Start A Petition

Exclusive Glenn Greenwald Interview: "I Will Not Be Kept Out of My Country for Doing Journalism!"

Society & Culture  (tags: activists, americans, crime, culture, dishonesty, freedoms, government, Home land Security, law, media, NSA, politics, society, violence )

- 1759 days ago -
Glenn Greenwald, the US lawyer-turned-blogger-turned-journalist, has been writing about state-sponsored repression, surveillance, torture and leaks for years. He has four best-selling books but nothing compared to the watershed event in June--->

Select names from your address book   |   Help

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.


Kit B (276)
Monday August 26, 2013, 3:01 pm
Photo Credit: Agência Senado / Flickr Glenn Greenwald

Glenn Greenwald, the US lawyer-turned-blogger-turned-journalist, has been writing about state-sponsored repression, surveillance, torture and leaks for years. He has four best-selling books but nothing compared to the watershed event in June when Greenwald and documentary filmmaker Laura Poitras received a cache of top secret documents from NSA whistle-blower Edward Snowden. On August 21, from his home in Rio de Janeiro, Greenwald described the latest twists and revelations in the NSA spy scandal.

Jonathan Franklin: Your partner, David Miranda, was detained and held at Heathrow airport for 9 hours; all his electronics were taken away, and he was interrogated about your reporting on the NSA. What was the message the US/UK governments were trying to send you by detaining David Miranda?

Glenn Greenwald: That if we continue to report on what the NSA and [the UK surveillance agency] GCHQ are doing, they will continue to target us for all sorts of retribution.

JF: Puts a different meaning to the term "Miranda" warning, eh?

GG: Yeah, it is ironic that he was denied the right to the lawyer; they actually offered one of their lawyers, and he said he didn’t trust their lawyers and wanted his own, and they refused that; so yeah, there is an irony there.

JF: How would you describe this new kind of Miranda warning? Incriminate yourself or else?

GG: It is pretty amazing that they have this law, and in this law, they force you to cooperate with them fully, not just answer their questions but to give them passwords if they ask for that; and then if you don’t [provide passwords], you are committing an entirely separate crime.

JF: [ed. note: Miranda was apparently carrying large amounts of encrypted documents and communications when stopped in Heathrow.] Why are you so confidant the world’s best code breakers can’t break the encryption in [Miranda’s] seized computers?

GG: Because I have read the documents of the world’s best code breakers, and they have talked about their inability to crack certain types of encryption.

JF: How do you think history will remember this whole affair? It is still unfolding but nonetheless, a lot has already gone down. What is Glenn Greenwald’s prediction on the historic legacy of all this?

GG: I think this will be the time the world realizes that the US and its closest allies are trying to build a surveillance system that has as its primary objective the elimination of privacy globally, by which I mean that everyone’s communications electronically will be collected, stored, analyzed and monitored by the US government.

I think it will be seen as the moment that the United States showed its true face to the world in terms of attacks on journalism and their desire to punish anyone who brings transparency.

JF: What precautions would you give to the average internet user vis-a-vis encryption?

GG: I think encryption is vital; I hope that people will use encryption in every way possible. It helps prevent intervening in their private communications, and they should definitely start using encryption.

JF: Is it correct to say that you have taken a crash course on encryption over the past few months?

GG: That is definitely correct to say (laughing).

JF: When you saw Edward Snowden for the first time, and when you saw that baby face, what went through your mind?

GG: Up until that point, I had no idea whether or not this was completely real. I did not know what to expect, and I had seen some documents, so I was pretty certain that it was, that it - but I did not quite know the scope of it or the magnitude. When I saw him, I said there is just no way that he has access to anything nearly as significant as I had led myself to believe he was talking about and that I had probably just flown all the way around the world for nothing. I also contemplated that he was the assistant of the source? Or his son. And would take us to the actual source. That is actually what I started contemplating. It was a definite period of significant disorientation and confusion.

JF: Can you repeat the story about putting your cellphone in the freezer in Hong Kong when you first met Snowden. What is that for? Is it true? Does it work?

GG: The NSA has the capability, which is widely reported, to remotely activate people’s cellphones and turn them into listening devices. Even if you turn your cellphone off, as long as the battery is in it, it will still function that way. You could take the battery out, but I actually had a cellphone of the type where the battery could not be taken out. The only real solution was to leave it somewhere outside of the room but there was no real place we could leave it. So Snowden suggested that we put it in the refrigerator; there, it would be hermetically sealed and there would be no pickup of audio.

JF: Was there a time when Snowden was thinking about turning himself in in the USA? Or going public in the USA? I hear rumors that there was talk of a [Washington, D.C.-based] National Press Club-type appearance?

