START A PETITION 27,000,000 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x

Is Breastfeeding Vegan?

Is Breastfeeding Vegan?

Parents-to-be hear constantly that “breast is best,” but do vegan parents have to skip breastfeeding to align with their beliefs? Is breast milk vegan?

The short answer to this question is YES. Want the long answer? Read on!

When I was pregnant people asked me frequently about breastfeeding. Is breast milk vegan? It comes from an animal, so obviously not, right? I can see where that logic comes from, but it’s not really that simple. Or, I guess, it’s simple but not in that way.

Related: Breast is Best, But Guilt is the Worst, Vegan Food: It’s Not About Deprivation

Breast milk is vegan, because you’re not exploiting an animal to get it. A new human mother offers her breast milk willingly to her human baby.

To understand why breast milk is vegan, I think we need to look at why cow’s milk is not vegan.

Unlike the human nursing her baby, a cow doesn’t get a choice about whether she wants to express her milk constantly and give it to humans to drink. Instead, female cows are inseminated, and their babies are taken away shortly after birth. Instead of giving her milk to her calf, we take that milk away and bottle it to pour over our cereal and use in our baking.

The difference is all about choice. When a human mother chooses to nurse, that milk is vegan.

What about banked milk?

The follow-up question that I get sometimes after “Is breast milk vegan?” is “Is banked milk vegan?”

If you’re not familiar with milk banks, they are a pretty awesome resource for mothers who aren’t able to breast feed but still want breast milk for their babies. In a milk bank, lactating mothers can donate their pumped breast milk for other mothers in need.

Banked milk is not cheap, which is why when I was unable to breastfeed I opted for baby formula. It was all about cost and had nothing to do with my veganism.

Banked milk is vegan for the same reason that nursing is vegan: a woman donating to a milk bank does so willingly.

Veganism isn’t about purity, it’s about compassion. If the milk comes from a willing donor, it’s vegan. If a cow could walk up to me on the street and offer me milk of her own accord, that would be vegan too.

Human breast milk would not be vegan if it were taken from the mother against her will. So, if you forcibly impregnated me, took my baby, then bottled my milk to sell at the grocery store, it would not be vegan.

One book that really helped me navigate subjects like this during my own pregnancy was Vegan Pregnancy Survival Guide by Sayward Rebhal. The book gives you solid, common-sense answers to questions you’ll get when you’re vegan and pregnant like, “Is breast milk vegan?” She also offers plain ol’ pregnancy advice, and I found the whole guide a big comfort when I was expecting. Recommended!

Read more: Babies, Family, , , , , , ,

have you shared this story yet?

go ahead, give it a little love

Eat Drink Better

At Eat Drink Better, we are passionate about food and drink! Whether we’re talking recipes, food policy, food justice, or anything in between, it all comes back to caring about what’s on our plates and its impact on our bodies, society, and the planet. At Eat Drink Better we accept all food philosophies that are aimed at creating healthier people and a healthier planet. We hope you’ll find recipes and information here to help you eat and drink…better! You can find us on Twitter, Facebook, and Pinterest.

119 comments

+ add your own
8:44AM PDT on Oct 28, 2014

To Timothy S. and to all people insulting vegans saying they are insane because they prefer give soy milk to their baby instead of breastfeeding them, PLEASE BOTHER READ THE ARTICLE FIRST!

It says that YES, breastfeeding milk is vegan, and WHY!

But the worst thing is that you clearly don't even care being right or wrong, all that you care about is bulling vegans as much as you can even if there is no reason why.

8:21AM PDT on Oct 28, 2014

Even though this looks unbelievable, as a vegan I personally faced some people with this kind of questions. These are people who want to do things the best they can, but who obviously missed something in the overall understanding of the cause, or who simply lack solid info from valable sources.
But I don't want to give water to the anti-vegan mill (they will say this is a proof that all vegan people are stupid), I will simply add I also faced many many more omnivore people who couldn't realize that all the meat in their plate was once a living animal.
All that to say, thank you for this brilliant article that explains perfectly this issue.

2:35AM PDT on Oct 22, 2014

Cows need to be milked because they've been selectively bread to produce more milk than her calf would ever consume and she'd die of over milk production.

8:52AM PDT on Aug 28, 2014

No vegan mother would deny her child breast milk because it is officially food from an animal. This sort of question comes from omnivores trying to trip up vegans into admitting that they are not vegan, to give the omnivore an excuse to not bother trying to live a more compassionate life.

2:45AM PDT on Aug 25, 2014

To question if a mother's milk is considered vegan is going a step too far, don't you think?!!

8:54AM PDT on Aug 24, 2014

brilliant!

1:26PM PDT on Aug 22, 2014

Really---
Stupid post

3:29PM PDT on Aug 20, 2014

ok ........... ha ha ha ha ha ha! I didn't even read the article and all
because of the title, mmmmm really??!! hahahahahaha

7:16AM PDT on Aug 19, 2014

Thank you so much!

3:07AM PDT on Aug 19, 2014

OMG .... what a silly idea

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

people are talking

Give to appropriate charities in their names. A donated animal through Oxfam or Heifer International…

Look. It's simple. Big dogs do big damage. I've owned Chihuahuas for years and been bit my them. …

They sound lovely! Thanks.

CONTACT THE EDITORS



Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.