Start A Petition

Sponsors Urgently Needed for ALC Bill to Ban Devocalizing or Silencing

Animals  (tags: animal welfare, animal cruelty, banning devocalizing, animal suffering, legislation, animal law coalition, animal protection, animal advocates )

- 3447 days ago -
Animal Law Coalition has drafted a bill to ban devocalizing or silencing of dogs and cats in Massachusetts except in limited circumstances. In dogs it is called "debarking". A grassroots effort led by 15 year old Jordan Star is underway to pass the

Select names from your address book   |   Help

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.


Simone Duffin (1462)
Tuesday January 13, 2009, 5:04 am
Animal Law Coalition has drafted a bill to ban devocalizing or silencing of dogs and cats in Massachusetts except in limited circumstances. In dogs it is called "debarking".

A grassroots effort led by 15 year old Jordan Star is underway to pass the bill. Rep. Lida Harkins will sponsor it. The bill already has a number of legislative sponsors listed below.

We need your help right now. We need as many legislative co-sponsors as possible. There will be stiff opposition to this bill from puppy millers, cat millers, backyard breeders, hoarders, cruel owners, and the like.

If you live in Massachusetts, please call your state representative and senator. Remember: Ask your representative or senator to co-sponsor An Act Prohibiting Devocalization of Dogs and Cats, sponsored by Rep. Lida Harkins. Get friends, neighbors, family members, colleagues, fellow students to do the same. Legislators need to know we expect them to join their ranks. If you don't live in the state, send this link to someone who does.

Email me at or if your representative or senator asks for more information or a copy of the bill. Animal Law Coalition will post a copy of the bill as soon as it has been introduced.

If your representative or senator is already a co-sponsor listed below, write or call and thank them!

What is devocalizing or silencing?

Devocalizing or silencing is a painful surgical procedure to remove or cut the vocal chords. This procedure can cause paralysis of the larynx, difficulty in breathing, and adverse reaction to anesthesia. An animal may be forced to undergo multiple surgeries because of regrowth of tissue.

The proposed legislation would make it illegal for anyone to surgically devocalize or silence a dog or cat. There are exceptions to protect the health of the animal. Only in rare instances would surgical devocalizing or silencing be medically necessary.

More typically, surgical devocalizing or silencing is a cruel, inhumane act done for the convenience of the owner. It does not address the problem causing the barking such as stress, fear, loneliness, frustration, illness, injury, poor socialization, lack of training, and instead is akin to cutting the vocal chords of a noisy child.

Dogs and cats that cannot vocalize their intentions, moods or needs present a risk to the public and increased liability to pet owners. People may not realize a dog is about to bite or attack, for example, because the dog has not barked, and because he has been debarked or silenced, can only make a wheezy, rasping sound. A dog that cannot bark also cannot signal danger to family members, for example, from an intruder or a fire.

Also, devocalizing or silencing enables illegal activities associated with dogs and cats: Owners trying to avoid pet limits, licensing or nuisance laws may simply debark their pets. Worse, commercial breeders hiding the numbers of dogs or cats they have and the squalid conditions in which they are kept, notoriously rely on surgical devocalizing or silencing. Surgical devocalizing or silencing allows hoarders to go undetected for too long. Dog fighters also use surgical debarking or silencing to avoid detection of their criminal activities.

Making surgical devocalizing or silencing a crime will, in fact, give law enforcement and prosecutors another tool in investigating and prosecuting dog fighting and animal cruelty as well as enforcing regulations for commercial breeders.

Please support this important legislation.

Cosponsors to date:


Ruth Balser

Dan Bosley

Garrett Bradley

Will Brownsberger

Steven D'Amico

Paul Donato

Sean Garballey

Patricia Haddad

Brad Hill

Louis Kafka

John Keenan

Kay Khan

Barbara L'Italien

Pam Richardson

Mike Rush


Scott Brown

Stephen Brewer


Simone Duffin (1462)
Tuesday January 13, 2009, 5:06 am
This is bloody cruel, sadistic, debarking, how about we just go around and cut out everybody's tongues, its no different. I hope this ban goes through.

Kathy W (299)
Tuesday January 13, 2009, 6:09 am
I agree! Just plain sadistic!!! I hope the bans passes also. Enough is enough!
Thank you Simone.
Or, log in with your
Facebook account:
Please add your comment: (plain text only please. Allowable HTML: <a>)

Track Comments: Notify me with a personal message when other people comment on this story

Loading Noted By...Please Wait


butterfly credits on the news network

  • credits for vetting a newly submitted story
  • credits for vetting any other story
  • credits for leaving a comment
learn more

Most Active Today in Animals

Content and comments expressed here are the opinions of Care2 users and not necessarily that of or its affiliates.

New to Care2? Start Here.