National Geographic Cancels “The Dog Whisperer”

On July 7, 2012, many dog lovers, science-based dog trainers, and veterinary behaviorists will be celebrating the end of an unwelcome era. The Dog Whisperer will air for the last time, after nine seasons of being one of the most popular and controversial dog training shows. I will admit, my tail will be waggin’, but I don’t know for how long. Cesar Millan will be appearing in a new show aptly tilted Leader of the Pack. His website states that the new reality show will be filmed in Spain and it involves families from the UK, the Netherlands, and Italy competing to adopt an ‘unadoptable’ dog and give him a second chance. While I hope this brings public awareness to how many homeless dogs deserve a second chance, I’m also wondering why families are competing over adopting a dog in need. Last I checked, there wasn’t any shortage of homeless dogs needing forever homes.

The controversy over the Dog Whisperer has been due to training methods that are outdated and often misunderstood. The Association of Pet Dog Trainers describes the misconceptions of dominance-based dog training:

“Contrary to popular thinking, research studies of wolves in their natural habitat demonstrate that wolves are not dominated by an ‘Alpha Wolf’ that is the most aggressive male, or male-female pairing, of the pack. Rather, they have found that wolf packs are very similar to how human families are organized, and there is little aggression or fights for ‘dominance.’ Wolves, whether it be the parents or the cubs of a pack, depend on each other to survive in the wild; consequently wolves that engage in aggressive behaviors toward each other would inhibit the pack’s ability to survive and flourish. While social hierarchies do exist (just as they do among human families) they are not related to aggression in the way it is commonly portrayed (incorrectly) in popular culture.”

What Millan does on TV sometimes looks remarkable: an undesired dog behavior is corrected with dominance-based training methods, and a dog emerges whose compliant behavior is acceptable to the humans. What TV doesn’t show you is the long-term results that occur when aversive, dominance-based training methods are used. It’s akin to a child that is fearful when locked in a dark basement. He’ll often yell and cry out of fear. A parent could punish the child and threaten that if he makes another peep, he’d get spanked. Short term, the child will often stop crying, out of fear of being hit. However, the long-term effects are often devastating. The same is true for a dog. A dog can show signs of fear by growling and showing their teeth to another. It’s a warning side that says, “I am not comfortable right now. Please stay away.” It is not a sign of dominance, it is a sign of fear.

Next: What happens when a dog stops giving warning signs of fear?

On TV, Cesar Millan, has been very successful at getting dogs to stop showing signs of fear. But, what happens when a dog is still afraid and they learn that they will feel pain if they show their fear? They stop giving warning signs, and the next time they are fearful, they just bite without warning. I wonder if that can explain why every episode of The Dog Whisperer says on top of the TV screen, “Do not try this at home.”

Personally, I’d rather create a partnership with my dogs than be a leader of the pack and dominate them. That isn’t to say that I don’t have very well-mannered dogs. Sanchez and Gina go almost everywhere with me. They are exemplary canine citizens and I still train every day with them, including Sanchez who is nine years old. The positive reinforcement training methods I use help continually build a bonding relationship and inspires them to keep thinking and learning.

What do you think? Are you a fan of dominance-based or science-based dog training methods? Are you happy or sad to see The Dog Whisperer being taken off the air? Thanks for posting a comment and taking our poll below.

Have you seen the new Adoptable Pets page on Care2? Check it out here! Please also share with your friends. Wed love your help in finding homes for these adorable animals!

 

 

Related:
Positively Dog Training with Victoria Stilwell
Is Dog Training an Animal Welfare Issue?
Are You Always Training that Dog?

278 comments

Carole R.
Carole R.4 months ago

I think Cesar loves dogs and would not do anything to intentionally hurt them. He has done a lot of good and I know his show will be missed.

Elena Poensgen
Elena Poensgen4 months ago

Thank you

Vidal S.
Vidal O.4 months ago

Nine seasons is hardly a fail. It is a celebration. Milan can make a wonderful difference to saving dogs that would otherwise be euthanized.

Shirley Plowman
Shirley Plowman4 months ago

I hope this gets resolved in ways good for the dogs.

Glennis Whitney
Glennis Whitney4 months ago

Great article Thank you for caring and sharing.

Glennis Whitney
Glennis Whitney4 months ago

Bring it back everyone liked it. Thank you for caring and sharing.

Glennis Whitney
Glennis Whitney4 months ago

Sounds like it was a great show. Thank you for caring and sharing.

Julia R.
Julia R.4 months ago

Ceasar is doing much good! I think that there's a lot of dog trainers out there who are looking to bash him because he's been very successful. I don't agree that using some of Caesar's techniques is like locking up a child in a basement all by himself and then threatening to hit him if he cries. This isn't a good analogy! National Geographic isn't cancelling his show, they're just doing another one with Caesar still in it. You have a misleading title here.

S Gardner
sandy Gardner4 months ago

National Geographic: I have always enjoyed your productions, but I don't think you should have canceled CESAR MILAN1

Jenny H.
Past Member 5 months ago

Your blog is really attention-grabbing for me; I will definitely bookmark your website. Thanks Who's Walking Who