START A PETITION 27,000,000 members: the world's largest community for good

Green Girl Hits Hand Sanitizer

Green Girl Hits Hand Sanitizer

The other day my friend walked into my dorm room, and I nearly keeled over. She had just used the hand sanitizer in our floor bathroom, and the smell was ridiculously strong. Now, people had been using this sanitizer all year (I myself have used it on occasion, though Iím more of a soap person), and it had not bothered me very much. I didnít like the smell of it, but it wasnít terrible.

I donít know what changed for me, but something did. I absolutely cannot stand it It gives me a headache and makes me want to throw up at the same time. I can smell the chemicals wafting toward me. Itís terrible.

The problem: Our dorm bathroom is not very well-equipped. We have this hand sanitizer or we have that pink soap that seems to be a staple in every communal/public restroom. The immediate issue with washing our hands is the lack of towels in the bathroom. Meaning, there are none. Thatís right. No paper-towel dispenser. Hence, using soap and water is problematic, whereas hand sanitizer is easy.

While it is tempting, I have determined that hand sanitizer is not the way to go (see above). So, yes, I use the soap and water and then rush back to my room with wet hands to the towel waiting invitingly in my room. Then, comes my question of whether or not I should even be using that soapómy mother was never pleased with using it in public restroomsómaybe itís not good for me? Though she was even more adamant about not using the hand sanitizer.

Well, really, neither is good. Antibacterial soap and hand sanitizers are made from synthetic antibacterial chemicals. The most common ingredient in these products is triclosan, a pesticide. Why is triclosan so bad? First of all, it is restricted for use in cosmetics in both Japan and Canadaóalready a tip off to its validity as a hazardous chemical . It is listed as possibly or likely being linked to cancer, endocrine disruption, skin irritation and allergies, organ system toxicity and developmental and reproductive toxicity. A recent study has shown that 75 percent of a cross-section test group of just over 2,500 people had triclosan present in their urine proving its bioaccumulation within the fatty tissues.

And the scary part is that triclosan is found in hundreds of common products ranging from hand sanitizer, makeup and deodorant to toothpaste and shoe insoles. For a list of the products in which triclosan poses a plausible hazard, go here.

This seems like enough of a reason to stop the use of antibacterial soap and hand sanitizer to me. The question is, how to do so. Well, it is just as effective to use any regular liquid soap and water as it is to use these specialized antibacterial ones, and much healthier chemical-wise. Wash your hands with warm water and soap for 15 to 20 seconds and dry your hands with a clean towel and you will kill just as much bacteria . I use Kiss My Face hand soap. It makes my hands feel quite lovely.

Recap: When looking to wash your hands, stay away from unnatural hand sanitizer. Use liquid soap, but not one that is antibacterial. Also, stay away from artificially scented soaps. Your best bet for a safe soap is the personal care aisle of your health food store.

Note to self: To sanitize, stay away from sanitizer.

Lily Berthold-Bond grew up in a chemical-free zone and has struggled her whole life to understand and accept this non-commercial lifestyle. Now a freshman at Tufts University, she has embraced her green life and hopes to share its possibilities with the rest of her generation.

Read more: Blogs, Green Girl Adventures, Hands & Feet, , ,

have you shared this story yet?

go ahead, give it a little love

Lily Berthold-Bond

Lily Berthold-Bond grew up in a chemical-free zone and has struggled her whole life to understand and accept this non-commercial lifestyle. Now a freshman at Tufts University, she has embraced her green life and hopes to share its possibilities with the rest of her generation.


+ add your own
3:52PM PDT on Oct 11, 2010

Yes, Triclosan is VERY bad for you. Want to know why? Read this short but insightful article

Hand washing is MUCH better than anything else. But let's be realistic, and moms can certainly back me up on this one...we're not always in a situation to be around a sink and non-toxic handsoap. Personally, I would much rather use a natural hand sanitizer than use that stinky and toxic commercial handsoap. There are some wonderful alternatives to those toxic hand sanitizers that work exceptionally well. To read unbiased product reviews for CleanWell and Natures Paradise products, go to
These product reviews are written by a MOM on a mission to educate other moms on the health dangers of toxic chemicals at home.

10:31AM PST on Feb 13, 2010

Very informative, article, thanks.

10:57PM PST on Jan 29, 2009

I mix up a liquid hand soap by using Dr. Bronner's liquid castile soap, add water, and put it into one of the foaming pump dispensers. I might add some essential oil to it after reading this. Thanks.

7:49PM PST on Dec 16, 2008

Hmm? The hand sanitizer our local hospitals and Purell use is isopropyl (rubbing) alcohol mixed with a little neutral moisurizer - NO triclosan or triclocaban, so I'll keep using it. Any form of alcohol kills bacteria, so you can even use gin, and that smells wonderful on your skin!

5:10AM PDT on Sep 16, 2008

Great and easy recipe, Joanna. I love it!
Thanks, Dina M.

7:29PM PDT on Aug 26, 2008

hand sanitizers when used a lot strip the oils from your hands that we need for protection

3:39PM PDT on Aug 24, 2008

Wow! Who knew! And I thought using sanitizer WAS better because you don't use water or paper products. But I'm a teen living in her parents house, so I guess I'll have to settle for recommending alternatives and buying stuff when I move out.

Thanks for sharing! I enjoy reading your work.


3:57PM PDT on May 22, 2008

I make my own liquid soap, and add lemon, lavender and/or teatree essential oil to it.

Take one bar of unscented "natural" soap (usually the cheapest type available anyway), and grate into a measuring jug.

Then add boiling water to four times the volume that the grated soap came to, and stir gently. Leave it to cool, giving it a bit more of a stir whenever you feel like it.

Decant into your choice of soap dispenser, adding essential oil to personal preference. (I usually use about 20 drops per 500 mL soap.)

Give a very good shake, and you're done!

I usually get around 2L liquid soap from one bar of plain soap. It smells the way I want it to, does the job, and costs a hell of a lot less than buying the stuff.

If it sets too firm, just give it a really good stir with something like a chopstick. Add a little more water if you need to.

You can also save soap scraps from bath and shower, and grate them.

12:25PM PDT on May 14, 2008

For My Kids All-Natural Hand Wash is good to use when you can't get to soap and water. It uses witch hazel, organic tamanu oil, and organic essential oils.

8:59AM PDT on May 13, 2008

You are so right! Sometimes the smell of harsh chemical cleaners or sanitizers is enough to knock you out of your seat. Honestly, if it smells that bad, it cannot be good for you! I have actually heard people say that if it smells awful, then it must be working...yikes! There are a couple of natural alternatives: I think Burt's Bees makes one and there's another one called Clean Well. And speaking of chemicals, can you believe that there are even some toothpastes that contain Triclosan? 'shudder'

add your comment

Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

people are talking

As a senior recovering from a broken hip here's what I have to say - If you're going to trip, you're…

Thank you for sharing.

Go ahead, test the theory yourself. Offer your cat a bowl of salad and a piece of meat and see what…

Making air biscuits! Very contented kitten....

Thanks for the article. I don't think there is any way I could or would leave my cat and dog behind…


Select names from your address book   |   Help

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.

site feedback


Problem on this page? Briefly let us know what isn't working for you and we'll try to make it right!