START A PETITION 25,136,189 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x

Should I Keep My Cat Indoors?

  • 1 of 3
Should I Keep My Cat Indoors?

 

Dr. Justine Lee, PetMD

I’ve talked before about avoiding the “hit-by-car” emergency by keeping your dog or cat under control: either on a leash or by keeping them indoors.† I got a lot of grief from some feline owners and veterinarians when It’s a Catís World Ö You Just Live In It came out. Why? Because I stated my opinion: that cats should be kept indoors.

First, there are several medical reasons for why to keep your cats indoors. Let the statistics do the talking: the average outdoor cat lives to two years of age, while the indoor cat lives to a more geriatric age (approximately 15 to 18). So ultimately, it depends on how long you want to have your cat around.

As a veterinarian, Iíve seen too many cats succumb to the “trauma of outdoor living”: being mauled by dogs, maimed by cars, shot by BB guns, etc., only to have pet owners who couldnít afford to have them treated (resulting in euthanasia).

Next Page: risks for outdoor cats

  • 1 of 3

Read more: Behavior & Communication, Cats, Everyday Pet Care, Pet Health, Pets, Safety, ,

have you shared this story yet?

go ahead, give it a little love

Nicolas, selected from petMD

petMD is a leading online resource focused solely on the health and well-being of pets. The site maintains the world's largest pet health library, written and approved by a network of trusted veterinarians. petMD was founded to inspire pet owners to provide an ever-increasing quality of life for their pets and to connect pet owners with pet experts and other animal lovers. For more information, visit petMD.com.

999 comments

+ add your own
12:33AM PDT on Jul 17, 2014

You're welcome, Lorna. I have 7 cats living on the property (10 acres, half of which is wooded). Two are my own inside cats, both spayed females, and both go outside during the day if I'm outside, and sometimes at night if weather permits and the slider is open. I have a screen door on that with a "doggy door" and both know how to use it. They go only around the house, into the garage, flower beds, etc. and if I go outside, they are usually sleeping on a deck chair, sometimes one might be on the roof. There are 3 that live outside in the garage, two neutered males and a spayed female and I've seen her and one of the males way down the private road that bisects my property, but they don't "roam" in the traditional sense. I keep food available 24/7 out in the garage for them and they have cat beds in the loft. I know I also feed raccoons out there, LOL! At the most, they go about 1000 yards, probably hunting. I've come home from shopping and seen one dart across the road in front of my car and by the time I've parked my car, she's trotting back into the garage.

2:54PM PDT on Jul 16, 2014

Diane L, thanks for your reply. You describe some of your cats as indoor cats but it sounds like they do have access to the garden which is great. When I say neutered cats don't wander what I mean is that if they are neutered males they are not so tempted to wander great distances following female cats and sometimes with the females they get chased by un neutered males when they are in season and get lost in the process, so neutering reduces the distance that they are likely to wander.

11:35PM PDT on Jul 15, 2014

Lorna, well said, but I think I disagree a bit. All of my cats are spayed and/or neutered, and they roam all over my property, which is 10 acres, and a couple go off the property and into the woods as well, but they return home daily/nightly as this is where their food, water and shelter is. I've seen two of my outside (garage) cats cross my private road below where my property line is, but it's thickly wooded and they're obviously hunting. Now as for not defecating anywhere else, that's mainly where I disagree. My inside cats have used my flower beds, and my garden as their litter box, but then it's freshly turned earth and loose bark/mulch and they only know that it's outside, doesn't stink and it's an appropriate "medium" in which to deposit their stuff. One of them, a neutered male, picked a spot where I'd just planted 5 geraniums, and in covering up his "stuff", he almost killed the plant on the outside edge, but I discouraged him from going there by squirting him with the hose and sticking some plant tags (the plastic marking kind) in the bark mulch where he was going.

3:43PM PDT on Jul 15, 2014

Roger, If you feed, care for, vaccinate, microchip and neuter your cats you are protecting them from a) being tempted to take food from strangers, b) protect them from disease c) Use a permanent method of ID. should they get lost - or stolen they can be returned to you), reduce fighting, wandering and unwanted litters by neutering them. c) Its mainly unneutered and feral cats that cause problems with defecation as they use that to mark territory, neutered cats don't cause such a problem. We should also remember animals like cats have a natural instinct for exploration and survival and also thankfully most humans are kind to animals.