GG: No, I never heard anything like that. My understanding from the start is that he believed that the US is not a safe place for whistle-blowers, that whistle-blowers cannot get a fair trial in the United States and that he wanted to participate in the debate that he helped to prompt rather than spending the rest of his life in a cage or incommunicado. So I never understood that he had planned to come back to the United States.

JF: You are a US lawyer. You are a world famous journalist. Do you dare travel to the USA? How does that make you feel?

GG: Right at the moment, I don’t have to cross that bridge, because I am writing a book; I am doing a lot of reporting, so I actually don’t even have time to go the US right now. But obviously I am an American citizen, and I haven’t committed any crime. The Constitution guarantees me the right to a free press, and I take all of that seriously. I won’t be kept out of my country for doing journalism. At the same time, the Obama Administration has become notorious for targeting the newsgathering process and trying to criminalize investigative journalism. There are prominent journalists and politicians in the United States who have called for my arrest. Obviously what just happened, with my partner being detained for 9 hours under a terrorism law by the US’ loyal servant in the UK, makes that analysis even a little bit more cumbersome - the idea that there is a real possibility that I could be arrested. I am working with lawyers. I absolutely intend that I will come back to my country when I choose, but I am not going to pretend that I think there is zero risk. There is definitely a risk, and it is less trivial than it was 3 days ago.

JF: You have cracked many a secret at the NSA, but we all think this is just the tip of the iceberg. What are your deepest fears about surveillance and spying? How much more insidious, widespread is this?

GG: The goal of the United States, which they are rapidly approaching fulfilling, is to be able not just to collect and monitor everybody’s electronic communications, but to store them for increasingly long periods of time. They are building a massive facility in Utah that has as its purpose storage of electronic data that they are collecting. They are collecting electronic data in such large quantities that they are incapable of storing it for very long, and they want to make sure that they can keep it for as long as they want. So you are really talking about a radical transformation in what kind of society we have if everyone of our electronic communications is being monitored and stored by this government that operates with very little accountability or transparency for anybody.

JF: What do you find encouraging about the public and international reaction to the disclosures? It is pretty depressing stuff that can keep you up at night, but it has lit a thousand fires in the world. What inspires you? What do you find very positive regarding citizen outrage and public indignity?

GG: I am extremely encouraged. It has actually gone much much better than I ever dreamed in my wildest dreams that it would. There are countless countries around the world in which Edward Snowden is considered a hero and in which there is a raging debate over the dangers of secret American surveillance and the value of internet privacy. Huge numbers of governments have openly defied the orders of the United States . . . beginning with Hong Kong, China . . . now Russia, multiple countries in Latin America. There are opinion polls in the United States that are incredible that show for the first time since 9/11 more Americans are worried about abuses of their civil liberties than they are of the threat of terrorism. You see new coalitions in congress forming against the surveillance state and could place serious limits on it. I think you are going to see more and more people inspired by the acts of Edward Snowden and the people who have tried to help report his documents, knowing that you can stand up to the United States government and to do so in a way that exercises your rights, without fear. I think it is going to have long-lasting implications on all those levels.

By: Jonathan Franklin | Truthout |
Photo: Agência Senado / Flickr)

JL A (281)
Monday August 26, 2013, 3:11 pm
Sad that he is telling it like it is and what the law is yet there are all these robotic systems acting as if it isn't.

Sheila D (194)
Monday August 26, 2013, 7:50 pm
Honestly doubt he'll ever be safe coming back here...the US government has a long memory, especially now. This is one of those situations that seems to be getting overwhelming to me. Note and thank you.

Kit B (276)
Monday August 26, 2013, 7:56 pm

We just can not allow this to overwhelm us, it is just too critical for the future of this country. One does not have to like or agree with Glenn Greenwalt, he is journalist and they keep this an open society.

Sheryl G (360)
Tuesday August 27, 2013, 10:42 am
Exactly Kit, whether one agrees or not with what he wrote, we go from an open society to a closed one if the press can not print or speak out.

We are getting into the next phase of dirty business. I recall Chris Hayes saying that things will not begin to change until the floor starts dropping out for the upper middle class, people exactly like Glennwald. The upper middle class better start doing something or they can keep watching themselves being picked off one by one.

I keep thinking back to those Equality charts, you know the 1% has a line way the heck up there, into the stars and the universe, then there was a line that was still up high, but it only reached the ozone layer. Those are a people that will never get into the stars, and those in the stars are going to make sure they don't.

This system is broken people.......and when the few at the top start to get scared, they get dangerous and it is then they try to shut everyone up and force everyone to remain at the bottom of their boot. The only way is to be in Solidarity, whether you like what he wrote or not, best stand behind your press.

The rest of the press, it also includes the brown nose press, best understand, that just because they have a brown nose doesn't at all mean that they too can't get shafted. When it's a dog eat dog society no one is safe. You are used, abused, in the end spit out.

