START A PETITION 25,136,189 members: the world's largest community for good
START A PETITION
x
3,038,833 people care about Animal Welfare

10 Arguments Against A Vegan Lifestyle

10 Arguments Against A Vegan Lifestyle

There are a whole host of reasons why you should continue to eat meat, dairy, eggs and use products that are derived from, or tested on, animals. Because the arguments that qualify for this list are too numerous to account for fully here, the list below has been limited to just ten of my personal favorites.

ARGUMENT #1:  If we didn’t eat animals, they would quickly overpopulate the planet and most likely starve to death.”

The population of domesticated farm animals in the USA in 2008 is estimated roughly at around 20 billion. This figure is quite small since the actual number of animals slaughtered for food for the US was 10,270,019,000 (that’s: ten billion, two hundred seventy million, nineteen thousand animals).

What this means is farm animals outnumber human beings by a 65 to 1 ratio in the USA.

As it may appear from these statistics, non-human animal populations seem to already be vastly out of control. You might think that to kill these animals would be the best solution since they are already consuming 80% of our corn grown in this country and 60 billion pounds of our soy each year, but unfortunately no matter how many animals Americans kill and eat each year, there continues to be more of them.

The reason for this is quite simple. Animal farmers have intensive breeding operations where they artificially inseminate as many female animals as possible to create even more offspring than the year before. Without giant egg hatcheries and other artificial forms of breeding, animals would never have any hope of reaching, let alone sustaining, current populations.

As far as animals suffering from starvation due to over population goes, the amount of grains and other crops consumed by US livestock is enough to feed 800 million human (animals) who are currently starving to death worldwide.

The argument against a vegan lifestyle stated above could also be reworded to read as “But if we didn’t slit the throats of animals and eat their flesh, they might die horrible deaths.”

ARGUMENT #2:  If we didn’t milk cows, their udders would explode and they would die.”

It is true that if a dairy cow is not relieved of the milk her udders are producing, they can be become so painfully distended and swollen with milk that she may be incapable of walking to reach water or food and, therefore, die.

The reason this is remarkably rare in nature is that bovine animals, like virtually all mammals, only lactate after giving birth or when they have nursing young.

Because farmers want to take milk from a cow who is producing it, they steal her newborn calf from her and instead hook her up to milking machines that roughly simulate the nursing of calves. If a farmer forgets or neglects to milk cows who have had their babies taken from them, the cows will moo their distress from the incredible discomfort.

If farmers didn’t take calves from their mothers, they would suckle naturally every 20 minutes or so and the mother cow would never experience the discomfort and potentially lethal result of underutilized milk.

ARGUMENT #3:  Humans are meant to eat meat.”

Human beings have the ability to consume other animals’ flesh and display the predator characteristics of forward pointing eyes and four sharper teeth called “canines.” Unfortunately this is where the basis for this reasoning ends. 

Human beings’ bodies, by virtually every measure, are intended to eat plants, not flesh. We have flat grinding teeth with jaws that can move from side to side. Virtually no other meat-eating animal has jaws that move side to side, because for animals that eat flesh the possibility of injury is too high in jaws with lateral flexibility, in addition to the fact that meat-eating animals don’t chew their food, but instead tear pieces from carcasses and swallow them whole, and thus don’t need flat teeth.

The canine teeth we possess are dubiously small for any sort of the stabbing all other species use their canine teeth for. It you compare our canine teeth to those of our distant relative gorillas, which are completely vegetarian, you will see that even those gentle giants have canines that outmeasure our own greatly.

Humans have long folding intestines that allow for food to move slowly through our digestive system, which allows our bodies to absorb as many nutrients as possible before the food is passed.

Animals who eat meat regularly have incredibly short intestines because meat may contain harmful pathogens and will putrefy in their guts if not processed quickly.

We lack the proper PH in our stomach acid to digest meat properly without thorough cooking. An animal who eats meat has the stomach PH of less than or equal to 1, whereas plant-eating animals have a PH of 4-5, which is what human beings have.    