With reference to little children, you can't let them wander on their own but they grow up into teenagers and adults. The lesson is you shouldn't confine teenagers or cats because in doing so you limit their opportunities to enjoy life. Gramps may need a little help as he or she gets older but then you might be more careful if a cat is elderly and deaf or blind but then an elderly cat probably won't want to wander far. After all gramps and an elderly cat hopefully have led a full and active life and might be quite content to stay near to home, I know my older cats stayed in the garden but there's no doubt that they still enjoyed the sunshine and chewing on a blade of grass.

2:00AM PDT on Jul 15, 2014

Roger, you're mocking a "bit" I think, but I "get it". Yes, the animal RIGHTS advocates are calling for us all to simply let our companion animals roam "at will" and of course, we're not to keep livestock for any reason. If we have them now, we're to simply open the gates & let 'em be.

1:58AM PDT on Jul 15, 2014

Lorna, I agree with you. I have 7 cats on my property........2 are mostly "indoor" cats, at least at night (or in my case, during the day since I'm a day sleeper) and the screen door has a "doggy door" which they both know how to use when they wish. 3 are 100% outdoor (live in my garage's loft) and they are all 5 years old and older. 2 belong to my daughter and her son and live with them, but also go outside during the day. I'm rural, so no traffic, but other risks. No cat is 100% without any risks, unless kept in a padded "bubble", which I doubt any cat would enjoy.

5:06PM PDT on Jul 14, 2014

Here's the thing. We- animals, minerals, and vegetables, are all in this together...We are the world...So if you think your dear Fluffy, or Fido, or Goldy the Goldfish should be shared, cared for, and fed by your neighbors (good or bad), then by all means let them roam free....

Free to be killed, taken, sickened, or maimed, by someone else. Free to forage for their own food, shelter, warmth or safety...Free to defecate, procreate, or aggregate wherever their free souls, and sentient minds will take them...Free at last!

Why stop there? Let's free the children and aged to share in humanities wonderful largess....Let Gramps or little Todd be nurtured by your entire human 'village'!

After all, We Are The World!

10:37AM PDT on Jul 14, 2014

PS. Dr Justin Lee is WRONG when she says outdoor cats only live about 2 years. I don't know where her practice is but its certainly not near to me!!! All my cats, friends cats, neighbours cats, relatives cats have been outdoor cats and they all lived to 16 years old or more. True they needed to be vaccinated, neutered and micro chipped but any cat should be. True Feral cats which are second generation domestic cats from a stray do suffer more injuries and accidents mainly because they are not vaccinated and neutered and also don't get quality food as a domestic owned cat would. I have also done rescue work in the London area for the last 20 years and one thing I have learned is that cats do have 9 lives! They are wonderful survivors even if they are strays. I have rescued stray mum cats who have given birth and looked after their kittens in gardens and other outdoor spaces. I have also trapped and neutered True Feral Cats. But I have also seen the sad faces of cats kept indoors with only a window to look out on; envious of those cats that have their freedom, can climb a tree, bask in the sun make friends, explor, run, jump and love life. To top it all owners who keep their cats indoors expect them not to scratch furniture. Its like asking us to stay indoors permanently with NOTHING to do. Finally as a vet you would see injuries more often as that's the nature of the job. I also think some vets get so used to confining animals in cages that they can't think outside the box!!!

10:18AM PDT on Jul 14, 2014

Melissa P. I can understand your worry about roads etc; but I live in a city and I have never had one of my cats involved in an accident. You have to weigh it up. Is it fair to deprive your cats of a natural lifestyle because something MIGHT happen. You could just as easily get run over when you go out. Walking on a harness is better than no outdoor freedom but its not the same. Would you like one of your parents trailing around behind you wherever you went? I think the sensible thing to do is to keep them indoors at night and let them out during the day. Once they know the local area they will be a lot safer. Indoor cats that escape are far more likely to get lost or injured because they don't know the area like an outdoor cat would. Also amongst the cats I have had some don't go very far by choice, two of them rarely leave my garden. The others who are more adventurous go further but they are able to cope with that. Microchip them and try not to worry.

1:38PM PDT on Jul 13, 2014

I live in a city and I keep both my cats indoors. I get a lot of flack from other cat owners who think I am being unfair but I cannot bear the thought of coming home and finding my cats hurt or dead on the road. I take them out on a harness every week and I believe that they are happy. Having lost cats on the road when I was little I just could not cope with going through that again

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

people are talking

Snails or slug problem, I put a little cornmeal around each tomato plant and the meal dries them up.…

God ida, you're an idiot.

(Continued from Below) http://www.cbsnews.com/news/study-us-marijuana-legalization-would-hurt-mex…

zinc = mineral :) Have a happy day.

Story idea? Want to blog? Contact the editors!



Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.