START A PETITION 25,136,189 members: the world's largest community for good

Helping Kids Cope Without Antidepressants

  • 2 of 3

The road to recovery
Sofia Wright’s journey back from panic came step-by-step. Driving with her mother to school she practiced relaxation techniques with a handheld biofeedback device, imagining situations that might make her anxious and visualizing how she would handle them. Sofia still feels nervous in some situations, her mother says, but she visits her friends at their homes and recently got on a subway for a class field trip.

“She made a remarkable transformation,” Joyce says. She’s feeling much stronger and has a sense of accomplishment for everything she was able to do. She continues to visualize and problem-solve on the way to school, only now she does it without the biofeedback device. They returned it to Yeaton a few months ago.

Helping kids cope without antidepressants
A growing number of alternative practitioners employ a wide array of techniques to help children suffering from depression and anxiety problems. Here is a quick guide to some of the key approaches these practitioners use to help troubled kids.

First: Assess the problem
The first step in working with a depressed or anxious child is to do a thorough assessment, says Michael Cantwell, MD, a pediatrician at the Institute for Health and Healing at California Pacific Medical Center in San Francisco. He gets detailed information from both children and parents about what the child eats, when and how much he or she sleeps, what’s going on in the family and at school, and when his or her symptoms seem to manifest themselves. “These elements of a child’s life can be critical factors contributing to depression or anxiety but often get overlooked because theyre so basic,” Cantwell says. A lot of kids these days are overscheduled and theyre tired. Thats another cause for depression; some kids just dont get enough sleep.

Diet: Check it, then change it
When assessing diet, one of the first things Cantwell looks at is a child’s protein intake. “While most Americans consume more than enough protein, many kids dont get enough,” he says, “especially in the morning when they need it most.” Inadequate protein can contribute to depression because neurotransmitters are made of amino acids, the primary in-gredient of protein necessary to make these mood-enhancing chemicals. One tip-off that children may not be getting enough protein is if they are sleepy by mid-morning and crabby or very tired in the afternoon, Cantwell says.

Unfortunately, the worst kind of breakfast in terms of triggering depression is also perhaps the most common: one with lots of sugar or highly refined carbohydrates–such as donuts, bagels and muffins–and little or no protein. Cantwell says there is mounting evidence that a high-sugar, low-protein diet can boost insulin levels and deplete serotonin, a virtual recipe for depression in many people.

The general rule of thumb is that growing children need about one gram of protein for every two pounds of body weight. To treat depression, Cantwell suggests as much as double that amount, with one-third to one-half of a child’s protein intake coming at breakfast. Easy sources of protein at breakfast include milk (1 cup provides 8 grams of protein), eggs (1 egg contains 6 grams of protein) and yogurt (8 ounces provides nearly 11 grams of protein).

Cantwell suggests making small changes to a depressed child’s diet, especially at breakfast, by incrementally boosting his or her protein consumption. If necessary, he says, keep a diary of what your child is eating along with notes on his or her mood and behavior. You may notice patterns, and youll be able to review these notes with a practitioner.

Exercise: Get kids moving
There’s plenty of evidence that exercise can ease depression in adults, but exercise scarcely has been studied as an intervention for depressed children. Still many experts believe it is likely to produce the same effect on kids. That exercise has a beneficial effect on mental health for children as well as adults is an attractive, intuitive and widely held notion, write Theodore Ganley and Carl Sherman in a 2000 article in the journal The Physician and Sports Medicine.

What’s the mechanism by which exercise could affect mood and ease depression or anxiety? James Gordon, MD, a psychiatrist and director of the Center for Mind-Body Medicine in Washington, D.C., says that there is good evidence, again in adults, that exercise can cut cortisol levels and boost levels of serotonin.

For these reasons, many alternative and mainstream practitioners will try to get kids to indulge in regular physical exercise. “We always try to get kids on an organized exercise program of some kind as opposed to being really sedentary, which a lot of them tend to be when theyre depressed,” says Tim Culbert, MD, a behavioral/developmental pediatrician and medical director of the integrative medicine program at Children’s Hospital and Clinics of Minnesota in Minneapolis.

Omega-3 fatty acids
Adults who don’t get enough omega-3 fatty acids, found mostly in cold-water fish, are at higher risk of depression. One study of hospitalized depressed patients found they had especially low levels of omega-3s and that their ratio of omega-3s to omega-6s was too low. Why shouldnt the same be true of children, alternative practitioners ask. I almost always recommend omega-3s for both children and adults because its really deficient in our current diet, Cantwell says.

That being said, clear guidelines on dosages of omega-3s have not been established for children. Cantwell recommends that kids under 6 take supplements containing 500 mg of omega-3s a day, in the form known as docosahexaenoic acid or DHA; children over 6, like adults, can take 1,000 mg per day, he says. Culbert also generally recommends omega-3s for depressed children; he advocates 1,000 to 2,000 mg per day. But see your child’s healthcare provider for the dosage best for your child.

  • 2 of 3

Read more: Alternative Therapies, Children, Eating for Health, Health, Mental Wellness

have you shared this story yet?

go ahead, give it a little love

Mel, selected from Natural Solutions magazine

Natural Solutions: Vibrant Health, Balanced Living offers its readers the latest news on health conditions, herbs and supplements, natural beauty products, healing foods and conscious living.