This argument can also be stated as “If we weren’t supposed to eat animals, why are they made out of meat?”

ARGUMENT #4:  Humans are more intelligent than other animals and so we have the right to do what we want with them.

Human intelligence has long been cited as justification for any number of actions. It is true that humans display an amazing ability to manifest abstract thought into physical forms, but because measuring intelligence is not an exact science and due to cultural — or in this case species — differences, quantifying intelligence remains subjective. 

Major problems exist with the theory that higher or greater intelligence grants us the right to dominate and consume others though because it provides us with the argument that it is all right to eat human babies and people with mental disabilities because they potentially lack the same intelligence we possess.

The argument of perceived higher intelligence has been used widely throughout history to justify unspeakable atrocities. It allowed for slave masters to dominate their slaves, for pioneers to murder American Indians, for denying woman the same rights as men, for the rape of Nanking and the Holocaust.

This higher intelligence argument is also linked to the argument of humans having larger brains than other species. Unfortunately, this again has a history of justifying extreme racism and sexism.

This argument can also be stated as: “Animals are stupid and deserve to be eaten.”  

ARGUMENT #5:  If it’s wrong to kill animals, should tigers and other predators stop eating other animals too?

Humans have the ability to kill and consume other animals, somewhat like other predators such as tigers, lions and wolves. The obvious difference between humans and true predators is that we lack the ability to kill most animals without the use of a tool of some kind.

Without a gun, trap, knife, club or large rock, humans have a tremendously difficult time killing and eating other animals. Unlike a tiger, which kills with her claws and teeth and can immediately begin eating, humans must fashion a killing and butchering tool first. Even for animals who we can kill with our bare hands such as rodents and birds, we would struggle eating their bodies without a cutting utensil.

The other obvious difference is that carnivorous animals have no choice but to eat other animals. Humans have the ability to live remarkably well without eating the flesh of other creatures.

There are of course human communities who have little or no other choice but to kill and eat animals to survive, but this tends to be limited to indigenous communities living a traditional way of life.

ARGUMENT #6:  Living a Vegan Lifestyle is Too Expensive.

It is true that if you buy pre-prepared and convenience foods, you can spend a large amount of money each month on food. But this is certainly not limited to a vegan lifestyle.

If you compare the price of meat and other animal products against the price of vegetables and grains, you will find that vegetables and grains will routinely be more affordable.

I personally have yet to visit a place where vegetables and grains are more expensive than meat. Having spent time in over 23 countries with very little money and most of my friends being world travelers, I still have not found a place where it was more expensive to be vegan.

Luxury foods such as soy meats, cheeses, and spreads are usually more expensive than their counterparts, but these foods again are luxuries, not necessities. If you compare the price of vegan cheese or meats to organic non-vegan cheeses and meats they are usually comparable.

It is estimated if it weren’t for federal subsidies to the meat and dairy industries, a pound of beef would cost $815 in the US.

ARGUMENT #7:  Animals don’t have feelings.

It is true that we cannot be absolutely sure that what we perceive to be happiness, sadness, love and pain in other species is the same as it is for our own. But any person who has ever spent even a very short period of time with a dog can attest to their ability to feel emotions.

Denying that other animals have emotions much like ours is a great justification for allowing the most unspeakable violence to be committed against them.

Professor Jeffrey Moussaieff Masson said in an article about research done for his book, The Pig Who Sang To The Moon., “A pig could be as devoted, as affectionate, as good a companion, as a dog, given half a chance. Chickens, like many birds, could form close bonds with a human who took the time to get to know these fascinating animals. Sheep, who had been dismissed as stupid animals, turned out to have remarkable discriminating powers, allowing them to recognize, know and have feelings about two hundred other sheep. Goats were as individualistic and as mysterious and complex as cats, and when permitted could live in delightful harmony with humans.”

ARGUMENT #8:  If everyone became vegan, all those farmers would be out of business.