Solidarity people......

Jamie Clemons (282)
Tuesday August 27, 2013, 1:53 pm
If anything happens to Greenwald we will know who is behind it. Any freak accidents and we will know its the NSA.

Lois Jordan (63)
Tuesday August 27, 2013, 2:08 pm
Noted. Yes, Greenwald is a of the Fourth Estate, and I appreciate all his work in getting this information out to the world. He's been publicly slammed by more than one "of his own"---which is absolutely outrageous to me. Those in charge are striking out because they're truly afraid of the information he has acquired. I'm thankful for the courage of Snowden & Greenwald, and look forward to more intriguing info.
But, our work's cut out for us....we have to press Congress to abolish the Patriot Act---it was wrong then and it's even more wrong now. Without our civil liberties, we aren't a democracy. I agree with Dandelion that the system is absolutely broken.

Esther Z (94)
Tuesday August 27, 2013, 2:18 pm
When a country starts to lose it's democracy, the ones in power first go after the journalists. Makes it simpler to control the country and its people when they're ignorant of what's really going on and false information becomes the norm. What's happening to Greenwald is very distressing, and not a good sign of where the U.S is heading! I agree with Dandelion, seems like the system is truly broken!

Joanne Dixon (38)
Tuesday August 27, 2013, 2:23 pm
The system is indeed broken, anywhere you touch it it is broken - freedom, privacy, the economy, education, public health, on and on. Sometimes it seems overwhelming. Did Dandelion mention to remember November 5?

Mike M (40)
Tuesday August 27, 2013, 3:08 pm
It is all going to plan. The grand takeover to make the world completely under control of one government that is run by the corporations, elites and religious leaders

Past Member (0)
Tuesday August 27, 2013, 5:59 pm

LucyKaleido ScopeEyes (82)
Saturday April 12, 2014, 2:35 am

Democracy Now!, April 11, 2014 VIDEO: Laura Poitras & Glenn Greenwald Back in U.S. for First Time Since Breaking NSA-Snowden Story, giving acceptance speeches at George Polk Awards ceremony-

"Ten months ago, Laura Poitras and Glenn Greenwald flew to Hong Kong to meet National Security Agency whistleblower Edward Snowden. They soon began exposing a trove of secrets about the NSA and the national surveillance state. They didn’t enter the United States again—until today. In this exclusive video, you can watch Poitras and Greenwald speaking for the first time since their return to the country, on Friday afternoon at the George Polk Awards in New York City. They were joined by their colleagues Ewen MacAskill of The Guardian and Barton Gellman of The Washington Post, who shared with them the George Polk Award for National Security Reporting."

(Active Links onsite: "See interviews on Democracy Now! with Laura Poitras, Glenn Greenwald, and all of our NSA coverage.")

- - - - SO, Greenwald was in fact kept out of the US for doing journalism -for nearly a year- and we don't know if he was arrested while on US soil or how quickly he left afterwards, or if, in fact, he stayed... Given that present at the event & joining in the award was a whole table full of Guardian editors & journalists, perhaps the US shied away from an arrest...

Let me specify that these are no ordinary acceptance speeches, of the type you hear at the Oscars. They talk about what they've been through.

And add some related information, also from DN!, which is really VERY shocking: Long Before Helping Expose NSA Spying, Journalist Laura Poitras Faced Harassment from U.S. Agents, from the time she made the first-in-a-series film on post-9/11 US & the Iraq War in 2006. She has been systematically detained & interrogated every time she's flown in or out of the US & had her telephone or computer confiscated.

Also, to demonstrate that we're not all taking this lying down: YouTube, July 2013, uploaded by Noam Chomsky (!) : "In this Surveillance Teach-In, award-winning filmmaker Laura Poitras is joined by computer security expert and privacy advocate Jacob Appelbaum and National Security Agency whistle-blower Bill Binney to present an artistic and practical commentary on living in the contemporary Panopticon."

LucyKaleido ScopeEyes (82)
Saturday April 12, 2014, 2:41 am
Oh, phooey - forgot the link: Democracy Now!, April 11, 2014 - VIDEO: Laura Poitras & Glenn Greenwald Back in U.S. for First Time Since Breaking NSA-Snowden Story, giving acceptance speeches at George Polk Awards ceremony
Or, log in with your
Facebook account:
Please add your comment: (plain text only please. Allowable HTML: <a>)

Track Comments: Notify me with a personal message when other people comment on this story

Loading Noted By...Please Wait


butterfly credits on the news network

  • credits for vetting a newly submitted story
  • credits for vetting any other story
  • credits for leaving a comment
learn more

Most Active Today in Society & Culture

Content and comments expressed here are the opinions of Care2 users and not necessarily that of or its affiliates.

New to Care2? Start Here.