+ add your own
1:59PM PST on Jan 7, 2013

Good article, Rob Waters.

"In Psychiatry no one knows the causes of anything, so classification can be driven by all sorts of factors --- political, social and financial" Edward Shorter, Historian of Psychiatry

"In our increasingly Psychiatrized world, the first course is often to classify anything but routine happiness as a mental disorder, assume it is based on a broken brain or a chemical imbalance, and prescribe drugs..." Dr. Paula Caplan, Psychologist

"Children on these (psychiatric) drugs lose their spontaneity--that which makes them children- The same thing is seen in chimpanzees given these drugs--they "behave" very nicely, not trying to interact with their neighbors and not grooming themselves. Kids are made into similarly good caged animals" Dr. Peter Breggin, Psychiatrist

"(regarding psychiatrists) They're not helping people with drugs. And they're not looking out for harming people. They're ignoring the harm that's coming from all of these drugs" Dr. Norman Shealy, M.D., Neurosurgeon

"They have documented through testing that the IQ has dropped drastically of these children on these (psychiatric) medications" Dr. Ann Blake Tracy, Psychologist

9:16AM PDT on Sep 4, 2010

Good article, but seriously--the elementary and teenage "signs"? How are those different from normal puberty? Who doesn't go through angst, boredom, mood swings (argumentative) during that time?

Drugging children isn't the answer, but parents and the medical industry need to chill out--remember when you were a kid to try to figure out how to deal with your own when they go through their hormonal roller coaster of growing up. It's common sense which adults seem to conveniently forget about (hence I still don't consider myself an adult).Spelling Games

9:51PM PDT on Jul 13, 2010

This is
Cheap retail and Wholesale new hangbag,sunglasse,hat Nike Sneakers, Air Jordan Sneakers, Air Force 1s, Nike Dunks SB, Bape Sta from nike outlets and factory stores, also Nike wholesale - Jordan Shoes wholesale.They wholesale nike shoes: Nike dunks SB, Nike jordan, Nike air force 1s, Nike shox tl nz r4 r5 turbo monster, Nike air max 360 95 97 03 180 90 TN High quality T-shirts,ED hardy t-shirts,ED Hardy hoodies, ED hardy Jeans Plus for cheap with discount.
our price $35shoes,$15tshirt, sunglasess, $16cap,$38jean,$36bag You can see the more photos and the price for our product in our website our website name is in the photos.we have all kinds of brand new shoes,clothing, handbag,sunglasses,hats etc for sale, 8000000% best quality with the cheapest price. ,they are satisfied with our product"



6:57AM PST on Feb 27, 2010


11:58AM PST on Jan 12, 2010

when my son had some problems (due to his father's depression) we found kinesiology very helpful...

10:08PM PST on Jan 2, 2010

kids don`t need antidepressants, they need attentive,understanding and caring grownups in their lives.i was glad i had a lot of good friends who where there for my daughter,when she felt she needed to talk to someone and it wasn`t me she wanted to discuss certain things with.

6:05PM PST on Dec 28, 2009

I wonder if you guys realize just how any people die from antidepressants? How many who manage not to die are paralyzed, heads messed up they need continuous care or who can no longer take any type of drug at all, not even life saving drugs?
I wonder if you realize just how many law suits there are against these drugs.

I sat in on an FDA meeting once. Thousands in the audience, all waiting to tell their story against Prozac. Each one spoke the terrors they had been through. Many where they had found themselves trying to stab, drown or choke their kids. Many who had died and not just from suicide. Kids, where they are now lethargic zombies. I could go on and on but I think you get the gist.
The FDA, a panel made up of rotating Psychiatrists decided there was not enough proof that the drug did nay harm despite additional testimony from doctors. It was later found that each and every member of the FDA had stocks and shares in Eli Lily the makers of Prozac.

3:41AM PST on Dec 16, 2009

Medications given properly, with extreme caution and STRICT monitoring can save young peoples lives.. that is those who are in NEED of medication.
Often times, we have neglected to realize that these meds can intensify actions of teenagers, BEFORE they help reduce depression..etc.
That means the child can carry through with suicdal thoughts with more strength, but he or she is not yet feeling better.
And yes, meds should not be given if other types of treatment are more appropriate.
My deep sympathy for those who have lost family members.
vitamin c

4:51PM PST on Dec 7, 2009

Not according to the Church Of Scientology they don't Katrina T.!! And I'm not saying that You are referring to the Church Of Scientology, Ok? I'm just pointing out the fact that Scientologists don't Believe in the use of Psyciatric Medications.They use Auditing Sessions with an E-Meter instead.And that has helped Me quite a lot more than Psyciatric Medication EVER did!! I mean no offence so please don't be offended,Ok? And stop wasting You're Time with Me Naga C.!!! If I don't want to Believe something,Im NOT going to Believe it no matter what!!

6:09PM PST on Dec 6, 2009

on the other hand, anti-depressants have their uses for certain people's illnesses...

add your comment

Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

people are talking

I wouldn't necessarily classify "junk" as food! Rather, just a lot of sugar, salt and chemicals.

Mmm, nice. Thanks for sharing!

Dimitris, Alaska used to belong to Russia. One of the tsars (I don't remember which one) sold it to …

Story idea? Want to blog? Contact the editors!

Select names from your address book   |   Help

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.