It is true that if humanity was suddenly overcome with compassion and respect for all other animals in such a strong way that everyone would forgo killing other creatures needlessly, a tremendous amount of people would be out of work.

Unfortunately for the billions of animals slaughtered each year, the possibility of a sudden and mass shift to a vegan lifestyle is remote, although still possible.

As more and more people transition towards a vegan lifestyle, the demand for animal flesh and other products will diminish and exploitative industries will either adapt to the new market, or will downsize gradually.

The main issue with this argument is that it can, and was, used to justify human slavery. “What will happen to all those poor plantation owners if we outlaw slavery?”

It was true that slave masters on plantations suffered heavy profit losses when they no longer had a free labor force. Does this mean we should have continued to allow human slavery so that an elite few could go about business as usual?

ARGUMENT #9:  A vegan diet isn’t healthy.

One of the most common arguments against a vegan lifestyle is the fact that vegans are perceived to be deficient in a number of nutrients and vitamins.

Protein, calcium, and vitamin B12 are the nutrients cited as being lacking for those who do not eat animal products.

Pinto beans, which are easily accessible in virtually all of the US, have only slightly less protein than meat, but with no saturated fat or cholesterol. Pinto beans are just one of many legumes and other plants that are high in protein.

Many soy products are fortified with added calcium and B12, which are also readily available.

For those who have dealt with less than ideal health while on a vegan diet, this is usually due to the lack of a balanced diet without enough iron.

The fact that the leading cause of death in the US is heart disease — caused almost exclusively from the consumption of animals — is usually ignored by those who argue the health aspects of a vegan diet.

Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine is a nonprofit group made up primarily of doctors who promote the ethics and health benefits of a vegan lifestyle.

ARGUMENT #10:  If we didn’t test on animals a lot of people would die from unsafe drugs.

Non-human animals have been used for over a century to test experimental medical treatments and procedures for humans. The reasons to justify the use of animals in testing that will not benefit their own species are many, most of which are touched on in the arguments listed above.

The truth is that every single effective medical treatment that has ever come about did not necessitate the use of other animals. Because doctors and scientists are searching for cures to human diseases, to test on another species that does not share 100% of our genes seems to be a flawed science.

Unfortunately, millions of people suffer from diseases that still lack effective treatment, but many of them are more than willing to allow themselves to be used as test subjects to experiment on for cures.

Effective medical treatments are held up for years, or completely abandoned, due to the use of animal test subjects who react differently to drugs and treatments.

For effective and ethical treatments, the use of animals as test subjects should be abandoned.

In conclusion, there are many arguments as to why you shouldn’t care about animals and instead should continue to support industries that exploit and kill them — unfortunately most of those arguments are not logical.

 

Read more: , , , , , ,

Image: graur razvan ionut / FreeDigitalPhotos.net


quick poll

vote now!

Loading poll...

have you shared this story yet?

some of the best people we know are doing it

931 comments

+ add your own
6:12AM PST on Jan 14, 2014

No matter how often we read it this is a great article, excellent in fact. Millions of meat eaters have become vegans and admitted to all that they wished it had happened a lot sooner. When people understand the true meaning of a vegan lifestyle - what compassion and ethics really mean - compassion extended to all beings, not just to humans- when people take the time to fully research the amazing health benefits of the vegan diet and not just google for arguments against it which are biased and false- when people get real and make the commitment to start on this journey and drop all the outdated, worn out ways of thinking .......but all this takes time because humans are very self absorbed and think always of their pleasure and comfort first before that of others - so much so that they convince themselves that it's ok to take the life of another being. Also ask yourself why it is necessary for meat eaters to come here and post comment after comment defending their right to eat dead animal parts and drink the breast milk of another species. It's a bit like mornings. Some people wake up early, and others wake up really late.

5:18AM PST on Jan 14, 2014

Diane L. - your comments are so ignorant that I just want to cry. It just keeps getting worse.

