Butterfly Rewards - earn free credits and redeem for good causes -  learn more!
my care2
make a difference
healthy & green living: more than 5,000 ways to enhance your life

customize your free newsletter

Customize your Healthy & Green Living newsletter now


Paper or Plastic?

posted by Megan, selected from Yoga+ Magazine Oct 18, 2009 9:13 am
Paper or Plastic?
29 comments

By Mollie Anne Smith, Yoga+

Which is greener, plastic or paper grocery bags?

ANSWER: Neither. A cloth bag is best; used just 11 times, it already has a lower impact.  Paper from trees is a renewable resource, but burdens landfills; 2,000 paper bags weigh 280 pounds. The same number of plastic bags weighs a mere 30 pounds, but polyethylene, made from crude oil and natural gas, uses nonrenewable resources. The EPA says about 20 percent of paper bags gets recycled, but less than 5 percent of plastic ones.

WHY WE CARE: In New York City alone, one fewer grocery bag per person per year would reduce waste by 5 million pounds and save 250,000 dollars in disposal costs.

Yoga+ is an award-winning, independent magazine that contemplates the deeper dimensions of spiritual life–exploring the power of yoga practice and philosophy to not only transform our bodies and minds, but inspire meaningful engagement in our society, environment, and the global community.

More on Green 101 (50 articles available)
More from Megan, selected from Yoga+ Magazine (25 articles available)

29 comments

29 comments

add your comment »
29 comments add your comment
Joey Scully

But a little more into the topic,

paper is decomposible but plastic uses less energy to make, it all depends on what you are more concerned about

maria d.

It's so typical. I have 2 reusable shopping bags made from rafia (not the plastic kind) wich was very normal thing to have here in Spain (where I live) untill few years ago. I take them everytime I go shopping but cashiers keep trying to put my stuff in plastic bags beffore i manage to put them in my own bags. There's a lot of publicity here about using reutilisable bags and even discounts for people who doesn't take plastic ones but then you go to suppermarket and you find this.
Everytime I tell the cashiere I don't need them and everytime she looks at me as if thinking "stupid girl"...

CINDY O.

I am trying my best, by not using plastic or paper bags when i shop, I bring my own bag, what is interesting I remember when I was in Germany in 1990, they were enforcing B.Y.O.B., if you did not, you were own your own.Recently i went to a retail store, telling a young cashier I woant to purchase a bag for a buck, she charged me, but she still used the plastic, I told her I wanted the cloth bag, that I purchased, and she looked at me weird, and say she could not. I really think they need to enforce employees why recycling is important and follow guidelines, Repetition is the best.

Shawn Williams

Hi,
Great post! It’s a pity that people don’t realize the importance of this information. Thanks for posing it.


gingko

cecily w.

I know this is a bit off topic, but ties in with the previous message about telephone books. Last week, I got tired of the phone books taking up room in my minimalist surroundings. On
the chance that I could actually do something about it, I went to the AT&T website--personal/home phone section--and e-mailed a request for information on how I could stop delivery.
Within 24 hours, a rep e-mailed back that she had forwarded the order to stop delivery to the correct department.

Kathryn Queen

Some people are campaigning to reduce the no.of phonebooks in circulation. Ive noticed that our Thompson Local Directory now has unsold advertising space filled with nonsense.Wouldnt it be great if some of that dead space could be used to advise people how to do useful things like recycle waste/save money? What gets recycled is a function of what people know they can recycle. Wasting space in a chunky phonebook is...a waste :-)

Evelyne S.

This gives a good overview of the issue of disposing of trash and what could be done: http://businesspublicpolicy.com/?p=90.

Evelyne S.

Suzanne P, I live in Switzerland and here we have specific plastic bags that you buy at the store that are only to be used for trash. they have a tax incorporated in them and cost clearly more than regular bags. trash cannot be disposed of in regular bags. I think that has people be a bit more aware of what and how much they throw out. are you in the states? I used to live in LA and at the time wasn't aware so much of how inefficient and irresponsible the local way of dealing with trash disposal really is. I wasn't getting any incentive to not be wasting and throwing out anything I wanted, as much as I wanted, in whatever I wanted. Unfortunately, at the time I was myself very irresponsible and didn't care and I am afraid to say I was quite representative of the mainstream household there. I don't know how it is handled in other cities but I think it can't be the solution to just let people trash whatever way they feel like. I'll do some research on trash disposal policies and will try to get back to you with advice, hopefully.

FlookyFribble Artist

Good point Suzanne,

Recycling, Freecycle, and composting everything posibble leaves very little to toss out into the land fills. Keeping a few disposable bags on hand from days the reusables are left at home is always an option, even better if the bag was used several times before or claiming them from a friend or family member who is about to toss some out. It would be a shame to counteract the benefits of reusable totes by purchasing trash bags.

Suzanne P.

I realize that a reusable bag is important and the way to go and do so intermittently, but i also need some sort of bag for trash. I feel paper is far greener, so use the paper bag i get from the store as my trash bag. It then delivers 2 uses.
I wonder what people who are using reusable bags are using for trash?

Please enter your comment.
Or, log in with your
Facebook account:
1500 characters remaining

who's talking about this story?

Disclaimer: Care2.com does not warrant and shall have no liability for information provided in this newsletter or on Care2.com. Each individual person, fabric, or material may react differently to a particular suggested use. It is recommended that before you begin to use any formula, you read the directions carefully and test it first. Should you have any health care-related questions or concerns, please call or see your physician or other health care provider.

1013123

Copyright © 2009 Care2.com, inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved