how Einstein’s E=MC2 was, he would be vindicated. The reason we don’t see any studies on blood types and nutrition, he complains, is “because of little interest and available money.” But he’s sold more than seven million books. Why doesn’t he fund his own studies? That’s what the Atkins Corporation did.

In fact, he has! In 1996, he wrote, “I am beginning the eighth year of a ten year trial on reproductive cancers, using the Blood Type Diets Ö By the time I release the results in another 2 years, I expect to make it scientifically demonstrable that the Blood Type Diet plays a role in cancer remission.” OK, so that would be 1998. The results? Still not released, sixteen years later.

Good tactic, though, saying you’re just about to publish a study and banking that nobody would actually follow up. So in his sequel, he said he was currently conducting a “twelve-week randomized, double-blind, controlled trial implementing the Blood Type Diet, to determine its effects on the outcomes of patients with rheumatoid arthritis.” That was ten years ago.

As my Norwegian colleague bemoaned, “it is difficult not to perceive the whole thing as a crass fraud.”

So rarely are popular press diet books afforded such fact-checking. Kudos to these researchers. If only we had this 17 years ago when the book was on the bestseller list!

I have a few videos on popular diets, such as:

I wrote a book about low-carb diets, with the full-text now available for free at AtkinsFacts.org

    In health,
    Michael Greger, M.D.

    PS: If you haven’t yet, you can subscribe to my free videos here and watch my live year-in-review presentations†Uprooting the Leading Causes of Death, More Than an Apple a Day, and From Table to Able.

    Related:
    Convincing Doctors to Embrace Lifestyle Medicine
    Big Food Wants Final Say Over Health Reports
    Half of Doctors Give Placebos

    103 comments

    Carole R.
    Carole R2 years ago

    Silly notion.

    SEND
    Nikki Davey
    Nikki Davey2 years ago

    Quack

    SEND
    Judith C.
    Judith C3 years ago

    Eat less, weigh less regardless

    SEND
    Elena Poensgen
    Elena Poensgen3 years ago

    Thank you :)

    SEND
    Debbi W.
    Debbi -3 years ago

    I'm sure a lot of people who tried that diet could have told the author it didn't work.

    SEND
    Julia Oleynik
    Julia Oleynik3 years ago

    Of course it can't be true!) Thanks for sharing

    SEND
    Roberto Meritoni
    Roberto Meritoni3 years ago

    Thanks

    SEND
    Darren Woolsey
    Darren W3 years ago

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blood_type_diet

    SEND
    Rita odessa
    Rita Odessa3 years ago

    I an O blood type, I don't eat meat but I still eat fish from time to time. I don't eat any dairy either. I had thinning hair but that was result of a thyroid issue, had a nodule but blood work ok. Medical world wouldn't help because the blood work was okay my doctor said nodules don't typically shrink. I started seeing a naturopath who treated me as though I had a thyroid issue and this year the nodule was too small to biopsy. Therefore what medical science couldn't do alternative medicine did and the nodule did shrink.
    Point is you can't believe everything your told or read, you have to determine what is right for you.
    I feel fine not eating meat, and I do not believe my O type means I need to eat meat.

    SEND
    Slava R.
    Slava R3 years ago

    ok

    SEND