5:08AM PST on Jan 14, 2014

Dale O. - your never ending comments on this subject whenever it comes up on Care 2 shows that you are feeling extremely defensive. In other words, you know that what vegans say is absolutely true.

5:12AM PST on Jan 11, 2014

Uuu

6:18AM PDT on Oct 8, 2013

3 years later Diane? Yet you are still in here complaining about others commenting... How is it okay for you, but something that you get to bitch about if others do it?

What does it really matter the age of the article if the conversation is still live and relevant? Or is it that you are tired of having to come in with your dominance to get the last word in... again, and again?

1:48AM PDT on Oct 4, 2013

True, Diane L, I would not want to eat a dairy cow for any reason, they produce milk. Sandra L, one is always bemused when some vegans serve up the tired old refrain:

“We understand that you are working through some inner problems and need for others to see your anguish as you do so.”

Really, Sandra L? Practicing psychiatry sans licence are you? People who are omnivore are not working through ‘inner problems’ while commenting and the only hostility is often the hostility of those implying that anyone eating meat is ‘angry’ or has ‘inner problems’ simply because we have another viewpoint. You said: “The only "vehemence" is coming from you, Dale O. The real question is why the opinion of others is such a sore topic for you? You can always ignore the "anti-meat eating arguments".

1:47AM PDT on Oct 4, 2013

No, I don’t ignore the statement of others and the last time that I checked, Care2 is still a democracy where people debate the issues. It seems that some vegans believe that they alone are free to dispute what others say, yet when an omnivore does so, then it’s the old …”why the opinion of others is such a sore topic for you” refrain.

Interesting, as some vegans are only too happy to dispute anyone who eats meat. Rofl! So, it is really a question of one standard for some vegans who comment whenever they see someone in favour of eating meat and another standard of ‘just ignore what we say’ for everyone else. Sure, I catch your ‘logic’ Sandra L, anyone disputing a vegan is always ‘vehement.’

11:23PM PDT on Oct 3, 2013

THREE YEARS later, and vegans are still saying the same things. I have to give you credit for one thing, if nothing else..........persistence!

Genoveva, what you're missing is that we also all have a right to live, ourselves, and some of us realize that killing something is necessary for us to do that. If it's not an animal, it's vegetables............once picked or removed from the ground, the plant dies. Plants kill to survive as well. In fact, nothing living exists without consuming something else in some way.

9:09PM PDT on Oct 3, 2013

"Every animal has certain fundamental rights, and the very basic fundamental right of every animal is the right to live. For you cannot take away what you cannot give. And since you cannot give life to a dead creature, you have NO right to take away the life of a living one."

11:41AM PDT on Oct 2, 2013

As a vegetarian, i've seen all the videos and read articles against meat eating and meat and dairy industries... and i have to say, i wish i had read this sooner, it just made me even more convinced...
So tell me, we are smarter so we have the right to do whatever we want? So, we are smarter than a 3 year old so we can beat them? ok, an extreme example, so i'll try something else: responsability. no? it's BECAUSE WE ARE SMARTER that we should start acting more like it and protect de weaker, not kill them.
And... animals don't have feelings? I don't believe that, but if you do, whatever... the thing is, most meat eaters use pleasure as an excuse to eat meat (as if that justified killing). Everyone can agree that animals feel that too right? And pain, and cold and desperation from spending their short lives trapped in a box? So even if you are cold as to believe that animals don't have feelings when you look into your dog's eyes while you pet it's head, it's obvious they can feel pain.
Now you tell me "but i don't eat dogs". Makes sense. Now tell me what's the difference between what you see in their eyes and in a cow's. Because to eat meat whithout guilt, you either don't think about it or you don't see anything there.

Sad, really... but i loved the answers (it's been said, i know)

add your comment



Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the author and may not reflect those of
Care2, Inc., its employees or advertisers.

ads keep care2 free
Story idea? Want to blog? Contact the editors!

more from causes




Select names from your address book   |   Help
   

We hate spam. We do not sell or share the email addresses you provide.