START A PETITION 25,136,189 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x

Drug Discovery in Ayurveda

Drug Discovery in Ayurveda

by Dr. Remya Krishnan, Contributor to Ayurveda on Allthingshealing.com

Editor’s Note from Sonica Krishan: This is an article submission by an author who is well versed with the sarcasm of drug discovery that seems to be cropping up in the Ayurveda medicine system. Her article compels the reader to understand and analyze the implications of the ‘new’ drug discovery in Ayurveda which seems to be not so much in flow with the authentic Ayurveda practices that have been carried out since ages. Please have a read.

Scope of new drug discovery has only secondary importance in Ayurveda until every “old drugs” and formulations with multi therapeutic actions (Karma) in the Ayurvedic medical literature are judiciously explored for their “effects” (not actions) in accordance to the state and stage of their application in various diseases in terms of Ayurvedic principles of Clinical Pathology and Pharmacology.

Although, the current trend in Ayurvedic drug research is the blind copying of western methodologies like bio- assay guided fractionation to discover any “active’’ compound by several cycles of fractionation of the extract linked with testing for activity of each fraction , until pure compounds are isolated from the fraction. Then experimental studies are conducted by using Western methodologies usually comprising some tests for relevant biological activity linked with the extract or any active compound. Thus most of the researches in all Ayurvedic research institutes are fundamentally designed imperfectly on the basis of biochemistry or molecular biology of the disease and their action is observed by conducting in vitro bio assays.

It’s disheartening to find that, the brilliant fundamental research protocols of Ayurveda has little relevance to these tests used except that it provided screening samples selected on the basis of their classical use mentioned in Ayurvedic medical literature. But unlike ethno pharmacological research which employ screening samples based on their assumed biological effects on certain “signs and symptoms” whose causes and effects are scientifically unknown and unexplored, Ayurvedic Medical system is based on solid rational thinking and scientific infrastructure (Basic evidences) well enough to explain the action and application of any Ayurvedic drug/medicine with  its accurate appropriate purpose in  each and every clinical status. Hence the very best test to verify a reputed efficacy of any known drug in Ayurveda in a particular clinical status is a well defined and designed clinical trial designed primarily on the basis of Ayurvedic clinical research guidelines and not really by bio assay guided fractionation! Moreover, these invitro test systems using animal tissue, cultured cells, cloned receptors or enzyme system could never ever successfully explain the exact scientific mechanisms of underlying pathogenesis in human body based on the fundamental Ayurvedic understanding and wisdom. For example, the key mechanisms in any inflammatory disease like for “Arthritis” (Modern Medicine) in terms of Ayurvedic pathology is not merely associated with the formation of various mediators involved such as lipoxigenases and cyclo-oxygenases involved in eicosanoid synthesis which are merely  again only the probable effects seen owing to a further deep underlying well definable reason which is well solely precisely identifiable by  accurately employing  the Ayurvedic  research methodologies . Thus Ayurveda targets to identify every cause and circumstance in the particular host responsible for the particular pathogenesis and not merely the pathogenesis as such. Again, the purpose of Ayurvedic clinical research is not to establish a guess ( probability) to the nature of active components of “anti inflammatory activity” but rather to judiciously explicate the cause and effects of the particular pathogenesis and mode of action and application of drug therapy in the particular status of pathogenesis in  that specific host . So adoption of these western methodologies like bioassay guided process which culminates in the discovery of a well known compound is an utter waste of time and resources in Ayurveda and at the same time is turning no way beneficial to the scientific updating of this science . Can ever French or German language be acquired by learning English grammar?

Read more: Alternative Therapies, Ayurveda, Drugs, Fitness, General Health, Health, Men's Health, Natural Remedies, Uncategorized, Women's Health, , , , , ,

have you shared this story yet?

go ahead, give it a little love

Dr. Neala Peake, selected from AllThingsHealing.com

All Things Healing (allthingshealing.com) is an online portal and community dedicated to informing and educating people across the globe about alternative healing of mind, body, spirit and the planet at large. We are committed to bringing together a worldwide community of individuals and organizations who are working to heal themselves, each other, and the world. We offer 39 healing categories, 80 plus editors who are experts in their fields, a forum for each category, and an extensive "Find Practitioners" listing. Our Costa Rica Learning Center and Spiritual Retreat is coming soon. Join us!

23 comments

+ add your own
4:18AM PDT on Sep 17, 2012

noted

2:35AM PDT on Aug 18, 2012

a little hard to read info....but i tend to agree that occidental medicine should not meddle, with traditional medicines that are tried and true, such as Chinese or Ayurvedic medicine...
Western medicine has a whole different approach, which is certainly not in prevention, and doesn't take into account body types or wholistic lifestyle, and mainly relies on pharmaceuticals!

10:43AM PDT on Aug 13, 2012

Thanks

1:16AM PDT on Aug 10, 2012

In my course of studies a long time ago, we conducted several exercises in Communication using a "readability scale". This article would score extremely low in readability.

I was interested in learning more, but found that what I was reading, was as clear as mud.

5:08AM PDT on Aug 9, 2012

Wow! Very informative. I am always troubled by the scientific attempts to break down herbal remedies to find "the" "active ingredient" with no regard to the synergistic actions and complicated relationships of everything in the original matter. It sounds like the approach is even more ridiculous for Ayurvedic medicine.

8:08AM PDT on Aug 8, 2012

As a fan of Ayurvedic medicine but also a believer in integrative methods, I find this article off-putting, not to mention poorly written. If its intention was to educate, then it needs serious editing to clarify its points.

8:03AM PDT on Aug 8, 2012

OK

4:23AM PDT on Aug 8, 2012

thanks

4:03AM PDT on Aug 8, 2012

Thanks

9:08PM PDT on Aug 7, 2012

Food for thought.

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

people are talking

Good article, thank you ; )

I love grapefruit. Thanks Lisa!

I had a rescue that didn't get proper socialization as a kitten and was litterly thrown in a bag and…

Thank you for the article, but now I'm more terrified than ever!

CONTACT THE EDITORS



Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.